4 ms·
Do you want to make backups unlawful? Or to require Zoom to police licensing for poster on walls? Because the strat IA is using here seems like a great way to g
by tptacek 2y ago
Do you want to make backups unlawful? Or to require Zoom to police licensing for poster on walls? Because the strat IA is using here seems like a great way to get that to happen. Doing literally nothing --- or at least stopping when they lost in the district court and not appealing --- would have been strictly better for the rights of Internet users than what they actually did, which more or less torpedoed CDL everywhere in the country. Bad facts make bad law! They teach this in law school!
- ranger_danger 2y agoI don't see how. The lawsuit was brought by specific book companies whose copyrights were infringed, the outcome of this case does not determine what the definition of a copy or "backup" is outside the context of borrowing books. And in the zoom scenario, it does not shift the legal burden for copyright policing to anyone else (it's always the rights holder)...
- kmeisthax 2y agoCDL was already torpedoed before IA started doing it; there's a very similar scheme for digital resale called ReDigi which was sued to oblivion. In fact, it's why the publishers sued in the Second Circuit. Zoom doesn't have to care about posters on walls for several reasons[0] and computer backups are already authorized by law. There isn't really any potential for any worse precedent than what already existed before IA took a crack at it. The converse to "bad facts make bad law" is that courts are really hesitant to establish precedent that is broader than it needs to be[1]. And the precedent here is very much limited to the practice of loaning out e-books without a license, which was already pretty likely to be a "no" from the courts. The only real risk is to IA themselves, but they apparently are protected by other parts of the law that limit damages on libraries. So they just wasted the court's time. [0] DMCA 1201, and more importantly, the fact that such a use would be de minimus [1] Except for the current political hackjobs in SCOTUS who need a good court-packing
- dannyobrien 2y agoThat's a very separate matter -- I was mostly here talking here about the philosophical question of "it's copyright, so if there's a copy made, we can use that as a guide to whether this is legal or not." There's no risk to what you're describing, mostly because there are -- as others have pointed out -- clear statutory exemptions for these situations. I do disagree with your assessment of the legal strategy, but wouldn't want to get into that here. IANAL (and therefore learned NOTHING in law school), but I worked at EFF when IA was a client, and I do know enough to not want to accidentally breach professional ethics and/or privilege regarding a client. I feel that this is actually a challenge in discussions like this -- there's usually a whole bunch of stuff going on in the background (pro and con) that determines these strategies, but everyone involved who knows that background that can't really talk about it. But you know the same gang of lawyers as I do, so you can probably get their assessment more privately.