9 ms·
[flagged]
by mmooss 2y ago
[flagged]
- mmooss 2y agoPeople do take other drugs for the rest of their lives, as commenters point out, and which I didn't address in my initial comment above: Those drugs often treat problems that can't otherwise be treated, such as diabetes. Weight loss has other treatments, though we now know it's often not as simple and easy as many thought (often it's not just 'eat less'). Certainly there will be a substantial net benefit for many people. On the other side, the dosing requirement matches the current trend in business, which is rent capture. When does the patent run out?
- tptacek 2y agoThere's nothing at all interesting about this. People take insulin their whole lives, and statins, metformin, immunosuppressants if they're transplant receivers, steroids for asthma, losartan for blood pressure, Levoxyl for thyroid malfunction, probably many dozens more. You take drugs for the rest of your life because that is a superior option to the alternative, which is suffering (or dying) from the condition the drug treats. Nobody who takes those drugs wishes the drugs didn't exist. Only people on message boards do. They have the luxury of comparing them to fantasy football therapeutics and morality plays. The pharma company that invents a pill you take once and stay stably at your goal weight for the rest of your life will make approximately 8.6 bajillion dollars. Nobody's holding it back to preserve profits for Wegovy or whatever.
- ipaddr 2y agoUntil the lawsuits. Many miracle weight loss products have come to market and have done well initially only to discover some side effect. At least you can join the class action lawsuit and don't need to shell out anything to find out your preexisting issue means they don't have to payout.
- tptacek 2y agoYou can say that about every new long term therapeutic. For what it's worth: these are not especially new drugs; they're just being used for a new purpose.
- ipaddr 2y agoThere have been a variety of weight loss miracle therapeutic with little success which is not the case for all medical areas.
- johnnyanmac 2y ago>Nobody who takes those drugs wishes the drugs didn't exist. Only people on message boards do you can't just work out and cure asthma. You can't lobby the government to increase air quality and improve your asthma. That's the issue. We were sold a problem, the government subsidized it, and people are getting medals for a financial solution. That's what's interestingly distinct about this case. we're using miracle medicine to mitigate something that should be fixed with better lifestyle changes (including the ingredients and portions in food that allows that to proliferate).
- mmooss 2y agoWhile I agree with the general point, for some number of people obesity isn't treatable by lifestyle changes.
- tptacek 2y agoPeople are getting medals for a breakthrough in pharmacology. This is an article about scientists.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI feel this isn't answering my reply with a charitable interpretation. But that's fine, I don't think there's much conversation HN is going to have on this topic. The obesity epidemic topics tends to be a sore spot here.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 2y agoMy sore spot is that I have family working in drug discovery chemistry and this thread belittles that work in the service of some toxic combination of "do you even lift bro" and "big pharma". This is HN, on a subject that is about science, and it's not the GLP-1 advocates who seem to be sore about it.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago
- AStonesThrow 2y agoYou carry stable insurance and good benefits, and you've been seeing your PCP for decades. They help you find specialists when needed, and you've established trust and rapport; the front-desk staff welcomes you by name, smiling. Your loved ones are available, and willing to discuss and support your decisions. You head to the pharmacy every month, same day of the week, and pick up your prescriptions together. Your loved ones help you divvy everything up and measure out exactly 8oz of water, because that's what the label says to drink. Your physicians monitor you, and you've already accomplished lifestyle changes, a better diet, and plenty of exercise, because you shop at a nice grocery store, your dependents cook at home, and you can afford a gym membership and a personal trainer. Yet sometimes these fall short, and so you agree to treatment. You may report debilitating side effects, and your prescriber adjusts everything until everyone's satisfied. Your insurance is covering everything, and your loved ones rarely need to follow up on billing errors or to appeal decisions. Your alarm sounds every 8 hours, and your dependents pour another 8oz of water, and you take your meds, obedient unto death. You're following all directions and faithful to the system. Your health and life itself is in good hands; no need to be concerned about garbage forums or fake gurus who wrote a self-published book. You're voting for Kamala, or Mitt Romney, and expanding health care, because that is justice for the world. Your advance directives are in order, and power of attorney assigned to dependents, who are in tune with your wishes, and ready to put you in their car, or call 911, if you should be incapacitated or helpless. Suffering is alleviated by warm relationships and a loving touch.
- standardUser 2y ago> smoking, measels, etc. are much worse and people don't seem to care nearly as much. Not a lot of people smoking and getting measles these days. But obesity is, apparently, back on the rise and impacts at least 40% of the US population.
- loeg 2y agoSomething like 70% of the US population is overweight or obese.
- maxglute 2y agoRestauranter's nightmare. It's like 150 bucks / month in most of world vs 1000 in US, once generics drop to 20, most people can come out ahead in groceries.
- renox 2y ago> smoking,[]. are much worse Sure smoking effects are worse but there's a easy solution: never start smoking. But you can't stop eating..
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> a business has developed a treatment that requires patients to pay the company for the rest of their lives or they revert I know plenty of people who took semaglutide, hit a target weight and then stopped. The research shows a statistically-significant permanent effect [1]. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35441470/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35441470/