14 ms·
Facebook forces all users over to Facebook.com e-mail addresses
- ColinWright 14y agoEarlier discussion, now 2 days old: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4151433 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4151433 Here's some discussion and a link describing how to fix it: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4157589 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4157589
- pwpwp 14y agoOutrageous, IMHO.
- reustle 14y agoI'm actually not able to change my email settings currently. It forced my real email to "not public" mode and my facebook email to "public" and the buttons are unresponsive. I also can't "remove this from my timeline" either. Update: A few hard refreshes later, the buttons started to work.
- smokinn 14y agoSame happened to me. I think their email settings servers/subsystem is just getting hammered right now as more and more news articles are being written about this.
- rhizome 14y ago"Forces" is too strong a word, IMO.
- sp332 14y agoYou can't avoid this change, so yes it's forced.
- rhizome 14y agoIt didn't replace my addresses and there are two other stories on the front page about this, so it looks rather linkbaity.
- ealexhudson 14y agoDid you check your profile, not your settings? My email settings were unchanged, but on my public profile they were different and had been set to a facebook address. I think it's easy to understate the importance of this, personally, and don't mind the multiple stories. I'm extremely annoyed at this - I don't want this email address, that I do not control, be published as some kind of contact point for me.
- sp332 14y agoIt's a big deal, and there's no "canonical" link, so it's not surprising that multiple stories got enough upvotes to be on the front page. Also if you had public email addresses, it hid them. That's not cool.
- damoncali 14y agoThey made me a new email address that I don't want and then told all of my friends that it was the one to contact me at on my behalf. And they also didn't tell me. Dick move.
- grecy 14y agoFWIW: I don't have timeline, and it changed mine to @facebook.com
- ceejayoz 14y agoTimeline was rolled out to all accounts. Are you using a plugin to approximate the old look or something?
- jlogsdon 14y agoI've seen several feeds that are still on the old layout. Not sure how that's possible, I don't think a plugin can do it.
- clownz0r 14y agoAFAIK, it was opt-in. I'm sure they (like me) just never enabled it.
- __float 14y agoI've still seen some people who don't have Timeline yet. It is rare though.
- idleloops 14y agoI can't stand timeline. I find it really difficult to read them for some reason - probably something to do with having more than one column - and poor alignment - it's cognitively difficult.
- alextingle 14y agoI read an opinion piece that said is was deliberately confusing... an attempt to trick you into clicking on ads.
- Spoom 14y agoAre you sure? I still don't have it (thankfully). I'm probably on the tail end of their rollout though. Might help that I hardly ever use Facebook anymore.
- zerohp 14y agoI don't think its overstating the situation to say: Facebook changes profiles without permission or notification.
- ThePherocity 14y agoTrue, but there is a fine line. You cannot reasonably move a product forward if a few select people refuse to play along. Every product I release, I'm met with disdain from users that don't want to change, and how it was perfect the way it was. And the next release with a different change, it's the same users complaining how the version that they're using now is perfect, why would I change things? People love to complain, and people don't like change.
- forgotAgain 14y agoThere is no fine line here. Facebook changed a personal attribute of their users. This particular action is not justifiable under any circumstances I can see.
- praxulus 14y agoThey're ethically obligated to hide infomation users don't want released, but are they really expected to publish everything their users ask to make public? It's annoying, but it doesn't spur anything like the moral outrage I would feel if they publicized your hidden addresses. At worst its a minor inconvenience.
- swasheck 14y agoIt's less about convenience and more about assuming the ability to modify a primary attribute of one's online identity without advance notice. People will sit back, be quiet, and move along and Facebook will progressively march forward with the invasion and the general populace will scream about it until it's too late.
- rhizome 14y agoAre you really flying the flag of Facebook's ethical obligations toward the benefit of their users?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Alterlife 14y agoThere are three discussions about this on the front page :-/ . I think this is just might be one of those things which would ticks us off as techies... but techies are the minority audience for sites like facebook. Do emails sent to the facebook id go to the standard facebook 'message system'? If so, for a majority of people this will probably make sense... want to message somebody on facebook? You don't have to login to facebook! Email them at xyz@facebook.com. I didn't know you could do that, pretty sure a lot of other people didn't either. Now a lot of folks probably are updated about this feature. In addition: non-techies who have accidentally exposed their private email id's will now have their facebook id's scraped instead... and the ones who exposed their private emails intentionally will change it back anyway. However, all said and done... it could have been done differently.
- ken 14y ago> If so, for a majority of people this will probably make sense... want to message somebody on facebook? You don't have to login to facebook! Email them at xyz@facebook.com. There are easy ways to advertise this fact, without changing anyone's personal info in their Facebook account. It could be as simple as adding the text "You can also send messages to JaneDoe@facebook.com" to JaneDoe's profile page.
- Alterlife 14y agoI do agree - it could have (and possibly should have) been done differently. I was trying rationalize facebook's action. It's a hugely successful company run by people smarter than I.
- alextingle 14y ago"run by people smarter than I" Don't bet on that!
- AznHisoka 14y agoIn 99% of cases, ppl didn't reveal their private email address. NOW, people can infer your facebook email address from your facebook id... thus making spamming you much more likely. Facebook IDs are public, right? You can argue people can already mass-message people, but now it's easier.
- brudgers 14y agoWell I was using my gmail account to collect all the worthless emails Facebook sends me. Now I guess I will be wasting Facebook's disk space instead. On the positive side, they'll be getting no data to mine since they already know what I do there.
- mccr8 14y agoYou can easily disable those emails by changing around your Facebook settings.
- AznHisoka 14y agoDoes it give you a friendly email address or is it just random numbers (or your fb id)? For instance, if your facebook username is "AznHisoka" do they display aznhisoka@facebook.com ?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- itsprofitbaron 14y agoIf you don't have a username then currently its your FB id although, if you do have a FB username then the @facebook.com email is the same.
- Zev 14y agoI didn't set a Facebook username, and Facebook force-assigned me one for this email address.
- itsprofitbaron 14y agoI'm assuming you have timeline as I still have friends on Facebook who don't have it and their user number = fb email
- itg 14y agoI have a Facebook username (first initial and my last name) but it gave me random numbers for my @facebook.com email.
- xtractinator 14y agoSmooth move Facebook engineers.
- dexen 14y agoObligatory jwz quote: ``Zawinski's law of software envelopment'' Every program attempts to expand until it can read mail. Those programs which cannot so expand are replaced by ones which can. (obviously Myspace did not read mail ;-)) [EDIT] In response to http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=patrickaljord http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=patrickaljord below, Myspace introduced email service in mid-2009. Perhaps the above should read, ``(obviously Myspace did not read mail back then when it mattered ;-))''
- patrickaljord 14y ago> (obviously Myspace did not read mail ;-)) Except that it can http://www.myspace.com/guide/mail http://www.myspace.com/guide/mail
- chrisdroukas 14y agoThere has to be a corollary floating around about sufficient user bases.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mintplant 14y agoI just checked, and this has not happened for me. My email address on Facebook is still my personal one. Interestingly enough, even though I have an actual username set, my @facebook.com address is still the numbered user ID.
- JSadowski 14y agoI only wish that when Facebook gave away my email when I connected with other sites that they gave away the Facebook email address. As it is, I almost never give permission to sites because most require an email address. I do not wish to share my real email address just to read an article that has shown up on my newsfeed, but would gladly share my @facebook.com email address
- lambersley 14y agoI'm one of a handful of people who don't have a Facebook account but I'll +1 this comment.
- SquareWheel 14y agoWhenever I come across an interesting "___ read an article" post, I just Google the title of the article.
- idleloops 14y agoTry right clicking (or menu key), copy the url, open new tab (CTRL+T), go to location bar (CTRL + L), and paste (CTRL + V). It's the Javascript I think that hijacks the click.
- yesbabyyes 14y agoAlternatively, click Cancel when it asks you to add the app, and it will redirect to the original article. I think this is what annoys me most on Facebook.
- jaredsohn 14y agoTry a browser extension similar to what was posted yesterday to automate this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4153772 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4153772 At least read the first comment to figure out which one to use.
- JSadowski 14y agoAs it is right now, I have a unique email address setup for Facebook on one of my domains. If anyone sends email to it other than Facebook, it gets instantly marked as spam.... I only wonder why I'm giving Facebook a pass and not marking their emails as spam too.
- crusso 14y agoYay... I'm always looking for more reasons to NOT use Facebook for any communication whatsoever. Thank you, Facebook!
- envex 14y agoDoesn't seem like you're looking too hard -- you know, still having a facebook account and all. If you hate it that much, delete the account :P
- crusso 14y agoWell, yeah. I'm mostly just jabbing at them in frustration at how much other people buy into centering their lives around FB... but I'm not a total luddite. :) Every once-in-a-while, someone from high school wants to get in touch with me and FB is a decent enough honey pot. That said, I am enough of a luddite to not see the need to have a Twitter account.
- icebraining 14y agoGrumph. Not having a Facebook account is not being a Luddite, not any more than not eating at MacDonalds means you hate food.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y agoI generally don't participate in "social media". My Facebook is mostly of invites, updates to businesses I am interested in. I would argue a Twitter account is much more interesting than a Facebook account. Quite a few notable people have Twitter and they are mostly interesting or funny reads.
- jfoutz 14y agoAmusingly, facebook dropped 2 out of 3 test messages from the other address facebook knows about. Seriously, if anything should be whitelisted, it's that. I understand that they want to read my mail. They want to know who i interact with. Why make such a shitty mail client? No POP. no IMAP. Can't view headers. It's not clear how much html is allowed, because they're dropping to many messages. They're not even pretending it's a serious offering. They're just screwing around with settings. edit -- mail lag is 30 minutes now -- <b> <u> and <i> work, <font> and <span> failed.
- kalleboo 14y agoI had my test message arrive straight away... Into their "Other" folder which doesn't generate notifications and nobody ever checks manually.
- user24 14y ago> Into their "Other" folder which doesn't generate notifications and nobody ever checks manually Incidentally, I once missed facebook asking me to interview because their message ended up in that folder.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jfoutz 14y agoI'm pretty sure a html 3.5 subset is what's rendered by mail clients. At least, gmail uses font to change fonts, and span to change color. they were both ignored. this was the raw string gmail generated: abc <b>def</b> <i>ghi </i><u>jkl</u><i> </i><font face=3D"comic sans ms, sa= ns-serif">mno</font><i> </i><font face=3D"courier new, monospace">pqr</font= ><i> </i><font size=3D"6">stu</font> <span style=3D"background-color:rgb(25= 5,0,0)">vwx</span><div>
- FixThisPOSSite 14y agoWhat do you expect from this moronic site, which is still trying to use E-mail addresses as user IDs? The only hope is that this change will be a tiny step toward informing users that they should log in with the string that precedes "@facebook.com". Otherwise, it's just dumb and dumb: http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/06/forcing-people-to-use-e-mail-address-as.html http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/06/forcing-people-to-use...
- jaredsohn 14y agoIt seems like they didn't change your previous preferences but rather added a new one and changed how they interpret preferences as to what is displayed. If you look at your list of e-mail addresses, it will let you choose who to share it with if it should be shown on timeline. Previously I had a real e-mail address that was being shared with friends and another real address that was for 'only me'. When I looked at my preferences today, I saw that those settings remained intact and that it added a third @facebook.com address that was being shared with only me. I think the second field might be brand new. It says either "Shown on timeline" or "Hidden on timeline" and when I looked today it showed both of the email addresses that I had previously set up as hidden and the new facebook.com one as shown. If they would have just marked the e-mail address that I had set up to be shared with friends as "shown" and added the @facebook.com address as "shown", I (and suspect many others) would be happy and it would still allow them to emphasize that people can use @facebook.com e-mail addresses. (Some people might not like this for spam reasons, but I think this is would be far less evil than what they did.) Also, since they don't share e-mail addresses via the social graph or have other ways of viewing data, what is the point of differentiating 'show on timeline' with specifying who you share it with? None of the other fields (phone number, IM screen name, address etc.) include this "show on timeline field" but rather set visibility based on the sharing settings. It seems like the "show on timeline" field is completely unnecessary and was only added to get the effect that we're all talking about. (So this was clearly evilness rather than incompetence; for some preference system changes one could argue that it was necessary to 'break' old preferences since the new ones were so different, but that isn't the case here.)
- desigooner 14y agoFWIW, I had my real email addresses showing before this weekend and when I checked this morning, the only email address that was being shown was the @facebook.com one. My other 2 email addresses (one visible to each of my friends and one only to a close few) were hidden from my timeline. Shady!!
- Periodic 14y agoI can confirm. I had my wife check my account, and she has the most liberal viewing privileges of my profile out of anyone I know. She now only sees a @facebook.com email address. My primary address, @gmail.com, is no longer visible under Contact Info on my profile.
- thefreshteapot 14y agoA few weeks ago, my facebook account appeared in the list of "linked to your facebook". I deleted that connection, yet still my email address has changed to this new facebook account. Unhappy.
- melvinmt 14y agoDisplaying FB addresses is not so bad, what I'm more concerned about is that I just tried sending mail to some of my friends' facebook addresses and nothing shows up..
- mtgx 14y agoThis is so much worse than anything Google has ever forced upon users with Google+.
- Fargren 14y agoI don't think it's worse than the "obligatory real name" thing. This at least can be fixed by a savvy user by changing preferences.
- kjhughes 14y agoFacebook also requires real names: http://www.facebook.com/legal/terms http://www.facebook.com/legal/terms
- drivebyacct2 14y agoWhat has Google "forced upon users" with Google+? Especially given that you can still remove G+ from your large Google profile (for now at least)
- stfu 14y agoOne thing that I still find highly annoying is the auto Youtube login.
- spindritf 14y agoWhat's an "auto Youtube login"?
- samstave 14y agoGoogle tried to get users to link their gmail accounts and youtube accounts. Thus, if someone sent you a youtube link in gmail and you clicked it - you would be logged into youtube already/automatically so that they can track your viewing behavior.
- 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cfqycwz 14y agoThis morning my mother was complaining that many of the email addresses in her Droid Razr contacts had been replaced with Facebook ones. It would seem the Facebook app had been populating her address book with emails and contact photos, and decided to migrate all her Facebook-using contacts over to this convenient new system. That seems like a much greater controversy to me than Facebook hiding people's email addresses.
- zhoutong 14y agoYes, and how about iMessage and FaceTime that require email addresses in contacts to work? And also the 3rd party sites that rely on Facebook OAuth API to identify users based on emails (they could use uids, but I'm sure some are still using email).
- kennywinker 14y agoConspiracy theorist in me wonders if this move might have anything to do with the new facebook integration in iOS... millions of iPhones are about to start automatically pulling contact info from facebook, wouldn't it be nice if all those people started using their @facebook.com email address?
- nickheer 14y agoSince this change, I haven't seen any difference in my contacts. It looks like it's still pulling all available email addresses, not just facebook.com ones.
- kennywinker 14y agoI assume you're running iOS 6, yes?
- nickheer 14y agoYes indeed.
- sheckel 14y agoWow. This thread just alerted me to the existence of that 'other' mailbox. I had no clue that existed. That could have saved me some trouble; I just found this message from last July: http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/1792/screenshot20120625at359.png http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/1792/screenshot20120625at35...
- grandpoobah 14y agothat must make you angry
- petitmiam 14y agoI just wonder how many millions of messages that have gone unnoticed. I've seen a few articles written, alerting people to it's existence, but it's not like people are searching for articles on things they don't know exist.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoYou what this is? This is money people having too much say on the product. I have no doubts this is so they have one more metric to impress (number of emails exchanged thru Facebook). Then they will proceed to selling paid messages for advertisers.
- washedup 14y ago"Force" seems a little strong. However, I am surprised I heard nothing about it until the change was already made. That's the part that makes me uneasy.
- shellox 14y agoFacebook is the electronic total surveillance, just on a voluntary base. They have enough users and nobody seems to care much about it, so it won't get better.
- systematical 14y agoReeks of desperation, but really who cares?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- biafra 14y agoDoes anyone know how to forward that address to a real email address which I can access with an email program? Is there an Facebook API for those Messages? Facebook chat can be easily plugged into my XMPP client (except for group chats). I'd rather not delete that address because I do not want someone else to have it. But as it is now the email ends up in a subfolder of Messages called "Other" and I am in no way notified about them unless I happen to click on Messages and recognize the small unread count beneath "Other". This is really useless.
- jbverschoor 14y agoCrap thing changed the primary email address of the contacts n my iphone ios6
- taysh555 14y ago?
- 17587176117 14y agoI am block on face book want too unblock too talk with my friends
- geoffhill 14y agoJust go into your About Me and enable "hidden from timeline" for the @facebook.com email address. Now everything is back to normal.
- bitskits 14y agoThe fact that you can easily change it back doesn't make it ok for FB to make these kinds of sweeping changes. Again, FB shows its poor stewardship of user account data. I'll happily continue only using G+.
- jimhefferon 14y agoAnd, they won't let me enter "Scheme" as a language. It is tyranny. Years from now, when people say "remember 2010 and Facebook?" I'll remember. :-)
- aniro 14y agoThe Manson Family. Note that "family". A controlling psychopath or cult requires cutting off access to outside resources, preempting a possible escape path. No different.
- pcwalton 14y agoCould we please not take the trendy HN cynicism so far as to equate Facebook with mass-murdering serial killers? It's a social networking site.
- dredmorbius 14y agoAnd Charlie and Co were just a happy song-and-dance love society until they weren't.
- aniro 14y agoMy point was not to equate the murderous behavior. I see that you might find such a comparison distressing. Facebook is circling the wagons on its user base. I see no one this benefits other than Facebook itself. While promoting effortless and frictionless sharing of every last minute detail of daily life and thought within the Facebook "family", they are now very actively creating massive amounts of friction in order to prevent people from sharing with the same people anywhere else. They are closing the exits in a defensive move to prevent people from leaving. This is not good social behavior. This is what cults and psychopaths do in order to exert control. This looks like the behavior of an entity with mal intent.
- aniro 14y agoThe Manson Family. Note that "family". A controlling psychopath or cult requires cutting off access to outside resources, preempting a possible escape path. No different.
- FixThisPOSSite 14y agoWTF, who has their real E-mail addresses SHOWING on Facebook in the first place?
- liamgriffiths 14y agoNot sure if it is related, but I noticed my "Political Views" entry was also removed quite recently. Was previously "other". Anyone notice similar changes to user info?
- nimblegorilla 14y agoI already use google as my preferred giant corporation with access to every email I send. I wish there was a way to turn off all facebook messages or at least send an auto-reply saying that I rarely respond to facebook messages.
- watmough 14y agoThis is nothing but a fairly desperate attempt to gain email address share, and promote Facebook lock-in. Think about Joe Average User who spends a bunch of time on Facebook. If people start emailing them at JoeAverageUser@Facebook.com, then they can scarcely abandon the site...
- leke 14y agoI can just see it now. There will be ads with your face endorsing products related to email correspondence.
- invisible 14y agoThe sad thing is that Facebook probably thought "Hidden from Timeline" was the appropriate setting since every opt-out thing they've done in the past has bit them in the ass. Now they do an opt-in for "Shown on Timeline" and they get bitched out. The only unfortunate thing is that you cannot see emails to which you should have access to that are not marked as "Shown on Timeline". Complain about bad UX, not a security (in some ways) setting that is opt-in.
- parfe 14y agoNo, they hid my previously viewable external email address and replaced it with their own. Facebook literally tried to hijack communications intended for me.
- lucian303 14y agoThis is good for a lot of ignorant users who don't know they're displaying their real email to the world.
- namank 14y agoWell, this is actually a good thing given Facebook's mission, "Making the world more open and connected." To do this, you have to have public profiles. Do you want your personal email to show up on public profiles? But Facebook email, on the other hand, probably doesn't matter (at least not right now when the "open" paradigm is still in infancy.). Its OK to be shown to random people and search engines and other features that come down the pipeline.
- jorgecastillo 14y agoThank god, I don't have a Facebook account.
- jusben1369 14y agoThat's it! I'm canceling my subscription to Facebook. Oh wait. Oh yeah.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wwweston 14y agoIt's a brilliant plan, really. What they really wanted is for everyone to list their real email address, but they knew that if they forced that, everybody would be up in arms, so they forced the opposite change instead. ;)
- oohaba 14y agoNot sure if this has always been a "feature" of Facebook's email service, but apparently you can login with the facebook email address. A would-be hacker only needs to guess your password. Case in point: a friend has already told me there have been renewed attempts to log into her account from other locations and devices.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kespindler 14y agoAlright, I'm tired of this. Can everyone please shut the hell up about Facebook 'forcing' people to change their e-mail address? Facebook isn't forcing you to do shit. They changed the default e-mail address that appears in your profile. I'm happy about this. It means all my Facebook friends have a way of contacting me that isn't my primary e-mail address, meaning that type of communication is easily compartmentalized and thus taken care of.
- lnanek2 14y agoReminds me of foursquare. I can't, for the life of me, get it to post pictures to my facebook feed any longer. I've tried reinstalling, posting with a camera picture, posting with a gallery picture, relinking facebook, tapping the icon on and off, making sure picture is public, etc.. I'm pretty sure they disabled this functionality so they can show the map instead which gets them more clicks into their site proper and helps their traffic. Really pisses me off because I take a picture every check in and think they are more interesting and don't think people should be forced into foursquare to view them and don't want to have to post them separately - then in their marketing material for the new face lift they even show a picture of a facebook post with a picture. Lies.
- tobtoh 14y agoWith Facebook making this change, I guess anyone who is unaware of this and syncs their Facebook contacts to their phone (either directly or via apps) stands to lose the 'real' email addresses of their friends and especially once they sync back to their desktop/cloud/gmail etc!!
- bad_user 14y agoOn my Android the Facebook details are in a separate bucket than my Gmail contact details. So the Facebook sync hasn't overridden the email addresses that were manually entered by me or have been synced by Google's Contacts. But on the other hand I'm seeing a lot of new Facebook email addresses in my contacts.
- bad_user 14y agoSo I just disabled the Facebook contacts sync on my phone, because as of today it is useless for me. I'm also thinking of uninstalling the Facebook app, because the web interface is good enough for me, and I kept the Facebook app just for the contacts sync.
- dudus 14y agoGood luck with that. I can't uninstall the facebook app because my carrier decided that this app is not optional. It just can't uninstall. Android Samsung Galaxy S2 on Rogers
- LoneWolf 14y agoRoot it, install titanium backup, remove it (if its not rootable then there is no way that im aware of). That's what I did for my HTC desire so I could remove the crapware (fb app included) on it.
- delosfuegos 14y agoWhy is the facebook sync useless to you? Our service (connex.io) also syncs with facebook (among others) and we are always interested in learning more about our customers. If you feel like explaining it to me in a bit more detail, you can send me an e-mail: michael@connex.io. Or you can just answer here and I'll follow the thread.
- saket123 14y agoI really feel this is the right moment to give other social networks a chance. I am so tired of FB and all their antics . If only my friends were there on G+.....
- jsilence 14y agoIf only other social networks started using distributed social protocols like OpenID, Activity.streams, Salmon, OAuth, FOAF. Don't crave for a nicer walled garden. Instead start tearing down the walls.
- saket123 14y agoI am really glad that G+ does not give right access to external apps. It prevents the network from getting spammed , help to maintain cleanliness of the content and really helps in relevant discussions rather then water my farm kind of posts.
- cefarix 14y agoSo that's why I've stopped receiving spam to my GMail account.
- vilya 14y agoThis has got me thinking that it's time to ditch Facebook. I'd like to use Google+ because I think they're more likely to be a trustworthy steward of my data, but I find the UI really confusing. Are there any other realistic alternatives?
- motters 14y agoI assume that this is an attempt to take advertising revenue away from other webmail providers. So if facebook's users become predominantly known by their facebook email address then their friends will just begin sending directly to that address and bypassing other systems.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- snitzr 14y agoI checked my settings and already hid my facebook.com email. My non-facebook address was sill visible. Anyone else not have the problem from this HN article link? I keep up on my privacy settings.