3 ms·
IMO, this article isn't even really about the death penalty, or shouldn't be. > In Texas they’re getting ready to kill Robert Roberson next month. Roberson was
by Wowfunhappy 2y ago
IMO, this article isn't even really about the death penalty, or shouldn't be.
> In Texas they’re getting ready to kill Robert Roberson next month. Roberson was convicted of killing his 2-year-old child in 2002 [...] In the days before the child’s death, she was running a fever, and an emergency room doctor prescribed an antihistamine that can cause fatal respiratory distress in young children.
> When Roberson brought her back to the ER, law enforcement officials didn’t like the way he was acting — unemotional and detached — and concluded it was evidence of guilt. It was likely evidence of his autism.
> The detective who testified against him now realizes that and is urging clemency so that Roberson is not put to death for a crime that he did not commit and that did not even occur, because evidence suggests the child died from pneumonia and septic shock. But Roberson is scheduled to be put to death for shaking her to death anyway.
If the author's description of the case is accurate, it really doesn't matter how you feel about the death penalty—you can replace "put to death" with "life in prison" and you're still left with an extreme miscarriage of justice. This person is very very obviously not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and he should be awarded his full freedom.
- rented_mule 2y ago> If the author's description of the case is accurate, it really doesn't matter how you feel about the death penalty—you can replace "put to death" with "life in prison" and this is still an extreme miscarriage of justice The difference is that you can partially undo a sentence of life in prison. The death penalty is permanent. In the absence of a perfect justice system (and perfection is not achievable in anything as complicated as a criminal justice system), innocent citizens will eventually be killed by the state with no chance of them eventually being set free if a miscarriage of justice comes to light.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]