4 ms·
> the other thing it did is start to legitimize this. If it’s only the Unabomber doing something, it’s clearly indefensible but as states use it other people w
by ryandrake 2y ago
> the other thing it did is start to legitimize this. If it’s only the Unabomber doing something, it’s clearly indefensible but as states use it other people will start to justify it on those grounds.
This is the most worrying part: Do we really need to normalize the idea of governments sending little bombs out into the civilian population and detonating them, hoping that they actually hit their targets? This is not how legitimate warfighting is done.
- edanm 2y ago[flagged]
- ryandrake 2y agoYea, I mean sure it's better than firing a missile at an apartment building full of families because there are a few terrorists hiding in it. But that's a pretty low bar. We are also just taking their word for it that it was a carefully chosen shipment (this time) and that it went out specifically to actual Bad Guys™ (this time). With only "Trust Us, Bro" as assurance. It's a bad precedent to normalize.
- acdha 2y agoThat’s what I’ve been fearing, too. It’s like dressing up as medical workers or using chemical weapons: no matter the legitimacy of the current target, it’s virtually certain that someone else will cite that as a justification for why they’re doing something similar. This seems especially dicey in the generative AI era where it’d be increasingly cheap for some government to “prove” that the people they just bombed were Hezbollah-level threats.
- zero-sharp 2y agowhat is "legitimate warfighting"?
- OutOfHere 2y agoLegitimate warfighting is where sensible pacifist civilians have a sufficient notice and a chance to leave the intended warzone with their belongings before the war starts. It is also where military, industrial, and infrastructural targets are the only targets, where reasonable efforts are made to avoid targeting civilians. Legitimate warfighting brings freedom in the end, whereas illegitimate warfighting takes it away.
- zero-sharp 2y agoWhat percentage of wars are fought with the intention to bring freedom in the end? A lot of wars are just the result of imperialism. I think that definition is somewhat artificial.
- kcplate 2y ago[flagged]
- bbqfog 2y agoIf a bomb went off next to me in Safeway, I'd consider the people who did that to be my enemy for life. This was an attack on civilians, civilian infrastructure and the general population of the world who now has to worry about being murdered by their devices.
- kcplate 2y ago[flagged]
- bbqfog 2y agoI would definitely be radicalized and take up arms. Hell, I'm not even there and it's radicalizing me! I know a lot of people who are making significant life changes in the US based on what Israel and its supporters are doing. I think it's a myth that you can "demoralize" people by killing their friends and family and terrorizing the public. That doesn't work and never has.
- kcplate 2y ago[flagged]
- bbqfog 2y agoIsrael has been trying this strategy since the inception of Zionism and not only has it not worked, it's created a massive amount of armed resistance. Sure enough, massive waves of rocket attacks have been coming from Lebanon since Israel's terrorist pager attack. It sounds like you're around Zionists, no one I've spoken to has anything but deep resentment toward Israel and that spans many different demographics.
- 2y ago