3 ms·
I don't think they're prohibiting dense housing per se, just not approving/building enough of it. There have been several 50-story condos opened in the past few
by _delirium 14y ago
I don't think they're prohibiting dense housing per se, just not approving/building enough of it. There have been several 50-story condos opened in the past few years, and several more currently under construction, but they're not enough to keep pace with growth in demand. It didn't help that there was a ~2-year lull in construction when a bunch of developers got into financial trouble during the financial crisis and had to put projects on hold. It's not as if SF isn't dense; it's the 2nd-densest city in the country, and way-way-way ahead of local peers San Diego and Los Angeles.
I agree on public transit, but it's not clear what to do about it. An east-west Geary subway line has been proposed since the 1930s, but it's really expensive to build in an earthquake zone, and the city / taxpayers just haven't been willing to pay what it'd cost. A cheaper alternative that leverages the already-built infrastructure might be to convince people to live in under-developed areas that do have good transit already, such as Oakland, which is actually closer to downtown SF by transit-minutes than much of SF proper is.
One thing that would help on the latter issue is if more of the suburban cities on transit lines also dropped their anti-development attitudes. For example, there is enough demand that there should be condos/apartments near the Palo Alto Caltrain station. But Palo Alto won't allow it, because they have some idea of an upper-class suburb full of single-family homes that they'd like to protect.
- planetguy 14y agoInstead of a subway line, would it be possible to close off one of San Francisco's many east-west streets (Geary if you like, probably a couple north-south of there would be better) and run a light rail line (using Muni Metro or similar cars) on an east-west route? You could adjust the timing of the traffic lights to ensure that the rail line always (or usually) has priority and cross the whole city in ten minutes.
- _delirium 14y agoThere's a plan currently under discussion for bus rapid transit on the Geary corridor, which is sort of the el-cheapo version of that idea (http://www.sfcta.org/content/view/37/70/ http://www.sfcta.org/content/view/37/70/). Give the bus a dedicated, physically separated lane to reduce traffic problems, and build light-rail-esque, less frequent stations in the median with level boarding. Not a full solution, but the hope is that it'll raise the average bus speed significantly.
- planetguy 14y agoI hope they plan to raise the average bus quality too; riding Muni is less like public transport and more like a homeless shelter. I couldn't imagine doing it every day.
- 1234the1234 14y ago> riding Muni is less like public transport and more like a homeless shelter. Douchebag alert. Sorry regular people interfere with your nerd boner. Edit: See what I did there, I mocked you for being a "nerd". Really just different from me. See, it sucks when people stereotype you as homeless or whatever you don't like because you don't scroll & pinch their way home everyday.
- mc32 14y agoI really think both the Geary and Van Ness corridors need at least a monorail to handle the capacity. BRT seems like a band-aid, to me. Of course, it's cheaper and quicker to deploy. Long term, though, if they build the Geary corridor as envisioned (dense housing) then I think something like monorail would be suitable.
- quesera 14y ago> You could adjust the timing of the traffic lights to ensure that the rail line always (or usually) has priority and cross the whole city in ten minutes. Not if you wanted to pick up or drop off passengers. :) But I've ridden N-Judah, and not loved it. Unless it's elevated or subterranean, it's going to be slow.
- mc32 14y agoI believe there are some political issues (neighborhoods decrying the loss of "Old SF") in addition to somewhat onerous (compared to SJ) planning requirements, specially north of Market (where no building shadow shall impinge on a public park during the hours of 10am to 4pm or something. Developments typically appease the loud-voiced locals by either pulling out of development plans or modifying their original proposals to lower heights (and thus lower density). It seems some voices SF, while urban, would prefer to keep SF a quaint victorian town. I mean, we're in the 21st century, allow the city to grow like a city.
- thwarted 14y agoAn east-west Geary subway line has been proposed since the 1930s, but it's really expensive to build in an earthquake zone, and the city / taxpayers just haven't been willing to pay what it'd cost. That hasn't stopped the MUNI subway expansion north under 4th Street and Stockton. http://centralsubwaysf.com/ http://centralsubwaysf.com/