Both solutions are OK, we have the in between one where people are expected to do their duty. Which they do or not. The recycling was solicited a few years ago

Both solutions are OK, we have the in between one where people are expected to do their duty. Which they do or not. The recycling was solicited a few years ago with just 3 bins: green for glass, yellow for paper, plastic, metal and a few other things and brown for generic trash