5 ms·
I live in a school district that pioneered this year giving half of the high school freshman class ("ninth graders") Apple iPad tablets at the beginning of the
by tokenadult 14y ago
I live in a school district that pioneered this year giving half of the high school freshman class ("ninth graders") Apple iPad tablets at the beginning of the school year. I attended the school board meetings during which the program was evaluated. After a lot of gee-whiz demonstrations ("look what you can do with an iPad") and a rather incredible statement by our school district's curriculum director that soon the district will no longer need to buy textbooks, because students will download instructional materials onto their iPads for free, the district decided to give ALL high school students iPads from now on.
So I think Gates is right where he is asked this near the end of this interesting interview:
"Q. Tablet computers are big these days. The Surface tablet was just released by Microsoft last week, and iPads are all over campuses, but it doesn't sound like your approach has been to give devices to students and hope things change that way. What do you think needs to happen for factors like tablets to really make a difference? Or is that not even part of the equation?
"A. Just giving people devices has a really horrible track record. You really have to change the curriculum and the teacher. And it's never going to work on a device where you don't have a keyboard-type input. Students aren't there just to read things. They're actually supposed to be able to write and communicate. And so it's going to be more in the PC realm—it's going to be a low-cost PC that lets them be highly interactive.
"But the device is not the key limiting factor at this point, at least in most countries. If we ever get the curriculum to be super, super good, then the access piece, which is the most expensive part, will be challenging, requiring special policies to let people get access. The device, you'll be able to check out of the library a portable PC, so I don't see that as the key thing right now."
Perhaps someday Real Soon Now, voice input may partly replace keyboard input (I'm trying that on this computer I use in my office), but I think Gates's essential point is correct that students need tools for producing content a LOT more than they need more tools for consuming content. And they still need adult guidance (which may not have to be every-weekday guidance from professional teachers in brick-and-mortar schools with compulsory attendance) to choose content to consume wisely and to be helped through the initial steps of learning to produce content.
- rbanffy 14y ago> students will download instructional materials onto their iPads for free My son spent a lot of time carrying heavy books to and from school (it's not usual for Brazilian schools to have lockers, so books are never left at the school). Ebooks would have made his bag a lot lighter over the years. It's also cheaper to distribute electronic books than physical ones and that savings can be put to better teacher training, more/better/deeper materials and so on. A final factor is that all students have easy access to Wikipedia. While not authoritative in every subject, it's an impressive resource. That's one of the reasons I like the OLPC project so much. It's a e-reader if you want to read, a laptop if you want to type, and a mesh router all the time. While not as flashy as an iPad, it gets the job done better for a fraction of the price.
- Zimahl 14y ago> Ebooks would have made his bag a lot lighter over the years. Agreed. I can't imagine that there is a reason for paper textbooks anymore. Even if it's a one-time, non transferable purchase, charge each student (or school per student) like $10. The textbook folks make a decent profit and the students get new, current books every year. > It's also cheaper to distribute electronic books than physical ones This is where I'm not so sure we can do this yet. The lowest-end Barnes & Noble Nook (Simple Touch) is $99. That's not expensive to me but still might be out of reach of low income families. Half that (or subsidize) and I think we'll be perfect, no more heavy textbooks for kids and millions of public domain books available for reading.
- rbanffy 14y agoRemember every student receives a set of books every year. Even if you distribute them very efficiently, you'll have the cost of transportation every year coming back. If you give every student a US$100 device they can use for many years, you'll end up spending much less during the education of the student. That's one of the reasons to adopt OLPC like products.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ippisl 14y agoTablets will hopefully open the system to bottom-up innovations in personalized education. then content will come, and pressure and support for teachers to use those innovations will come.