2 ms·
you say: > the practical effect being that the well off were already advantaged. ... In both instances a class perpetuates itself. by contrast, the article s
by kragen 2y ago
you say:
> the practical effect being that the well off were already advantaged. ... In both instances a class perpetuates itself.
by contrast, the article says:
> You could be a farmer, and then you took the exam, you succeeded, and then you became an official. So in that sense, it’s not social mobility, it is political mobility.
> Ilari Mäkelä: But there was genuine political mobility.
> Yasheng Huang: Oh, absolutely.
> Ilari Mäkelä: How would you convince a skeptic of that?
> Yasheng Huang: Very easily. Again, going back to our earlier conversation about data, this is not something you can just use stories to illustrate. You kind of have to use statistics and data. An earlier historian, Ping-ti Ho 何炳棣 who really pioneered research on the keju showed that it was meritocratic. There are later historians who study keju, and they say, “Oh, so-and-so came from a prominent family, and he also succeeded. He got promoted.” But the problem with that is, how do you know it is the prominent family part that contributed to his mobility? Maybe he was extremely smart.
> I’m not saying that the second view is necessarily wrong, but all I’m saying is that just telling that story itself is not convincing enough to make your point. In my work with Clair Yang from the University of Washington, we ran statistical tests to determine the effect of family backgrounds on exam performance. Whether or not you came from a rich family, whether or not you came from a politically prominent family, your father was a government official, your grandfather was a government official. Statistically, if that background influenced your exam score, we should be able to see it. We should be able to detect that effect in the statistical results we generate.
> Indeed, because you had three rounds, in the first two rounds that were anonymized, we didn’t see any effect of family backgrounds on exam scores. That’s quite impressive — going back to the 6th century, 7th century, 9th century, and 13th centuries — that your backgrounds didn’t influence your exam scores.
it sounds like you disagree with dr. huang's research conclusions, but you don't seem to be offering any argument against them, just bare contradiction