7 ms·
Teenager jailed for 18 months still in prison 18 years later
- bagels 2y agoI'm having trouble understanding if he received an 18 month sentence or an indefinite one: "was jailed for 18 months but is still trapped in prison 18 years later under a cruel indefinite jail term". That's in the first paragraph.
- throwup238 2y agoFrom Wikipedia: > [IPP] was intended to protect the public against criminals whose crimes were not serious enough to merit a normal life sentence but who were regarded as too dangerous to be released when the term of their original sentence had expired. It is composed of a punitive "tariff" intended to be proportionate to the gravity of the crime committed, and an indeterminate period which commences after the expiry of the tariff and lasts until the Parole Board judges the prisoner no longer poses a risk to the public and is fit to be released. [1] That last bit is even worse than it sounds: the burden of proof is on the prisoner to prove that they're no longer a danger to society, instead of requiring the Parole Board to prove that they're still a danger. Between that burden and the rest of the Parole Board's workload, it's taking forever to get anyone released. IPP was eliminated in 2012 because it was unjust and overused, but politicians made the conscious decision to not retroactively undo it because of the bad PR it'd cause if some violent offender was released and killed someone. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imprisonment_for_public_protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imprisonment_for_public_protec...
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago[flagged]
- mulmen 2y agoWhat about all the people who don’t reoffend that you don’t notice? As a resident of a “coastal city” I’m happy we value liberty over safety.
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoI would much rather be harsher on violent criminals in general. If you even attempted to murder someone once, especially a stranger, I have no reason to assume you are incapable of a second attempt. And sure, I’d be fine with giving people a first pass in some situations, but we’re talking about career criminals. Do you think it’s okay to let people with violent rap sheets 50+ charges long go free because you value their “liberty”?
- freeopinion 2y agoI'm not sure what you consider to be violent or what you consider to be a crime. Do you think speeding through a school zone is violent or criminal? What about drunk driving? What about a fist fight? I am willing to bet that you routinely violate the law. Somehow in your culture that is acceptable. Maybe you ignore a speed limit. Maybe you fail to disclose some income. Maybe you pay a kid to mow your lawn in violation of Child Labor laws. Maybe you take a swing at somebody during a pickup game of basketball. In U.S. culture these are tolerated and even encouraged. If you arrested people for these things and sent them to jail do you think they would re-offend when they got out of jail? If you haven't changed the culture into which you return them, there is a high probability. Is there anything about prison that changes the culture outside prison in a positive way? I don't ask that in a "See how pointless prisons are?" kind of way. Mostly my attention there is on the environment outside prison.
- consteval 2y ago> I'm not sure what you consider to be violent or what you consider to be a crime Yes, this right here is the key people are missing. This varies from person to person, from political affiliation to political affiliation. But it also varies within a person. Someone black is not going to be viewed in the same light as someone white. As much as we like to believe this isn't the case, it just is, and we have to account for that. The problem with IPP is that we start with the assumption the violent are violent and they must prove otherwise. When we begin at a baseline of disadvantage, the potential for corruption is strife. Racism is trivial and invisible in such a system.
- mu53 2y agoThe data shows that violent crimes are lower today than they've been in decades. Ever recorded, technically in the US. Crime is enormously politicized. Whichever politician is in office can be attacked with any crimes that happened in their jurisdictions. Its easy to see it in alt-right propaganda bringing up horrific stories.... from years ago. As in, they had to go back years to find a story horrific enough of a story to resonate with people. I see this pattern common in European and American conservative news. Between the media's "If it bleeds, it leads". Private prisons ties to politicians. Companies benefiting from slave labor. Many people's personal preference for excessive punishment. The data supports one story, and more and more people feel another one is true.
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoAround 40% of inmates in the US will reoffend, many finding themselves back in prison (and subsequently released) within the year. Violent crimes can be at a low and repeat violent criminals can still be a problem. Most crime in the US is done by a fraction of the population, and we are doing nothing to actually address rehabilitation. We simply let them go and watch as they hurt more people. You can try to hand wave this away as “alt-right propaganda” all you want, but the government’s statistics don’t lie.
- defrost 2y ago> Around 40% of inmates in the US will reoffend, many finding themselves back in prison (and subsequently released) within the year. Why? Having served their time are they dumped without resources and the stigma of a criminal conviction with limited ability for employment and support? The US is outstanding extreme in the per capita imprisonment rate which speaks to some systemic issue, however to be fair the US is about middle of the pack for G20 recidivism rates after (say) four years. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/recidivism-rates-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/recidivis... ~ 40% seems commonplace.
- underlipton 2y agoReoffend how, specifically? Obligatory context: the monetary value of wage theft alone (not including other types of white-collar crime, like embezzlement, tax fraud, securities fraud, etc.) is greater than that of every type of "violent" theft or burglary. Combined. Priorities.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AngryData 2y agoYou got a source for that? Because ive heard it before but never seen any evidence for it and it screams political propaganda to me. The US has not been soft on criminals in a long long time, that is why it has near 25% of the total world prison population.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> The US has not been soft on criminals in a long long time You should read more about SF, Portland, Seattle, and LA (while under district attorney George Gascon). Being soft on crime is normal in some parts of the US, and it predictably leads to lots of crime. These soft on crime policies have come so far that my local retail store locks up detergent behind glass now, and this is common on the west coast at this point.
- nsonha 2y agoidk, don't you find jailing people for crimes they have not committed (but likely to I guess) a bit... insane?
- selcuka 2y ago> politicians made the conscious decision to not retroactively undo it because of the bad PR it'd cause if some violent offender was released and killed someone. So it's ok if a violent offender jailed after 2012 gets released and kills someone. Typical politican logic.
- duneisagoodbook 2y agopoliticians are choosing instead to kill these prisoners via indeterminate detention
- Hydenty 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- duneisagoodbook 2y agoI hope you reflect on why that is.
- selcuka 2y agoTo be clear, my comment was sarcastic and I'm not defending the indeterminate detention option. Just pointing out the hypocrisy.
- sweeter 2y agoIsn't it the opposite? They don't want to be blamed if something happens so they uphold a blatantly unjust ruling. To be clear, thats not how any of this works. You can't just imprison someone indefinitely because they "might" do something.
- selcuka 2y ago> Isn't it the opposite? It is. My comment was a (failed) attempt at sarcasm. If the new ruling is thought to be more just, it should be retroactively applied.
- mathieuh 2y agoOn the point that the prisoners have to prove that they’re no longer a danger: in some cases that means completing courses which are completely inaccessible to the prisoners due to cutbacks.
- Spivak 2y agoHe received an indefinite sentence (for a crime that absent this statue doesn't allow for life sentences) with an 18 month minimum where it was later ruled that indefinite sentences were torture and driving prisoners to suicide. But the gov't has been slow to review people's cases and so folks are stuck.
- xyst 2y agoI didn’t understand it as well (not from the UK, but US), so I had to lookup the gist of it in Wikipedia. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imprisonment_for_public_protection https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imprisonment_for_public_prot... Basically, the “18 month sentence” is a minimum sentence for the crime(s). But after that period, a parole board is supposed to rule on whether this person is fit to rejoin society. What I don’t understand: - are parole boards just denying for any reason? Why are people serving such long sentences? - is it a backlog of cases to review to blame? - or is this similar to “cash for kids” scandal in the US? Basically, teenagers were sentenced harshly under the pretense of “zero tolerance” and sent to prison. But, in reality it was motivated primarily by the need for private prison systems to fill the cells and many judges getting kickbacks.
- crooked-v 2y agoThe onus is put on the prisoner to show they will successfully reintegrate into society, rather than on the parole board to show they will not. Of course, I'm sure the guidance or help given to said prisoner is nonexistent.
- consteval 2y ago> are parole boards just denying for any reason? Why are people serving such long sentences? Yes. There's guidelines for parole but they're just guides. Personal bias, as well as potential monetary values, keep prisoners in prison. For example, Georgia, based on statistics, should have a parole rate of 80% for non-violent offenders. The parole rate is 8%. This is for non-violent offenders. That's an order of magnitude of difference. The culture around parole and personal biases fuel this. Ultimately, the community and parole judge can only LOSE by allowing parole. In the best-case scenario, they break even - nothing bad happens if you let someone loose. In the worst case, they commit a crime. They're heavily biased to preserve the interests of themselves, the prisons, and their community. The well-being of the prisoner is least important because they are a criminal. > motivated primarily by the need for private prison systems to fill the cells and many judges getting kickbacks There's some of this as well. Some of these prisoners in (again, Georgia) are being coerced to work. Parole is a carrot above their head. They're paid less than minimum wage to literally flip burgers at McDonald's. It's a win-win situation for everyone involved. The prison makes money (garnishes half the wages), local shops get cheap labor, and "dangerous" people are kept locked up. Only the prisoners lose.
- smegsicle 2y agoso just let them out? why is british politics so boring
- ivewonyoung 2y agoAdditional details: "guilty to two robberies and two common assaults, while asking that a further four robberies, one attempted robbery and one assault occasioning actual bodily harm be taken into consideration." Also: "2020 - Luke Ings appeared over videolink from HMP Long Lartin at Worcester Crown Court yesterday where he denied four counts of administering a poisonous or noxious substance with intent. The 31-year-old was arraigned by the clerk, denying four counts of administering 'human excreta' unlawfully and maliciously with intent to injure" No mention about this in the article, looks like a very biased source.
- chris_wot 2y agoSo let's get this straight. The guy got into a fight in a Macdonalds 19 years ago. Noone died. He has autism. He got an indefinite prison sentence, which was seen to be so unjust it got abolished. So he is still in jail indefinitely for his original crime. The crime you mention doesn't allow him to be kept in jail indefinitely, not for the original offense. I think it's pretty clearly manifestly unjust.
- ActorNightly 2y ago> Noone died. Sentences are based on intent, not outcomes. Fighting can result in life lasting injuries.
- chris_wot 2y agoDid it result in life lasting injuries?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoSo let's get this straight. You see the post stating that he committed seven robberies and three assaults, i.e. was persistently victimizing people, and you choose to completely ignore that. He isn't in prison to punish him for one specific crime, he's in prison to keep him from victimizing people, because his history of crime makes it likely that he will keep doing that.
- teruakohatu 2y agoNew Zealand has the same concept, called preventative detention, which means kept in jail until they deem the risk of danger to the public meets some threshold. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preventive_detention#New_Zealand https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preventive_detention#New_Zea...
- spoonfeeder006 2y agoStuff like this is proof that any and all politicians who do not vigorously act to end these kinds of things... all, no exception, are psychopaths or otherwise rotten terrible people Like who the hell of a fucking idiot comes up with these stupid ass laws is beyond me Just goes to show, if you give people power to ruin peoples lives and torture them with impunity, there is no shortage of "people" willing to fill such a role And such lack of empathy is basically everywhere in society, though they conglomerate into business leadership roles in higher proportions
- tiku 2y agoProtecting the public is the point of these sentences. What needs to be correct is the support and evaluation incarcerated people get.
- spoonfeeder006 2y ago[flagged]
- the_gorilla 2y agoDo you think anyone would be willing to bet their life that this guy isn't going to victimize someone else when he gets out? Obviously not. We don't have to gamble with anyone else's life either to see if he's going to keep robbing and assaulting people until his victims are permanently physically or mentally damaged.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- spoonfeeder006 2y agoUh, yeah? I think most people? Including me??? Everyone makes mistakes. If he hasn't damaged anyone beyond repair then he doesn't deserve to have his life ruined beyond repair Its about justice, not fear 6 months is fine unless he hacked someone's arm off or something
- tiku 2y agoIn the Netherlands we call this "TBS" (Ter beschikking staat, translated "available for the state, something like that). It means you are classified dangerous and not curable. I guess this is the same in England. So there must be something seriously wrong with the guy. Mother doesn't see that obviously.
- duneisagoodbook 2y agothe sentence in the article "The jail terms were scrapped in 2012 amid human rights concerns, but not retrospectively – leaving almost 3,000 people languishing in prison with no release date." tells me that there is not an amount of danger which justifies this behavior from the state. if we have been able to live without this law since 2012, then there are other answers available which do not include this treatment.
- throwup238 2y ago> I guess this is the same in England. So there must be something seriously wrong with the guy. Mother doesn't see that obviously. The indefinite sentences were abolished in 2012 because they were being overused. They just didn't retroactively eliminate the existing sentences and the Parole Board has taken forever to sort through the problem. In 2016 the head of the Parole Board said they wanted to reduce the number of IPP sentences to 1,500 by 2020 [1], but you know... Tories happened. [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/news/statement-on-ipp-prisoners-from-parole-board-chairman https://www.gov.uk/government/news/statement-on-ipp-prisoner...
- zarzavat 2y agoThe reason is that resentencing people is a low priority when the justice system is falling apart in so many other ways. The authorities also don't want to be held to account for traumatising these people and any crimes they subsequently commit. 12 years is a murder tier stint, so pretty much all of them should just be released. However releasing a lot of dangerous people looks bad even if it's morally justified.
- arp242 2y agoNo, that's a different tihng. TBS comes with a psychiatric diagnosis, and is intended for psychiatric treatment. There is no such diagnosis or treatment with IPP. TBS also doesn't mean you're "incurable" That's just flat-out wrong. The entire point of TBS is to treat (i.e. cure) people. Everything about your comment is wrong. There's a reason IPP got shot down for human rights violations and TBS hasn't been: because it's fundamentally different.
- xdennis 2y agoHe was sentenced to "imprisonment for public protection", which is life imprisonment by another name. I don't understand why they would use such an euphemism instead of calling it what it is.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoBecause it's intentionally distinct from imprisonment to punish and/or rehabilitate. He already served his punishment, but because he has shown to be a danger to society, he is removed from it until he is no longer a danger (which may be only when he's dead or too frail to commit more violent crimes).
- mise_en_place 2y ago[flagged]
- tamimio 2y agoWow, and you don’t do anything productive for a year and you think you wasted your life... absolutely cruel. Even if he were released today, he would need another 15 years of therapy.
- jdietrich 2y agoThe problem with IPP sentences is more complex than just "the government arbitrarily locking people up indefinitely". The IPP prisoners who are still behind bars are there for a reason - in every case I'm aware of, because they keep committing violent offences while in prison. The psychological burden of an indefinite sentence is undoubtedly an obstacle to rehabilitation, as are the wider issues of understaffing and overcrowding in the prison estate, but let's not kid ourselves. IPP sentences were created specifically to deal with prisoners who habitually reoffend on release. These are people who were on a revolving door of offending and imprisonment before their IPP sentence, and who would almost certainly be stuck in that cycle again if their IPP sentence was quashed. IPPs are unjust and the current government will almost certainly retroactively resentence most or all IPP prisoners within this parliament, but the underlying problem is still there. We could definitely do a better job of rehabilitating this cohort, but even the best-funded and most liberal systems have had fairly meagre success in actually breaking the cycle of reoffending; the much-heralded low recidivism rates in Scandinavia are substantially a reporting artifact rather than a meaningful difference in outcomes.
- tasuki 2y ago> the much-heralded low recidivism rates in Scandinavia are substantially a reporting artifact rather than a meaningful difference in outcomes More on this?
- jdietrich 2y agoHeadline recidivism rates aren't really comparable across jurisdictions, because there are so many variables - what kind of offences lead to imprisonment, what counts as "reoffending", how long you follow up for, how likely people are to be arrested, charged and convicted etc. One study found that recidivism rates could vary from 9% to 53% based on the same underlying data, simply by changing the definitions. The more you try to standardise the methods, the smaller the difference in apparent recidivism rates. https://sci-hub.ee/10.1177/0011128715570629 https://sci-hub.ee/10.1177/0011128715570629
- 2y ago
- shadowgovt 2y agoI'm a little surprised this is compatible with habeas corpus, which (IIUC) is one of those rights that the Brits have beheaded kings over in the past. Why is nobody sharpening an axe over this kid stuck in jail?
- pmyteh 2y agoHabeas corpus allows you to challenge the legality of detention. If a writ were sought in this case the prison governor would present the original order of the court authorising imprisonment and the application for habeas corpus would be dismissed. There are routes to challenge 'wrongful' detention authorised by a court, but not via habeas. Some IPP prisoners have been released by the Court of Appeal criminal division on a (very late) appeal against sentence where other factors appeared after the original sentencing. You can also challenge the refusal of the Parole Board to release you by judicial review, though this is a fairly high bar to clear.
- frmrcnk 2y agoCanada has the same designation, "dangerous offender". It's what is keeping Paul Bernardo in jail (Canada has 25 years max sentence) Bernardo should have probably best been executed. Or given a proper life sentence. But this way, Canadians get to keep their progressive pieties vis a vis the US (no death penalty! No life in prison) and keep Bernardo in jail.
- birriel 2y agoI'm an attorney barred in the US, so I'm not familiar with this kind of sentencing. However, I'm having a hard time understanding commenters trying to add nuance to IPP sentences simply by saying that inmates don't get released because they keep committing violent offenses while inside. The reasonable thing to do in such cases is to give the inmate a new trial for each of those alleged offenses. This is very basic due process.
- starspangled 2y agoThe fair trial and "due process" was the initial conviction. The punishment for that is imprisonment until they prove to a parole board that they no longer pose a risk to the public. That's the thing about "due process", isn't it? It's just a phrase that basically means "the law", and the law can be changed by legislation and judges, and the law can be unjust. The phrase is nothing more than giving airs of being impartial or some check and balance against the law. This hapless fellow got his "due process".
- birriel 2y agoI hear you, but the problem is that the alternative is much worse. These indefinite detentions lend themselves to all manner of corruption. Maybe a prison guard doesn't like you and falsely claims you committed a violent offense, just to keep you inside. Maybe a fellow inmate attacks you, and when you defend yourself, it gets registered as a violent offense. The first element of due process is that a citizen be notified that the State is mobilizing its resources with the intention of depriving them of their life, liberty, and/or property. Another core tenet of due process is that, once notified, you get a chance to submit evidence in your favor before an impartial adjudicator, precisely to avoid the issues in my first paragraph.
- starspangled 2y agoI'm just saying that due process doesn't mean fair or just. Normal parole boards in America with American due process also do not have an obligation to release people unless their guilt for further crimes can be proven beyond reasonable doubt, but they're also part of what is called due process. You can argue this legal punishment is no good, but you can't argue for due process because he got it. In fact that is exactly what people have argued, hence this punishment being removed from the books. But in a cruel and seemingly unjust twist of "due process" of the law, the punishment was not vacated for all of those previously convicted. So if anything you would plead for an exception to normal due process here and ask that the change be retroactively applied, wouldn't you?
- milabogdanova 2y ago[dead]
- johnea 2y agoIf you ever wonder how the US became so fucked up, just take a look at the UK. The apple doesn't fall far from the tre...