3 ms·
When Craigslist started they had to overcome this problem. They even had to make the idea of using the Internet for a lot of these kinds of ads something anyone
by saurik 14y ago
When Craigslist started they had to overcome this problem. They even had to make the idea of using the Internet for a lot of these kinds of ads something anyone would even consider. If you look into the backstory, this took many years of bootstrapping at small scales before it really took off. Why should we be cheering anyone on who wants to just cheat their way into this space, piggybacking on all of that hard work and dedication building this market?
- crazygringo 14y agoNo, Craigslist didn't have to overcome this problem. They merely had to overcome the problem of building the market in the first place, which was much easier because nobody else on the Internet was obviously the "default" option. Nowadays, any site that doesn't already have the same kind of buyer and seller populations that Craigslist does is at a complete and total disadvantage in competing, and the point is, it's virtually impossible to overcome that. Craig today would never get his foot in the door. > Why should we be cheering anyone on who wants to just cheat their way into this space, piggybacking on all of that hard work and dedication building this market? Because Craigslist's success is not due 100% to hard work and dedication. It's probably more like 10% hard work, and 90% being in the right place at the right time. So the question is, why should Craigslist be forever rewarded for dumb good luck, while competitors who work even harder to create better products are doomed to fail, because it's impossible for them to attract users while Craigslist sucks them all up, just because of its network lock-in effects? I want to see Craigslist start to have to compete and innovate again, just like most other companies have to.
- saurik 14y agoYou drastically underestimate how difficult it was to make people think the Internet was a reasonable place to look for apartment listings in the first place. I was one of those people in 1995 schlepping around town trying to convince companies that the Internet existed, and that they wanted a website ("yes, I guess it is kind of like a brochure..."). The entrenched competitor at the time were physical newspaper classified advertisements. There were great apartment-specific guides you could get. If you were serious about apartment-hunting, the Internet would have looked stupid. Remember, Craigslist started in 1995, and they were an email mailing list of Craig and his friends. It wasn't until 1999 that they incorporated. Meanwhile, while their /look/ hasn't changed, their functionality has, and it has defined entire genres of things people use it for that, as someone only 30, I'm still floored by the success of (as in "people seriously want to use a website for that?!"). There actually was competition, even among friends, and the user community seriously stuck with Craig only because he had spent years making them like him (which is hard work that does not involve code, but instead service: Craigslist actually does a lot of work behind the scenes on that community, and does to this day). The story of bootstrapping Craigslist is actually epic: please read it. There have been some amazing write ups of the story in various publications. I recommend Gibson the longest one.
- crazygringo 14y agoI'm sure the story of bootstrapping Craigslist is very interesting, I don't doubt it. But that's not my point. My point is, their bootstrapping was a challenge just like any other other startup has to gain users, but it was possible, with hard work. Nowadays, if any other startup tries bootstrapping that is even better, with even more hard work and dedication, they'll still fail, because Craigslist wins via network effects. It's now virtually impossible. Resentment towards Craigslist is not because they got to where they are now easily -- they didn't, it was hard. That gets respect. The resentment comes because they're staying where they are now, easily, and potentially better competitors have virtually zero chance, no matter how much they work hard.
- koide 14y agoIt's a childish complaint. The new startups simply aren't better, because they don't have the network effects. They may have better looking UI, better text classification, better customer service, or whatever you want. But as long as they don't have the users, they are not better. And don't forget that recent history is filled with companies that were "virtually impossible to defeat" until they were beaten, and harshly.
- creamyhorror 14y ago> But as long as they don't have the users, they are not better. That's a truism. Crazygringo's point assumes that network effects are excluded from the measure of a "better" service. I think that's a fair basis for comparison, since the network effective advantage accrues from an earlier period in the marketplace's history: it's the prize won by being better/smarter than previous competitors. But it says nothing about the dominant service being better than current, newly launched competitors. If you define "better" as having more users, then that's pretty much ex post facto reasoning and tells us little. > And don't forget that recent history is filled with companies that were "virtually impossible to defeat" until they were beaten, and harshly. 1. The number of years that a company dominates is the measure of how much that company has won. The fact that a company eventually falls to a competitor doesn't mean that the company didn't profit handsomely for years or decades. 2. The fact that some large companies have fallen doesn't mean that the existing behemoths don't derive most of their advantage from network effects. Maybe we would have seen better, more open social networking startups emerge and win the market by now if Facebook's network effects were somehow nullified. The ultimate point is that network effects are a very significant barrier to entry, and mitigating them would allow a more dynamic market for startups to compete in, and higher competition in the market (which is better for consumers). Imagine if all social networks were interoperable and people could choose which service they wanted to live on -- then there wouldn't be a tendency for a 1000-ton gorilla to emerge at the top of the heap. (Funnily, I have nothing against Craigslist, since they're providing a very useful service at virtually no cost. They deserve their position, easily; their market's story is a happy one. Let's hope it happens in more places soon.)