8 ms·
Glass Antenna Turns windows into 5G Base Stations
- westurner 2y agoWould this work with peptide glass? "A self-healing multispectral transparent adhesive peptide glass" https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07408-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07408-x : > Moreover, the supramolecular glass is an extremely strong adhesive yet it is transparent in a wide spectral range from visible to mid-infrared. This exceptional set of characteristics is observed in a simple bioorganic peptide glass composed of natural amino acids, presenting a multi-functional material that could be highly advantageous for various applications in science and engineering. Is there a phononic reason for why antenna + window?
- westurner 2y agoBass kickers, vibration speakers like SoundBug, and bone conductance microphones like Jawbone headsets are all transducers, too Transducer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transducer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transducer https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41442489 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41442489 : > FWIU rotating the lingams causes vibrations which scare birds away.
- preisschild 2y agoThe new HSR trains in my country use similar tech to improve cell phone reception while traveling https://press.siemens.com/global/en/pressrelease/obb-puts-first-new-generation-railjet-siemens-mobility-service-and-orders-19-more https://press.siemens.com/global/en/pressrelease/obb-puts-fi...
- 1udsdhoasfih 2y agoNo. The article is about windows as active antennas. Meanwhile, trains now start having permeable windows that let the radio coverage from outside through. Train windows are metallized to protect from the sun - unfortunately blocking radio waves as well.
- loa_in_ 2y agoMaybe not in your country but I know there's cell repeaters all over civic infrastructure in Europe
- kurthr 2y agoI'm all for more innocuous cell antennas. I'm just not convinced in this case. Just looking at the picture it seems neither innocuous nor particularly transparent even thought it's on glass. Maybe they can make the connections less apparent without exposed coax, and maybe they won't need to add (extra) windows on top of windows, and maybe they can make the conductive areas more transparent, but this is only useful as a proof of concept. Let's see what they can do for a commercial product. Usually, there are tens of antennas on a single tower so they can't all look like this. Also, I'm going to assume that you have to keep anyone from getting within 3 meters just due to radiated emissions, so don't go just looking out that window!
- juancn 2y agoDo you mean inconspicuous? - innocuous: not harmful - inconspicuous: not clearly visible or attracting attention
- Bjartr 2y agoI think it can be used as "non-objectionable" or "non-irritating" which would still work here
- furyofantares 2y agoSure although the article says inconspicuous and transparent and the comment it saying it's neither of those things.
- asveikau 2y agoThe harm considered here is being conspicuous. So you could make an argument for either term.
- stackghost 2y agoInnocuous also means inoffensive, which is apt here.
- m463 2y agoInnocuous means producing no injury or harm, or not likely to give offense or arouse strong feelings. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/innocuous https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/innocuous
- throwaway48540 2y agoIs it possible to create a mesh 5G network run by volunteers supplying their connectivity, thus remove the need for mobile network operators?
- yieldcrv 2y agomesh is a pipe dream change my view
- pdabbadabba 2y agoMaybe we’d have a chance if you told us why you have that view in the first place.
- throwaway48540 2y agoWhy is it a pipe dream? It could also be something like roaming (in foreign countries), whatever - just a community mobile network that anyone can join.
- RandallBrown 2y agohttps://www.vice.com/en/article/detroit-mesh-network/ https://www.vice.com/en/article/detroit-mesh-network/
- vel0city 2y agoThat's less a "mesh" than it is a community-run WISP. Mesh would be each home (or some percentage of the homes) act as nodes. These have all the homes hit a few towers around the city. Traffic isn't routed directly between (or through) the homes in this example, it is all centralized. They hit a single big tower that then does all the routing.
- 0xEF 2y agoThe link in the Vice article to the project's site is old. Here's a current one; https://detroitcommunitytech.org/eii https://detroitcommunitytech.org/eii
- 2y ago
- rspoerri 2y agoMy first thought was, which windows version does it need? /s
- mrvenkman 2y agoWhich way up is that picture?
- MisterTea 2y agoPretty sure we're lookup up at a slight angle. Those high hat lights are usually on the ceiling and not walls or floors.
- 1udsdhoasfih 2y agoThe product website has a bit more helpful pictures: https://wavebyagc.com/en/hidden-antennas-for-urban-environments-connectivity-without-visual-pollution/ https://wavebyagc.com/en/hidden-antennas-for-urban-environme...
- hnbukkake 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- burleson 2y ago[dead]
- bee_rider 2y agoI don’t 100% get the story. TLDR, skeptical due to the issue of the two 5G frequency ranges. > Because 5G networks include spectrum comprising higher frequencies than 4G, base stations for 5G networks serve a smaller coverage footprint. Sure > It [the window antenna] is compatible with frequencies in the 5G Sub6 band—meaning signals that are less than 6 gigahertz (GHz). Sub6 antennas represent critical portions of a 5G deployment, as their lower frequency ranges penetrate barriers like walls and buildings better than the substantially higher-bandwidth millimeter-wave portions of the 5G spectrum. But 4G seems to go into at least the 3-ish GHz range just fine. At least my layman understanding is that sub-6Ghz doesn’t have the range problem, the whole point of adding that (IMO, less-than-intuitive-to-consumers) frequency band was that (while it didn’t fulfill the bandwidth promises of 5G) it also didn’t have the range problem. So it is there to fill the gaps. The ability to deploy sub-6GHz antennas everywhere seems like it misses the whole point of that band. I’m sure there’s some advantage to the 5G tech in general, because it is newer. But that’s a different pitch, right?
- toast0 2y agoSub6 is more or less the same frequencies as 4G. I know there's more low frequency (additional spectrum formerly used for over the air TV), and there might be some slightly higher frequency too, but this is the general purpose stuff. The mmWave stuff is really for locations with dense crowds like stadiums and maybe airports and busy train/transit stations. 5G is still better than 4G on sub6 for lots of reasons, but yeah, it doesn't have the oodles of bandwidth that 5G promised. Being able to put more sub6 base stations in more places is still good though. There's plenty of areas with poor coverage, and sometimes the reason there's no coverage is the aesthetics of the base stations are poor. Blending in helps. Which is why some antennas look like weird saguaro or palm trees and pine trees. It might be nice to have antennas in windows in office buildings instead hanging on the side, and it might be easier to install as well.
- hammock 2y agoGlass is silicon and silicon is conductive metal, after all…
- blueflow 2y agoa semiconductor.
- hammock 2y ago“Silicon substrate, as one of the most important materials for the integrated circuit industry, can be used to manufacture mm-wave antennas for a highly integrated purpose” Here’s an interesting paper on how to make it work efficiently: https://www.mdpi.com/2079-9292/12/24/4983#:~:text=Silicon%20substrate%2C%20as%20one%20of,for%20a%20highly%20integrated%20purpose https://www.mdpi.com/2079-9292/12/24/4983#:~:text=Silicon%20....
- Joker_vD 2y agoThat neither makes silicon a metal, nor glass silicon (it's silicon oxide at best, and oxides generally have radically different chemical and electrical properties than the pure element).
- vel0city 2y agoGlass is a resistor, it is not conductive. Its actually a pretty good resistor, its often used to separate extremely high voltages. Those little discs you often see holding high-voltage power lines are often made from glass. Silicon is not a conductive metal. Its a semi-conductor, it needs doping to become a good conductor. That's why its used in IC's. Naturally not very conductive but react a little with something else and suddenly it becomes a pretty good conductor. Make a mask of the channels where you want that conductivity, and suddenly you can draw little wires.
- jimmySixDOF 2y agoAlso why this system needs to be customized and tweeked to work with each specific panel of building glass it is placed with to get the full RF signal pass through
- HumblyTossed 2y agoThat's not a glass antenna. That is an antenna encased in glass.
- iwontberude 2y agoAgreed, also the article becomes orders of magnitude less interesting once you get past the click bait title.
- pests 2y agoThe glass and the antenna have been designed and tuned to work together. The antenna will not work without the glass, its part of its RF characteristics.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- istultus 2y ago[flagged]
- caseyy 2y ago> I don’t think the idea for using transparent conductive materials as an antenna existed before Many slightly older cars (2000-2020) had antennas embedded in glass. The idea is solid. Antennas in glass are protected, so they can be very thin and almost invisible, more aesthetically pleasing than a shark fin or a rod on the roof. I would consider this an aesthetic choice, not so much engineering. A small antenna sticking out on the roof solves the engineering problem adequately.
- HPsquared 2y agoThey still do, I believe. Cars usually have several antennas embedded in e.g. the rear glass. Even something like the FM radio often has 3+ antennas in different locations and the receiver switches between them to get the best signal. One shark fin isn't enough.
- caseyy 2y agoNow shark fins are in vogue again because they house multiple antennas — FM/AM, DAB, GPS, and recently more importantly, 4G. Maybe even WiFi — weird as it sounds, I saw some strings for WiFi antennas in a popular stock media/head unit’s firmware. Though you are probably right and many cars with just FM/AM and DAB still put them in windshields. I’m not sure about that 3+ antenna claim for FM. Do a fact-check there. ;) I think most diversity antenna systems that you describe use 2. And they are still considered “premium”. 3 is a bit overkill for FM, FM is very resilient against obstacles. If I’m wrong, would be interesting to see an example of a car that uses 3 or more. Probably far outside of my pay grade to say the least.
- HPsquared 2y agoI'm going by the BMW E90 (Top HiFi option) which has 3 physical FM antennas FM1, FM2 and FM3, all in the rear glass, and a fourth "FM4" which is not a physical antenna but a combination of FM1 and FM2. They really didn't want you losing signal! This isn't even mentioning the festoon of other antennas for DAB, mobile (which has a backup too and phones home in a crash: in case the shark fin is broken in a crash)
- ortusdux 2y agoI'd like to see a version that doubles as exit signage. https://www.exitsignwarehouse.com/products/esw-el-r https://www.exitsignwarehouse.com/products/esw-el-r
- n2d4 2y agoThey do that in this article towards the end: https://wavebyagc.com/en/hidden-antennas-for-urban-environments-connectivity-without-visual-pollution/ https://wavebyagc.com/en/hidden-antennas-for-urban-environme...
- ortusdux 2y agoVery cool, thanks. It looks like they can be used for WIFI as well, which would make these perfect for business mesh networks.
- russfink 2y agoWhy not just make a hawk silouhette into an antenna? They paste those on windows all the time to minimize bird strikes.
- kragen 2y agohow do we end up with statements like 'millimeter waves can deliver typically between 10 and 50 GHz of bandwidth' getting published in ieee spectrum? are there no electrical engineers at the ieee anymore? apparently this article is by a 'tim hornyak' with a degree in journalism from carleton university in ottawa. what the fuck?
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoWhy the hostile nature of your question? Sounds like there's some context to note.
- kragen 2y agobecause i think that kind of ignorant schlock discredits the ieee as an organization
- ssl-3 2y agoIs "between 10 and 50GHz" not a description of a range of widths of a band? Are bands of that width not typically delivered with mm waves? (There's more definitions of the word "bandwidth" than counting bits per second. It has, at least, uses in both RF and in data networking -- and the former use is predates the latter.)
- kragen 2y ago10 to 50 gigahertz is a range of bandwidths, yes. that's not the problem i don't know why you're bringing up bits per second. neither i nor the clueless loser who wrote the article were talking about bits per second the quote doesn't say 'designs that deliver 10 to 50 gigahertz of bandwidth typically use millimeter waves'. it says the opposite: 'millimeter waves can deliver typically between 10 and 50 GHz of bandwidth'. that's clueless nonsense. it's not even wrong. bandwidth is delivered by a medium, not by a signal in it; the signal is closer to being what the bandwidth is delivered to. the signal occupies or consumes or has bandwidth, which is close to the opposite of delivering it. and a millimeter-wave signal can be of any bandwidth at all up to about 300 gigahertz, including—obviously, one would hope—bandwidths of well under a megahertz. (in theory you could transmit or detect a millihertz-bandwidth millimeter-wave signal, but that probably requires exotic instruments like an atomic clock.) it's complete nonsense to try to describe the 'typical' bandwidth of a millimeter-wave signal. it's like talking about the typical mass of objects made out of atomic matter, or the typical distance traveled by photons. is jupiter or a tardigrade a more typical-sized atomic-matter object? it depends entirely on context. there is an upper limit (objects much larger than jupiter will stop being made of atomic matter pretty soon) and a lower limit (probably you need at least a dozen or so atoms of lithium before you have an 'object') but there are many orders of magnitude of slop within that limit if we were talking about bits per second, it might make sense to talk about a signal delivering something, but even in that case the information capacity of the signal depends on many more considerations than just the wavelength. the bandwidth, for one, but also the relevant sources of noise, the transmit power, the path loss, and the efficiency of the coding scheme used. so you'd still have a lot of orders of magnitude of slop, and plenty of mmwave signals aren't even used for communication, so trying to characterize their shannon capacity is a somewhat questionable enterprise
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- system2 2y agoSo you are telling me this looks better than a simple dish antenna resembling a Unifi AP dish? This thing might be a concept, but when it is implemented, it will still show a bunch of wires encased in glass. I am also not into being blasted by radio waves all day long from every angle.
- humanfromearth9 2y agoNext step is to develop the use case for smartphones, then for foldable smartphones.
- sgt 2y agoWon't tapping on the glass disrupt the signal, or simply wind or heavy rain against it disrupt it as well?
- zonkerdonker 2y agoIt would if this was actually mm-wave 5g. The article says this antenna only functions in the sub 5ghz range, which makes a lot of sense. Most modern windows use an aluminuzed coating for UV reflection (usually called low-e glass), which surprise surprise, is absolutely great at attenuating mm-wave frequencies, making windows pretty much the worst possible place on a building to place an antenna. But, turns out most people also dont need gigabit wifi for their phones and other devices, so true mm-wave 5g seems to mostly be reserved for wireless home internet at the moment.
- mrguyorama 2y agoWhat advantage does this actually confer over just a normal antenna you place at the top of your window? The "look it's glass!" hype claims it won't obstruct your view, but on an 8ft tall window, nothing is obstructing your view up there anyway!
- ssl-3 2y agoThe entire window itself is the antenna, and that antenna is transparent. The shit you see at the top are the wired connectors for the antenna that is inside of the window.
- p0w3n3d 2y agoIt took me a moment to realise this is about window not an operating system even though 'windows' was lowercase
- J_cst 2y agoExactly the same here... Same happens when I see the word 'file' written somewhere (which in Italian means queues, and I'm Italian), and I read it as the English IT word 'file'. This always make me lightly smile.
- sexy_seedbox 2y agoWhat or which "teams" are you taking about? Oh, the Microsoft Teams' teams.
- nakulgarg22 2y agoI'm exited to see if an array of antennas in the glass can 'beamform' in the building and increase signal strengths intelligently.
- zonkerdonker 2y agoThis device in this article seems to be mainly for serving signal outside of the building. However, devices like the one you descibe exist, such as: https://pivotalcommware.com/echo-5g/ https://pivotalcommware.com/echo-5g/ (Full disclosure, I'm a previous employee)
- _boffin_ 2y agoThis may be out of context, but I wonder if this will have any effects on cell tower REITs.
- gyudin 2y agoPerfect for businesses in San Francisco :D
- hooli_gan 2y agoThe company Alcan Sytems also produces 5G glass antennas. But they use LCD (Display Technology) to create a phased array to dynamically direct the signal. https://www.alcansystems.com/ https://www.alcansystems.com/
- justinclift 2y agoSo give it a few years and all new car windows could be mobile network antennas? Can imagine both good and horrible points to that happening.
- olliej 2y agoDoes that mean we’LL no longer need vaccines to get 5G at home? :D :D More seriously, the terrible nature of start up/project names meant I actually read this as being “Glass Antenna[software name] turns windows [operating System] in base stations [an actual base station or network hub]” And it was not until I saw Ieee.org that I realized it actually meant real antennas, and even then my incorrect interpretation of the headline still seems plausible to me
- BurnGpuBurn 2y agoThe photo caption reads: "An interior photo of a rectangular glass device attached to a building's window, with cables going between it and the ceiling." But it is clearly an AI-generated image. Look at the reflection of the lamp in the window, it overlaps the window frame. Is this now the norm, AI-generated images pawned off as begin real? Good lord...