5 ms·
Beirut airport bans pagers, walkie-talkies on all flights
- colechristensen 2y agoThat is entirely sensible, I wonder how long it will last or if it will spread? How difficult was the sabotage to detect? Would it be detectable by ordinary airport scanners/explosives detection methods? What do we do if the answer is "you can't trust a flight with an electronics device onboard"? AI detection of anomalous Xray readings from known hardware?
- rogerrogerr 2y agoThe answer might be “you can’t trust a flight with potential terrorists onboard”. There are obvious, but high-false-positive and non-PC, methods to make that estimation.
- nemomarx 2y agoDo you think that estimation works for airlines in the middle east?
- rogerrogerr 2y agoProbably about as well as “you can’t have electronics”
- whimsicalism 2y agohizbollah is a broad political party in lebanon, not simply a paramilitary group i know blonde hair blue eye people with relatives involved, so you are just making false inferences
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> hizbollah is a broad political party in lebanon To be fair, so were the Nazis. (Trying to think of a less-combustible example.)
- hammock 2y agoThe Bolsheviks? Southern Democrats in 1883 after the Supreme Court ruled the federal government lacked jurisdiction over racist terror?
- whimsicalism 2y agoright, so if you were trying to look for militants when you should be looking for civilians with pagers… you’d be wrong
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> if you were trying to look for militants when you should be looking for civilians with pagers… you’d be wrong We're speaking within the fog of war. It's unclear, for example, what fraction of Hezbollah's ranks had a pager or walkie talkier. And what fraction of those were military. I'd still challenge that the collateral damage from such an attack constrained to Hezbollah members--even arbitrarily--is less than a conventional strike on suspected militants.
- whimsicalism 2y agoI am merely talking about criteria you would want to use in excluding people from planes. I doubt looking for stereotypical islamic militants would actually be that effective
- alephnerd 2y ago> broad political party But overwhelmingly Shia, and has token Christian and Sunni membership due to Lebanon's constitution. Hezbollah is not Lebanon, and Lebanon is not Hezbollah. Lebanon is an equal 3 way split between Sunni (Future Movement/Hariri), Shia (Hezbollah), and Christian (Kaateb and smaller parties). All 3 fought a vicious civil war from the 1970s into the 1990s, and then multiple invasions and interventions by Israel and Syria lead to factional conflicts. The Sunni bloc and Christian bloc both oppose Hezbollah in Lebanon, and this helped the Israel-Saudi rapprochement, as it is Saudi that supports Hariri and Israel supported the Christian bloc during the civil war and occupation. Edit: Love the downvotes from idiots who can't even find Tripoli or Beqaa on a map for pointing out how Lebanon is a very complex and split country.
- whimsicalism 2y agoMy understanding is cooperation between Hizbollah and some christian communities is a lot more than token, but that is mostly talking from friends with family (christian) in Lebanon
- alephnerd 2y ago> cooperation between Hizbollah and some christian communities is a lot more than token Yep. I made a broad strokes statement because it gets complex very fast. The Christian community appears to be split between anti-Hezbollah and anti-Palestinian groups like Kaateb (that were also historically pro-Israel during the civil war and intervention), and historically Syrian supported parties who supported Syria during their intervention in Lebanon such as Tashnag, Marada, etc. FPM was historically opposed to Syria but Michel Aoun made a strategic deal with Hezbollah in order to become M8's face in Lebanon, and because Hezbollah was never going to get Sunni support. Hezbollah will only accept Shia and are Shia-first, but allied with Syrian-then-Iranian backed parties because they all fought together on behalf of Assad in the Syrian Civil War, along with the alliance of convenience with FPM. The Pro-Syrian/Iranian coalition is the March 8th Coaliton (of which Hezbollah is the lynchpin), and the anti-Hezbollah/Saudi-funded coalition was the March 10th coalition before it splintered due to political infighting, corruption, and the Syrian Civil War. Furthermore, now that the Syrian Civil War is largely over, a LOT of battle hardened nuts from all sides in Lebanon have started returning, plus the economic collapse exacerbated an already tense political environment.
- crooked-v 2y agoMore than that, it's basically a mini-state within a state... and at this point more functional than the government of Lebanon. The attack was by all accounts pretty well targeted, but that still means there are probably a bunch of dead or maimed civil servants of the sort that a traditional military offensive would never care about.
- jordanb 2y ago> attack was by all accounts pretty well targeted Which accounts are you listening to? The accounts that I've heard is that they set every single one of these off all at once with no targeting and they blew up all over Lebanon in markets, theaters, schools, public transportation, etc.
- Sabinus 2y agoThey weren't a random shipment of pagers to Lebanon, they were specifically ordered and used by Hesbollah.
- jordanb 2y agoThey were distributed randomly throughout the country before detonation. The fact that they were likely purchased by Hezbollah members is kinda beside the point when Israel knew they were going to be all over the place in public places and crowds when they blew up. Thousands of people were injured and some killed for the crime of being near a member of Hezbollah (or even just their belongings) when the bombs went off. If thousands of bombs were distributed to members of a large criminal syndicate in the US or other western country and then all detonated as these people went about their lives and interacted with normal citizens, we would be absolutely horrified.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> were distributed randomly throughout the country before detonation We have literally zero evidence of this. Either way. If you think you can pierce the fog of war by looking at one side's official announcements, you're going to spend a lot of time confused.
- invalidname 2y agoThat is a "beard" they use to legitimize a large terrorist group that murdered hundreds of Americans. Fires on civilians, killed children and is conducting a war with Israel without the consent of the people of Lebanon. One of the "victims" was an Iranian ambassador to Syria. They are an arm of Iran serving their interests within Lebanon which are in conflict with the interests of the Lebanese people. They fight Israel but then hide behind civilians within tunnels. For once they became a direct target without the ability to hide behind anyone. Just recently there was declassified intel on them planting bombs within Israel trying to assassinate politicians. They already bootstrapped a phone in the past too. The reason they have popularity is due to funds they get from Iran which they use to provide loans to poor people. To make this even more attractive they push for a situation of dependency and poverty so the poor would be even more dependent on their loans. Lebanon is in deep distress (financially and politically) and these are the a*holes pushing for it on the behest of Iran.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- girvo 2y agoI don't really get to choose the other people on my flight...
- kmeisthax 2y agoYou forgot "high false-negative". There are plenty of white guys that want to do a terrorism as well.
- bigfatkitten 2y agoAnd the security services have done an amazing job of mostly ignoring the white supremacists, Sovereign Citizens, Christian fundamentalists and other white guys with a penchant for politically motivated violence.
- joomooru 2y agoThe explosive material presumably not detected for some months, so probably not very easy to detect
- mc32 2y agoYep, no-brainer with regards to the decision. W/regard to the method used… that open a new vector for all kinds of bad things. These were working devices that would function like normal but could be remotely detonated. What else would a terrorists want in a tool?
- yreg 2y agoIs it sensible? Explosives can be in many items other than pagers and walkie-talkies.
- miki123211 2y agoI'm afraid that the only sensible answer might end up being no more right to repair, no more phones from smaller manufacturers and no more unauthorized parts. Something like, if it goes through an airport, it has to have enough charge to turn on, and all the parts need to deliver a cryptographic signature (via an USB-C connection) that they're genuine and that they haven't been tampered with. Your phone is from a Chinese manufacturer? Good luck entering the US. It's that or no electronic on flights, not even in checked-in luggage,, and that won't fly (no pun intended) in 2024. That's assuming airport scanners are genuinely incapable of detecting this kind of sabotage, and I hope that this assumption is wrong.
- jxramos 2y agointeresting strategy, make the cost of modern communications to be too high due to hard to verify risks and subsequently push your enemy back to adopting slower modes of communication.
- imglorp 2y agoCellphones can be tracked. Walkies and pagers can't.
- outworlder 2y agoOf course they can, just not as easily or conveniently. EDIT: I meant walkie talkies. Old school pagers probably can't. Also I guess if you just use walkie talkies to listen to instructions. The station broadcasting can be tracked, however.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoHow would you track a pager? It's a receive only device
- tomrod 2y agoMaybe they once were. Are there features now like receipt confirmation?
- bigfatkitten 2y agoThere was for a while (Motorola ReFLEX), but it was never popular.[1] The pagers in this case were very boring POCSAG receivers, no transmit capability. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReFLEX https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReFLEX
- bhelkey 2y agoA walkie-talkie receiving a message should be a passive device no? One can triangulate a radio broadcasting, I don't know how one would track receiving the broadcast.
- donsupreme 2y agohow soon will US overreact and start banning within US airport and other public places?
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThe new scanners (ones that can differentiate water and explosives) would pick this up.
- lukan 2y agoHow would you know this? Lots of different explosives exist and if it is sealed in an airtight container, good luck finding it.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoI don’t know how those scanners work, but I’ve always presumed they’re looking for individual chemicals. There’s not many you’d need to detect to find explosives (probably just high concentrations of carbon, nitrogen and metals?)
- lukan 2y agoThere are lots of different explosives. High concentrations of nitrogen you can also find in the air for example. And metal all around in an airport. Carbon as well.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoThere’s not a lot of solid state nitrogen or metallic powders in an airport. The rest of the high explosives that I’m aware of are all rather dense organics. Possessing those things is how you get yourself selected for secondary screening. Again, I’m not an expert in how these things work, so I’m happy to be corrected. That to me just seems like the most obvious way the new dual energy scanners would be put to use.
- deleted 2y ago
- klarzn 2y agoLots of ink has been spilled on whether this operation was "legal" in a war or not. The Guardian points out a global treaty, which is signed by Israel, that prohibits booby trapped innocent looking devices: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/sep/18/the-guardian-view-on-israels-booby-trap-war-and-unacceptable https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/sep/18/the-gu... So now we have new fodder for the TSA and others, probably justified this time.
- ChocolateGod 2y ago> The Guardian points out a global treaty, which is signed by Israel, that prohibits booby trapped innocent looking devices: If the last 3 years (Ukraine onwards) have proved, international law and treaties mean nothing, other states are too cowardly to enforce them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- golergka 2y ago[flagged]
- wmf 2y agoI wonder how many decades this rule will persist.
- pton_xd 2y agoSeems like the citizens have been successfully terrorized.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoAs have the Israeli citizens who have been subject to indiscriminate rocket attacks over the last 11 months from Hezbollah. Personally,If had the choice between enduring rockets versus not taking a pager on a flight, I’d prefer the pager ban.
- fordfastlane 2y ago[dead]
- DoreenMichele 2y agoIsrael controls the water supply in Gaza. They aren't even allowed to collect rain water. It rains something like 2 inches a year there. People collecting rain water someplace with so little rain are likely quite desperate. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/campaigns/2017/11/the-occupation-of-water/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/campaigns/2017/11/the-occu... I wish there wasn't so much conflict but sometimes the people resorting to violence have been essentially left with no other meaningful solution. People with power can politely ruin your life and murder you and yours and then claim you are the bad guy when you fight back less politely.
- BenFranklin100 2y ago[flagged]
- WaxProlix 2y ago[flagged]
- DoreenMichele 2y agoI am opposed to the practice of raping people as a war tactic. And I wish Israel would get its boot off of Gaza's water supply.
- golergka 2y ago[flagged]
- sweeter 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- firejake308 2y agoWhat I'm interested to see is how this will spur additional divestment from Chinese supply chains in Western countries. Now that Israel has set a precedent, Western governments will likely be even more hesitant to use any goods that touched Chinese territory during production.
- krm01 2y agoYou mean European supply chains. Devices were produced in EU (Hungary)
- rysertio 2y agoDevices were procured through Hungary, they were made in Taiwan
- lukan 2y agoThe parts maybe, but they were assembled and the explosives put in in hungary as of current information. (And Taiwan is not China, but the 3. World war might be fought over the question whether they must be the same)
- ls612 2y agoWell the classic route for electronics manufacturing is chips get fabricated in Taiwan/Japan/SK/America -> the PCB and other mechanical elements get integrated in China -> the finished product gets exported to the West. So you could certainly have the explosives adding process be done in step 2 regardless of if step 2 occurs in Europe or China.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoIf that were the case, I think China would have the incentive to remove this from their own supply chains, they don't want to be excluded from world trade because of this stuff. But as others have noted, China was not the link in this specific instance, rather a European country was
- 2y ago
- hammock 2y agoWhy didn't/can't they catch the explosives in the X-ray scanners?
- unsnap_biceps 2y agosee https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/2024/turning-everyday-gadgets-into-bombs-is-a-bad-idea/ https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/2024/turning-everyday-gad...
- bakul 2y agoThe law of unintended consequences…
- stoperaticless 2y agoAre the models of walkies talkies and pagers known? Did they use batteries or rechargeable batteries? I guess one of those might get banned as well.
- maxglute 2y agoWonder if any of these electronics passed modern airport security, someone must have travelled with 1000s of devices out there for months.
- renegat0x0 2y agoAh yeah banning pagers will solve all the issues. If explosive materials were planted in pagers, then god only knows where they could be planted in the future.