3 ms·

I use Whatsapp often and one major issue I have with the app is how older media gets lost in the history, it's not retrievable anymore, you can only see the blu

I use Whatsapp often and one major issue I have with the app is how older media gets lost in the history, it's not retrievable anymore, you can only see the blurry thumbnail but downloading it again will not be possible. So until recently, I've considered everything I send on whatsapp as ephemeral unless I back it up. Also, is exporting possible? Let's say I would like to export all text / media to my pc, is that possible?

skydhash 2y ago
You can export WhatsApp conversations, but it was flaky last time I tried to do all of them (spanning 4 years). But I expect monthly or semiannually to be fine.
rahulg 2y ago
If you're referring to your journal entries to Today Has Been, Export functionality will be available soon.
lxgr 2y ago
WhatsApp does seem to delete old media from their servers, but it should be available on your primary phone indefinitely until you delete it. Any chance you’re accessing your messages from a different device and your main phone is offline?
- Alifatisk 2y ago
  I use Google photos on my phone so everything I send is not directly stored locally. Whatsapp wasn’t like this before, it was when they introduced E2E that old media started to get lost. If you want a groupchat with accessible history, whatsapp is not the place sadly.
  - lxgr 2y ago
    WhatsApp never had persistent server-side storage. I believe they keep media binary blobs only for a few days after each recipient has downloaded them. If you delete your local copy, that's arguably on you – there was never any promise that WhatsApp would be holding your media for re-downloads forever.
    - Alifatisk 2y ago
      > If you delete your local copy, that's arguably on you I don’t know if you’ve participated in a large group chat, but on those occasions, lots of media is being sent to each other. I am not that eager to have every media sent in the group chat stored on my Photos library. I don’t think anyone wants that. So I guess everyone, including me turns off that feature (automatically storing images received), meaning no one will eventually have that image stored on the device which causes the data loss after a while. Now, there is a backup feature in iOS, but it can only backup to iCloud drive, which I don’t pay for so the limit will be exceeded pretty quickly. I wouldn’t put the blame on anyone for this, except Whatsapp.
      - lxgr 2y ago
        Why should WhatsApp pay for the indefinite storage of your media any more than iCloud? Of course WhatsApp could start charging for storage in the same way that Apple does, but given that WhatsApp is pretty focused on local-only message storage at the moment (similar to Signal, and unlike e.g. Telegram or Facebook Messenger), I don't think that would be a very popular feature.
        Alifatisk 2y ago
        Maybe they could offer storage backup to other providers than iCloud, like on Android. But that’s just one idea. Either way, I seriously think there is a flaw in the design, especially in the scenario I provided. Had I know that WhatsApp would behave this way beforehand, I wouldn’t have used it.

skydhash 2y ago

You can export WhatsApp conversations, but it was flaky last time I tried to do all of them (spanning 4 years). But I expect monthly or semiannually to be fine.

rahulg 2y ago

If you're referring to your journal entries to Today Has Been, Export functionality will be available soon.

lxgr 2y ago

WhatsApp does seem to delete old media from their servers, but it should be available on your primary phone indefinitely until you delete it. Any chance you’re accessing your messages from a different device and your main phone is offline?

Alifatisk 2y ago
I use Google photos on my phone so everything I send is not directly stored locally. Whatsapp wasn’t like this before, it was when they introduced E2E that old media started to get lost. If you want a groupchat with accessible history, whatsapp is not the place sadly.
- lxgr 2y ago
  WhatsApp never had persistent server-side storage. I believe they keep media binary blobs only for a few days after each recipient has downloaded them. If you delete your local copy, that's arguably on you – there was never any promise that WhatsApp would be holding your media for re-downloads forever.
  - Alifatisk 2y ago
    > If you delete your local copy, that's arguably on you I don’t know if you’ve participated in a large group chat, but on those occasions, lots of media is being sent to each other. I am not that eager to have every media sent in the group chat stored on my Photos library. I don’t think anyone wants that. So I guess everyone, including me turns off that feature (automatically storing images received), meaning no one will eventually have that image stored on the device which causes the data loss after a while. Now, there is a backup feature in iOS, but it can only backup to iCloud drive, which I don’t pay for so the limit will be exceeded pretty quickly. I wouldn’t put the blame on anyone for this, except Whatsapp.
    - lxgr 2y ago
      Why should WhatsApp pay for the indefinite storage of your media any more than iCloud? Of course WhatsApp could start charging for storage in the same way that Apple does, but given that WhatsApp is pretty focused on local-only message storage at the moment (similar to Signal, and unlike e.g. Telegram or Facebook Messenger), I don't think that would be a very popular feature.
      - Alifatisk 2y ago
        Maybe they could offer storage backup to other providers than iCloud, like on Android. But that’s just one idea. Either way, I seriously think there is a flaw in the design, especially in the scenario I provided. Had I know that WhatsApp would behave this way beforehand, I wouldn’t have used it.