4 ms·
T-Mobile cites SCOTUS Chevron ruling to argue FCC can't mandate phone unlocking
- hindsightbias 2y agoI wonder how many of the things important to you are going to be Chevroned.
- themaninthedark 2y agoDoes the law allow the FCC to mandate unlocking? If not, it doesn't matter how important it is to me if it is illegal. There are many things that I think would be great for the government to mandate; free food for those who can't afford it. However, that would be the government just taking from companies with out payment and be illegal. Furthermore, if the government can just mandate that a company do something, they can also mandate the individual do the same. Congratulations, your house is now a soup kitchen.
- falcolas 2y agoYes, the law did allow the FCC to mandate unlocking. They were given the ability to write regulations - which are a form of law - on behalf of Congress within their stated mission. Just as, to use your food analogy, the FDA wrote regulations that make it illegal for companies from selling you rotten meat.
- themaninthedark 2y agoHere is part of the Act that gives the FDA power to mandate food safety: >IV. Food There is a distinction in food adulteration between those that are added and those that are naturally present. Substances that are added are held to a stricter "may render (it) injurious to health" standard, whereas substances that are naturally present need only be at a level that "does not ordinarily render it injurious to health Broadly, the FCC is mandated to: >make available so far as possible, to all the people of the United States, without discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, or sex, rapid, efficient, nationwide, and world-wide wire and radio communication services with adequate facilities at reasonable charges. But I don't see anything in there that say they have the ability to mandate unlocking. You can argue that it falls under the "adequate facilities at reasonable charges" portion. I certainly want the ability to unlock my device but is the FCC mandate legal or not?
- falcolas 2y ago> But I don't see anything in there that say they have the ability to mandate unlocking. That's because cell phones didn't exist when the FCC mandate was created. So no, you won't see cell phones (or attributes of cell phones) explicitly mentioned. That said, cell phones are radio communication devices, which is something the FCC does indeed regulate. They have long history of regulating the manufacture and operation of such devices. Vendor lockin included (something that ATT tried and was swatted down for with landline phones). And let's be honest, Congress has had decades to narrow the mandate of the FCC if they believed they were misbehaving when it comes to cell phone regulation. The FCC operates on behalf of congress, after all.
- themaninthedark 2y agoI would not expect to see anything that says cellphones or the like, I would expect to see something that allows them to mandate the kind of communication equipment or characteristics of the communication equipment. We had landlines for a long time before cell phones and the phone company was AT&T. They didn't allow a customer to buy another phone and hook it up to their network, you rented it from AT&T. At some point that changed, I don't think AT&T gave that up out of the goodness of their heart. It was probably from a FCC mandate or law, which would in turn give the FCC ground here. If not, then it is and oversight that should be corrected.
- orra 2y agoIANASC but IMHO “efficient” grants power, in addition to the “adequate facilities at reasonable charges” you mentioned. Remember, Congress can ban you from growing weed in your own garden and for your own consumption, on the basis that indirectly affects the interstate price. I think that the FCC regulating cellular modems is way less of a reach.
- themaninthedark 2y agoI think that is a reasonable argument, I had a similar thought when I copied the text out. >Remember, Congress can ban you from growing weed in your own garden and for your own consumption, on the basis that indirectly affects the interstate price. It was feed corn during the Great Depression, I have always thought that ruling was bullshit(I understand the end goal) but anyone is welcome to try and change my mind :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn It basically opened the door for the Federal government to try and stick their hands in everything, for good and bad.
- deepfriedchokes 2y agoSounds like rotten meat is back on the menu.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gnulinux 2y agoIt was only a matter of time. I have a feeling -- not being a lawyer and not intimately knowing the US Law -- that the whole legal structure of the Federal Government will soon experience a tremendous shift. Alphabet agencies will stop having any kind of authority that the Judicial Branch never approved of. It will completely shatter everything we know about the feds, from drug regulations (FDA et al), to communications (FCC et al), to stock market (SEC et al), to worker/consumer rights (FTC et al), to immigration (USCIS et al)... There will be a period in the US history where no lawyer will be sure how anything can be relied on anymore because there will be this giant free real estate the Judiciary Branch can make precedents on whenever they want. When congress passed laws to create these alphabet agencies, they thought they're assigning some amount of authority to them to "regulate", and they thoughts these unelected bureaucrats making up laws -- instead of the glacier slow Congress -- will let Congress off the hook. But they didn't realize that the Judicial Branch would ultimately see it as an existential threat to them -- because the authority to "interpret" law belongs to the Judicial Branch and not the Executive Branch -- and thus by doing so, they actually wrote a blank check to the Judicial Branch (ruled by another set of 9 unelected High Priests) to eventually determine all these things for the Congress. It's gonna take the Congress an unprecedented megaproject to take these powers from the Judiciary and exactly define each law as elected Congress sees fit. I hope I'm tremendously wrong, but I'm expecting Armageddon-level legal change to soon follow in this country.
- themaninthedark 2y agoRight but it is not all as bad as it seems. During the pandemic, we saw government agencies mandating all sort of things that seemed very out of scope for the agency. For example the CDC was dictating to landlords that they could not evict anyone: https://www.politifact.com/article/2021/aug/04/cdcs-new-eviction-moratorium-it-legal/ https://www.politifact.com/article/2021/aug/04/cdcs-new-evic... There was no legal basis for this, a very good human one but you can't run a country on what we feel is best at the time. That is how we end up violating human rights.
- falcolas 2y ago> There was no legal basis for this I pointed this out in a separate comment, but there is absolutely a legal basis for this. The CDC is the Center for Disease Control (emphasis on control), and so it's absolutely in their mandate to make regulations that prevent the spread of infectious diseases. > you can't run a country on what we feel is best at the time I hate to say it, but this is exactly how the country is run. "What is the best course of action?" "Put us on that course of action." Whether done with laws, orders, regulations, court mandates, etc that's exactly what we do.
- brodouevencode 2y agoThe removal of Chevron deference isn't the harbinger of doom everyone thinks it is: this standard is only 40 years old.
- falcolas 2y agoThe combination with a different decision to remove the statute of limitations for new companies on old regulations does indeed make this a bit of a "doom" scenario. The courts are already backing up with these lawsuits, and it's going to only get worse. It won't stop agencies from creating new regulations, but it's going to make enforcement depend entirely on the court that the lawsuits are filed in, and how backed up their caseload is. The US isn't the same as it was 40 years ago.