4 ms·
Typically in RPS you reveal your choice as your hand descends the third time. By the time your hand is at rest vertically, your move is already visible. However
by eridius 14y ago
Typically in RPS you reveal your choice as your hand descends the third time. By the time your hand is at rest vertically, your move is already visible. However this robot doesn't make its move until afterwards. So the robot is effectively playing rock every time and then changing his play to beat his opponent, which is pretty blatant cheating. The only thing that makes this different than a human cheating is the robot is fast enough that you might not notice.
- sounds 14y agoIt is interesting to an A.I. researcher. I loved watching the slow-motion version at 50x When I took Machine Learning, we studied different "bots" in various contrived game scenarios to illustrate the effects of imperfect information, non-deterministic outcomes, and other kinds of noise. The most interesting outcomes were when the bots learned to cheat. Since the system doesn't punish cheaters, it becomes a winning strategy. I think humans have learned not to cheat - for the most part - because at the most basic level cheating reduces the group's overall survival rate. E.g. stealing food from another member of the group. tl;dr if cheating is so obviously the best strategy, maybe the game needs to be revised? Because for this robot, cheat-really-quickly leads to 100% victory.
- saraid216 14y agoLook up Kristian Lindgren's work on using the Prisoner's Dilemma in a Sugarscape scenario. Among the results were islands of Always Cooperate strategies buffered by Tit-for-Tat strategies from Always Defect strategies. Unfortunately, I've been unable to find any actual papers. :/
- mistercow 14y ago>I think humans have learned not to cheat - for the most part - because at the most basic level cheating reduces the group's overall survival rate. I'm pretty sure that our anti-cheating behaviors are mostly instinctive responses, rather than something humans learned. We have an emotional concept of "fairness" that causes us to punish cheaters. There's also no need to invoke group selection to explain this (which is good, because group selection has been pretty thoroughly falsified). Game theory gives us perfectly adequate explanations in terms of individual self-interest for why cheater-punishment is an advantageous behavior.
- bambax 14y agoYou're right that "group selection" doesn't exist; but our "instincts" have themselves evolved into what they are, for a reason? Therefore, "not cheating" must bring a benefit to the individual (or be correlated with some other behavior which itself brings a benefit). The question is: what is that benefit?
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoIt would seem that group selection could be possible, depending upon time constants in the equation. E.g. if the group benefit accrued faster than the individual benefit. Furthermore look at religeon, not a lot of benefit to the individual but the cohesive group survival is improved. Lots of cultural examples. Heck, even look at cells cooperating to make an organism - thats group selection at the most basic.
- mistercow 14y ago>Furthermore look at religeon, not a lot of benefit to the individual but the cohesive group survival is improved. There is a very strong individual pressure to conform to your tribe. Humans are extremely vulnerable on their own, but benefit hugely from being in a group. It is therefore of paramount importance for an individual to avoid being outcast from the group. I think it is likely that religion is more or less the name we give to the feedback loop that causes tribal conformation pressure to override rational analysis in an individual's belief selection process. > Heck, even look at cells cooperating to make an organism - thats group selection at the most basic. No no, that is kin selection in its most extreme form. Kin selection is very strongly backed by evidence, and differs from group selection in that the individuals have an above average statistical overlap in their genomes. For example, a brother and sister have an average of 50% shared genes, so genes that promote sibling cooperation can propagate more effectively than their complementary alleles, even if that cooperation causes some reduction in survival of the individual. In the case of cells comprising an organism, the overlap in genetic material is 100% (excluding anomalies like mutation and HGT), so we see enormous amounts of individual cell sacrifice which prove advantageous in preserving those cells' genes by benefiting the other cells in the organism.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gala8y 14y agoBlatant cheating, that's what it is. Cant help, but quote from "I, Robot": "Look, this is not what I do, but I got an idea for one of your commercials. You could see a carpenter making a beautiful chair. Then one of your robots comes in and makes a better chair twice as fast. Then you superimpose on the screen, "USR: Shitting on the little guy. That would be the fade-out."
- JohnLBevan 14y agoThe robot cheating isn't the interesting thing here. Implementing that would be a simple case statement. This is a demo of fast digital signal processing (DSP) combined with fast mechanics/electronics.