4 ms·
Your logic is correct about the snowball's chance in hell most 3rd parties have in the US, but the editorializing weakens your comment, IMO. You're right in so
by davidw 14y ago
Your logic is correct about the snowball's chance in hell most 3rd parties have in the US, but the editorializing weakens your comment, IMO. You're right in some ways, but there is no perfect electoral system. A representative democracy like here in Italy carries risks of its own: that a small party will hold the critical votes needed for a majority in parliament, and so hold a much larger party 'hostage'. That is quite undemocratic in its own way, and also leads to "weak" democracy because it's often difficult to hold fairly diverse coalitions together long enough to do anything coherent.
- Mvandenbergh 14y agoAgreed. PR has its own problems and allowing marginal parties a place in government also means that you're going to have fascist and nationalist parties represented in your legislature as many European countries do.
- dchest 14y agoyou're going to have fascist and nationalist parties represented in your legislature as many European countries do You mean, people with different opinions than yours (and mine) can be represented in government? Isn't that great?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- baddox 14y agoIt depends. If your opinion is that fascism is good, then it's a bad thing for you to have representation in the government where I live.
- alxtye 14y agoHaving fascist and nationalist parties is a demonstration of democracy working, is it not?
- davidw 14y agoDon't forget the hammer and sickle waving communists, either. There's something to be said for being inclusive, but there's also something to be said for not giving a platform and a voice to every nutjob out there, either. It's a balancing act...
- jmj42 14y ago"I detest what you write, but I would give my life to make it possible for you to continue to write." --Voltaire (1770) There is _nothing_ "to be said for not giving a platform and a voice to every nutjob out there." The balance must always lie with not restricting speech. If that means that a nutjob (as you call it), gets to say unpopular things, then so be it.
- philwelch 14y agoIt's not a matter of restricting speech, it's a matter of restricting the power to govern. It's Europe that actually bans fascists from marching down the street bearing swastika banners, and yet they still get elected to parliaments.
- arethuza 14y agoIt is worth noting that some of the censorship of Nazi/Fascist ideas can be traced back to laws imposed by the Allies after WW2: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denazification#Censorship_in_the_American_zone http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denazification#Censorship_in_th... Once these kind of rules get put in place what politician is realistically going to ask for them to be repealed? [Personally, I would leave these laws in place while there are people alive who suffered directly from the Nazis].
- jmj42 14y agoThe power to govern is, in effect, speech, so by limiting ones ability gain political influence, you are limiting speech. The ability of small political parties to gain representation in government is, I believe, a good thing, even (perhaps especially) when the views of those small parties are unpopular. Even those with extreme views have a right to express them. Now, while I believe that all people have a right to speech, they do not have a right to be heard. There's an important distinction there. If someone cannot get elected due to extreme or unpopular views (I, for instance, will not vote anyone who holds various social stances that I consider detestable), that's acceptable. Not being able to get elected due to a mandated ban on your position is not something I can accept. I'll grant you, the ability to gain office with extreme views has had some pretty dire consequences in the past, but I still cannot bring myself to believe that, even in the most extreme cases, limiting speech is acceptable.
- arethuza 14y agoI'd be careful about regarding all parties that are "nationalist" as in some way extreme - the UK has national parties in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland that are all part of mainstream politics (the Scottish National Party even forms the government in the Scottish Parliament). On the other hand, we do also have the British National Party - which probably does correspond to your ideas of what a "nationalist" party is like.
- egypturnash 14y agoHave you looked at the actions of the Republicans lately?
- SagelyGuru 14y agoWhen you examine the history of 'strong' governments, you will see that a 'weak' government is the lesser evil. So, while this criticism of proportional representation is factually true, it is not a bad thing. What if small parties' votes are inconvenient to every budding dictator? Why should a large party have even more representation and power than its fair share of votes? Isn't that deeply undemocratic, in principle?
- TheAmazingIdiot 14y agoI believe it was phrased better by those much smarter than I: No matter the voting or electoral system, somebody will be disenfranchised.