3 ms·
The first article you link actually suggests, sort of indirectly, that NYC is an example of a place with successful rent-stabilization. The article argues that
by _delirium 14y ago
The first article you link actually suggests, sort of indirectly, that NYC is an example of a place with successful rent-stabilization. The article argues that the reason NYC hasn't been destroyed by rent control is that it liberalized rent control into the more flexible rent stabilization (which allows market-driven changes, just within certain year-to-year rate limits), which mitigated the worst problems of rent control.
I don't really have a worked-out position on the question, but I'd tentatively think that stabilization that doesn't amount to de-facto freezes would avoid some of the worst problems, since prices would track the market, just with a lag, as opposed to never doing so. For example, the problem with CA's Prop 13 isn't that it limits the y-on-y assessment increase for property-tax purposes, but that it limits it to 2% per year, not accounting for inflation, which is such an absurdly low limit that assessments will never track market prices, even in a delayed sense. Esp. since in years with >2% inflation it actually mandates a cut in real valuation. (Also, if I had my way, I'd remove the inheritability of rent-stabilized rents and Prop-13 valuations, to avoid any weirdness crossing generational lines.)