3 ms·
> Projecting the same with LLMs, we will have AIs running locally on mobile devices That’s not much of a projection. That’s been announced for months as coming
by latexr 2y ago
> Projecting the same with LLMs, we will have AIs running locally on mobile devices
That’s not much of a projection. That’s been announced for months as coming to iPhones. Sure, they’re not the biggest models, but no one doubts more will be possible.
> or perhaps AIs replacing OS of mobile devices and router protocols and servers.
Holy shit, please no. There’s no sane reason for that to happen. Why would you replace stable nimble systems which depend on being predictable and low power with a system that’s statistical and consumes tons of resources? That’s unfettered hype-chasing. Let’s please not turn our brains off just yet.
- praveen9920 2y agoYou are going with assumption that llms will remain same forever. There are attempts everywhere to make them smaller, efficient and more focused. Would you have called « transferring mails online « in the 90s is hype-chasing because our postal system was working great? Probably not a great analogy but you get the point
- latexr 2y ago> You are going with assumption that llms will remain same forever. I definitely am not and that’s stated directly in my post. I specifically said “but no one doubts more will be possible”. > There are attempts everywhere to make them smaller, efficient and more focused. That doesn’t matter when the issue is inherit. An LLM, by definition, needs large amounts of data and acts on them probabilistically. If you change that, it’s no longer an LLM. Any system that requires predictability needs to be programmed with rules we can understand, test, and reproduce reliably. LLMs ain’t it, and won’t ever be. Something else by a different name, maybe. > Would you have called « transferring mails online « in the 90s is hype-chasing because our postal system was working great? Probably not a great analogy but you get the point I understand analogies are never perfect, but that’s a particularly bad one. At least stay within the same realm of physicality. You made a bad comparison then ascribed a bad argument to be against it. That’s a straw man. I don’t even believe our current digital system is “working great”, so the analogy fails on multiple levels. There are bad programmers and bad technology everywhere, the world is barely held by proverbial spit and bubblegum. Yet that doesn’t mean any crap that’s invented afterwards, be it “web3” or LLMs are immediately the solution.
- praveen9920 2y agoYou are missing the whole point of comment. Its a prediction/ speculation. I agree that it may seem bad with current state of things but no one can say with certainty it WILL be bad. There might be hybrid models which can do both probabilistic AND heuristic work within the scope, you never know. That’s my whole point. If you see my comment, I said AI, not LLMs.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoWhat is an AI? Just an LLM? What do you call Siri, Cortana, and Google Assistant? I've already received a Gemini app on Android, and they're promoting the premium version too. Runs locally, yes? 30 years ago, my supervisor wrote, from scratch, an "AI" running on the company web server (HP/UX PA-RISC; 32-64MB RAM), that would heuristically detect and block suspected credit-card fraud. Remember that "AI" is a perennial buzzword with fluid definitions, both an achievable goal right now, and a holy grail. ¡Viva Eliza!
- latexr 2y ago> I've already received a Gemini app on Android, and they're promoting the premium version too. Runs locally, yes? Are you asking me? I don’t know nor do I care, I don’t use Android or Gemini in any capacity. > Remember that "AI" is a perennial buzzword with fluid definitions You don’t need to tell me that. I didn’t use the term “AI”, I just quoted the other post and responded in what I understood to be their terms. I don’t think LLMs are intelligent, thus not AI. You’re nitpicking the wrong person.