4 ms·
I think there should absolutely be a rent stabilization law -- everywhere Do you think this on the grounds of economic theory? The empirical finding is that re
by tokenadult 14y ago
I think there should absolutely be a rent stabilization law -- everywhere
Do you think this on the grounds of economic theory? The empirical finding is that rent control laws limit the supply of rental housing unduly wherever they are enforced. What's a successful example of a place with a "rent stabilization law"?
http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html
http://econjwatch.org/articles/rent-control-do-economists-agree http://econjwatch.org/articles/rent-control-do-economists-ag...
- michaelochurch 14y agoRent stabilization (if applied fairly; New York's 1947-era rent control doesn't qualify) is a good thing, but it's a temporary fix. It's only one part of the solution, because it doesn't do anything to fix an intrinsic shortage. More necessary is taxing landlords and owners of large amounts of real estate (anyone owning real estate at more than 12 times the average pre-tax income in an area qualifies) at very high rates and using the funds to build the best public transit system in the world-- a long-term solution that obviates the need for stabilization in the first place.
- _delirium 14y agoThe first article you link actually suggests, sort of indirectly, that NYC is an example of a place with successful rent-stabilization. The article argues that the reason NYC hasn't been destroyed by rent control is that it liberalized rent control into the more flexible rent stabilization (which allows market-driven changes, just within certain year-to-year rate limits), which mitigated the worst problems of rent control. I don't really have a worked-out position on the question, but I'd tentatively think that stabilization that doesn't amount to de-facto freezes would avoid some of the worst problems, since prices would track the market, just with a lag, as opposed to never doing so. For example, the problem with CA's Prop 13 isn't that it limits the y-on-y assessment increase for property-tax purposes, but that it limits it to 2% per year, not accounting for inflation, which is such an absurdly low limit that assessments will never track market prices, even in a delayed sense. Esp. since in years with >2% inflation it actually mandates a cut in real valuation. (Also, if I had my way, I'd remove the inheritability of rent-stabilized rents and Prop-13 valuations, to avoid any weirdness crossing generational lines.)
- ubernostrum 14y agoYou seem to be conflating "rent control" and "rent stabilization", which are two different things. Also, these economists appear to be ignoring a simple practical matter. The idea behind most rent regulation is to avoid pricing low-income-but-necessary-to-basic-function people out of an area. These are, basically, the garbagemen and janitors and cooks and such, who can quickly find themselves priced out of anything within a reasonable distance of the city. This results in a corresponding shortage of those services in the city, and prices for those services increase until even the wealthy -- who can still afford the higher rents -- are not willing to bear those costs to remain in the area, and begin leaving. This can happen surprisingly quickly. In modern environments where many lease agreements come up for renewal at essentially the same time, it can happen frighteningly quickly, far more quickly than new construction can hope to "correct" the housing shortage.
- planetguy 14y agoThat's the stated justification. The real reason is that politicians of certain stripes enjoy redistributing wealth from the landlord class to the tenant class and getting rewarded with votes for it, so the stated reason is disingenuous anyway, but let's examine the stated reason carefully. Has this ever actually happened? Has any city ever run out of garbagemen and janitors due to a lack of rent control? I have never heard of anything like this happening, even in extremely expensive cities with free rental markets.
- articwombat 14y agoYes, this happened in San Jose during the last bubble, when Firefighters and Police couldn't afford to live in the city. Who on minimum wage can afford to drive a car for an hour to work each way?
- kemiller 14y agoSo they should be paid better, and the burden spread among the constituents of those services. Not pinned on landlords.