6 ms·
Europe's deadly floods are glimpse of future climate
- sylware 2y agoSome areas may become inappropriate(lethal...) for housing. A lot of people may have to be moved, not to mention the amount of new housing to build. Some states should have a lot of spare housing and keep it available... because because once they need it in a kind of urgent matter...
- Sakos 2y agoAs long as housing is considered a financial instrument and problems like NIMBY and overly restrictive zoning continue to persist, none of this will happen.
- sandworm101 2y agoOr housing can be modified to tolerate the occasional flood. Lives can be saved through better prediction and quick evacuation. The economic impact of regular repair and recovery may be less than abandoning such areas.
- sylware 2y agoprediction and quick evacution is AI hallucination grade. People died with flash floods, and it is worse if happening in the middle of the night, not to mention in the "middle of nowhere".
- dredmorbius 2y agoIt is insanely difficult to construct general-purpose housing which can withstand metres-deep water flowing at high rates. All the more so where flooding is combined with landslides, debris flows, washouts, sinkholes, and the like. Prediction and advanced warning helps considerably, but is itself problematic where storms intensify rapidly and threaten a huge area. This has been the case for several recent European flood events, most notably in the Ahr valley in 2021: <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/13/floods-then-and-now-photographs-germany-ahr-valley-flooding-disaster-july-2021 https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/13/floods-then-an...> As I write, Hurricane Helene, a tropical depression just a day ago, is intensifying in the Gulf of Mexico and threatening landfall on a region which spans from Alabama to the Florida peninsula (though the panhandle / Big Bend region seems most likely). The storm is anticipated to further intensify to major hurricane status (category 3 or higher, winds from 178 -- 209 km/h, 111--130 mph, or higher) before making landfall tomorrow evening local time. That's a huge area which faces possible evacuation. The more so as despite the localised nature of the hurricane eye, Helene's total diameter is huge, and tropical storm or better wind speeds are forecast from Louisiana to South Carolina, and encompas all Florida and Georgia, along with nearly all of Alaabama and South Carolina, as well as parts of Mississippi, Tennessee, and North Carolina. The one saving grace is that the storm seems to be moving rapidly and won't linger over any one area for long, though I suspect that river systems in the southeast will see much flooding. Forecast cone for eye location: <https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/refresh/graphics_at4+shtml/213335.shtml?cone#contents https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/refresh/graphics_at4+shtml/213335.s...> Forecast wind speeds: <https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/refresh/graphics_at4+shtml/213335.shtml?tswind120#contents https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/refresh/graphics_at4+shtml/213335.s...>
- cpursley 2y ago[flagged]
- toenail 2y ago[flagged]
- DataDive 2y ago[flagged]
- llamaimperative 2y ago> The World Weather Attribution (WWA) group said one recent four-day period was the rainiest ever recorded in central Europe
- DataDive 2y agoStatements like the above are what should give everyone pause. I think that statement can't be true. Detailed measurements exists for less than a hundred years - yet the WWA is cock sure this is the highest rainfall ever. It goes to the credibility.
- llamaimperative 2y agoWhat do you think "ever recorded" means? I'll take a stab: "the most rain we could find credibly recorded in the data we have currently available to us." If you have other data you should consider sharing it with them.
- ben_w 2y ago> They act as if natural disasters never happened before. https://xkcd.com/1321 https://xkcd.com/1321 > then start using coal to replace the missing energy s/start/stop/g https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41443347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41443347
- ch_sm 2y ago
- blueflow 2y ago[flagged]
- adityaathalyo 2y ago[flagged]
- latexr 2y agoThis is what was defined by Daniel Dennett as a deepity. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Deepity https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Deepity
- hfalka 2y ago[flagged]
- wiz21c 2y agoFTA: "Central Europe's devastating floods were made much worse by climate change" There are always been floods. But now they get worse. How much worse ? I don't know. And as another HNer said, land management has its part in this too...
- john61 2y ago> There are always been floods. But now they get worse. How much worse ? I don't know. From the OP: "But if warming reaches 2C, similar episodes will become an extra 5% more intense and 50% more frequent, the WWA warned."
- DataDive 2y agoBut if you look at the number-crunching process that gave you those percentages, it turns out to be woefully fragile and sensitive to a whole range of other factors Countless prior models were completely off, but this one is suddenly correct and needs to be treated as a reliable predictor. The problem is that if you dare to question the accuracy, you are immediately labeled a "denier." The only acceptable answer is that no matter what the prediction is, if it is alarmist, it is correct.
- llamaimperative 2y ago> The World Weather Attribution (WWA) group said one recent four-day period was the rainiest ever recorded in central Europe Surely you have data ready for peer review that contradicts this group of scientists?
- kdlaq 2y agoThe comment you replay to literally praises the fact that we have rain again, as opposed to several almost arid climate years in Europe. Remember when the rivers were too dried up in France for the nuclear plants to function? Then everyone said that due to climate change we'd soon have an arid climate in Germany. So, according to "peer reviewed data", we go from an arid 2020 to rain forest 2024 in just four years due to climate change. Remarkable.
- blueflow 2y ago[flagged]
- HenryBemis 2y agoFrom (father being a fireman/worked in many search and rescue operations). TL:DR from a fireman: My father has always been saying "water will find a way". As progress+civilization expand, there is less and less free/open ground. Roads, parking lots, shopping centers, more roads, train tracks (elevated = blocking water), rivers being covered, fires, etc. Water doesn't care, it wants to go through - it will go through. In the "good old days" it would rain X amount up on that mountain, and 10% of X amount will find its way towards your town. Now, burn that mountain, then add 50 roads/highways/etc. Now 40% of X amount will find its way towards your town. By the way your town has 30% less free ground (roads, parking lots, etc.) Thus, floods. You can (rightfully so) poke 100 holes on the above, because each town/village/mountain/river is different, but the point/spirit remains. "Water will find a way". EDIT: I am always fascinated to read in the news that the (e.g.) "Old lake" flooded again after 30 years". Guys!!! The name of the location is "Old Lake", which means that for about a couple of million years water has been converging there. The fact that some people built there, doesn't Water/Nature from doing its thing.
- hyperman1 2y agoI saw a report on the Schelde river. The total amount of water transported per year is not changing. But the difference in volume varies much more than it used to. We have longer periods with lower water heights, and more extreme heights on peak days. This means a few things: Salinity of the sea perpetrates deeper on land. The risk of drinkable water buffers getting depleted grows. The risk for flooding rises.
- blueflow 2y agoCentral Europe is in recovery from widespread deforestation. The regrowing forests act as a increasing buffer, weakening floods, overshadowing the effects of climate change.
- 2y ago
- piva00 2y agoWhat's up with so many Hacker News commenters coming out of the woodwork when headlines blame climate change to challenge it? Just a glimpse of the article shows there's some research behind making the point of the headline, still people feel the need to comment on their feelings to deny it possibly could be due to climate change. Per the article: > The World Weather Attribution (WWA) group said one recent four-day period was the rainiest ever recorded in central Europe - an intensity made twice as likely by climate change. > The kind of rainfall unleashed by Boris is thankfully still rare – expected to occur about once every 100-300 years in today’s climate, which has warmed by about 1.3C due to greenhouse gas emissions. > But if warming reaches 2C, similar episodes will become an extra 5% more intense and 50% more frequent, the WWA warned. > Without more ambitious climate action, global warming is expected to reach around 3C by the end of the century. > “This is definitely what we will see much more of in the future,” said Friederike Otto, senior lecturer in climate science at Imperial College London and co-author of the WWA study. There's a study, BBC is reporting on it and some people feel the need to challenge it even though probably know nothing of climate science? Is science denialism reaching even folks here? What do you get out of this behaviour?
- pjc50 2y agoHN audience is both reflexively contrarian (will argue with any article on any subject), and also surprisingly rightwing (exposed to climate change denialists).
- alephnerd 2y agoThere is a surprisingly vocal and toxic community that are fringe members on both sides of the aisle on HN. Hypothetically a good thing, but in action it tends to derail most conversations. The whole COVID Pandemic, the 2020 election, (edit: and the shutdown of SlateStarCodex) definetly brought a lot of nuts out of the woodwork, and they never left. Edit: Here's an example below. It's one account that I've had significant arguments with before. In addition, it's also a "new" (post-2021) account, ime all of whom don't tend to provide the level of discourse comparable to earlier HN users (yes, I recognize the irony as a combative newish throwaway) There was a large increase in HN usewebase around that time when the SlateStarCodex forum shut down.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pvaldes 2y agoI still think that all those oil and weapon depots exploding relatively close to Poland, the Czech Republic, Romania, Austria and Italy have something to say here. Hot clouds travel far away in no time and a similar stormy behavior has been seen lots of times in pyrocumulus from big wildfires before.
- kkfx 2y agoFew notes as an European NOT concerned by floods while being born in a relatively flood prone area: it's not about climate change but people who do not want to change. In the very past our ancestors have chosen settlements prone to floods sometimes, BUT with clear water available regularly because back than there was no effective pumped aqueduct and the need for clear water was the same than today, while the impact of floods was sometimes MUCH LESS than today: for instance many old homes was built of two-story with the ground level used only for animals or tools, in case of floods foods was kept at the first level and hay for livestock under the roof. In case of flood anything who suffer water wast dry, animals are easy to moves and steel/wood tools does not suffer much; today car's do not like being flooded and are not as easier to move as livestock in nature back then, we have electricity who not like water as well and so on. Long story short, it doesn't matter if floods are more frequent or more powerful, our society have changed so our needs are different and we change homes and their location accordingly. This is a thing most people here reject vehemently. I have friends flooded multiple time, they can relocate economically alone as I do, they have no special constraint not to do so, but they refuse, they cry against the government, weather, anything else, they waste money to restore anything and keep going refusing the fact that when their ancestors have chosen a specific place there was different needs than today. Similarly at less urgent level: back then zones with little circadian thermal variations was preferred because there was no cheap heating, so it was better for human health to be in a moderately change temperature than in a quickly change one every day. Nowadays where it's hotter in summer and we have p.v. and effective insulation it's much better for us living with large daily thermal delta because nights where we do not have p.v. we do not need to cool homes, and even if night are even cold it's not an issue thanks to insulation, while during the day we get "free" A/C with local p.v. Back than being near the sea was nice because yes, sometimes the sea invite itself inside the home, but every day we can go fishing with less time and efforts. Nowadays we can cars, roads etc being so near a certain place it's still useful sometimes but much less demanding than before and avoid salt and chlorine corrosion, submersion etc is much more important. To going straight to the point: the world have always changes, civilizations have fallen because of that, it doesn't matter if today it's faster than ever or not, and it does not even matter much the various causes because the current climate change impose to adapt, AFTER such monumental effort we could discuss about how much we can mitigate the effects if we can or not. To implement the new deal we need anyway to rebuild anything because we can't on scale converge to electricity homes not designed to be heated with little energy, we can't generate enough, anyway aging infra and homes demand the same. It's not so "urgent" that anyone have to find a new home tomorrow, but it's about time to start discussing how to mass relocate food productions and people, starting from the most difficult areas a step at a time and year after another AND DOING SO CALMLY also makes the economy back on track because no one can de-localize the construction of a home, at least not for the largest part of the job.