12 ms·
Malthusianisms
- jamesaguilar 14y agoNot all of these are actually even the case, to say nothing of the responses being correct. For example, wedding clothing isn't that expensive, and the people I've wanted to date have for the most part never been cruel or aloof. Just because an explanation sounds obvious doesn't mean it is correct.
- TheSOB88 14y agoEh, I think some of these are circumstantial. The dating one probably applies to a very specific type of person. This is the one that does it for me: Why are even some affluent parts of the world running out of fresh water? Because if they weren’t, they’d keep watering their lawns until they were. It's all about greed/constraints/pressures/incentives/desires. People want to use water, but people don't have an incentive to keep water use down. Instead, they put pressure on engineers to bring availability up. And when availability, or supply, goes up, demand comes back in to seal the gap.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoEconomics was aware of overconsumption of underpriced resources before Thomas Malthus. It's not really a Malthusian observation to say that if a good is priced lower than the cost of acquiring it, it will be over-consumed.
- npsimons 14y agoEh, I think some of these are circumstantial. The dating one probably applies to a very specific type of person. Yeah, some of these are gross oversimplifications; others are just wrong. Take the shaving one for instance. You can get a very close shave and not cut yourself, and have been able to for as long as straight razors have been around. The reason people cut themselves is not because they want a closer shave, they want a shave that takes less time and money. If you didn't cut yourself this time, you obviously didn't go fast enough and don't need to buy a new razor. Razor gets dull and nicks you? Don't sharpen it (that takes time), chuck it in the trash and buy a new one. And working 90 hour weeks? That assumes that you provide more value for those 90 hours versus 40, which may not always be true. Work smarter not harder. As for the dating one, cruel, aloof or insensitive people are by definition not the type I would want to date.
- fulafel 14y agoThat "some" really pulls the rug out from under it. It becomes pretty circular. "People who waste water do it until it runs out."
- mcherm 14y agoWhy does the quality of a news site like slashdot, digg, reddit, or Hacker News deteriorate until it reaches annoying levels? Because if it didn't, then more and more people would join, reducing the average quality of the participant pool.
- tokenizer 14y agowhich is a good thing considering by the time that happens to reddit, kn0thing will have made his impact, and will be able to do whatever else he wants, and somebody else's site will be the new and popular one (until it is).
- astrodust 14y agoReddit crossed that event horizon a year ago. People inside just haven't realized yet.
- bgilroy26 14y agoThat's true. The only thing that Reddit has going for it is that has a way to build new communities built in. /r/DepthHub, /r/math, and /r/askscience are doing just fine.
- guth 14y agoThe "only" think Reddit has is an engine to sustainably produce new communities as good as the original Reddit, at the cost of providing a pile of chaff I dislike that thousands of people enjoy? I would love to have "only" what Reddit has.
- baq 14y ago/r/askscience is nearly 600 thousand subscribers, that's hardly 'only'. subreddits are as good as their moderators and that's also true of HN.
- astrodust 14y ago
- Estragon 14y agoWhy are our personal reproductive choices so rarely informed by these Malthusian dynamics, let alone by the enormous personal burden involved in raising children? Because a nation/ethnicity/clan/family whose culture is comfortable with honest consideration of such questions does not grow as fast as one in which reproduction is seen as a crucial to identity and survival (both that of the group and that of the individual), and in which critical consideration of reproductive behaviors is rejected as perverse, judgmental or selfish.
- rfugger 14y agoThis is well-stated by Garrett Hardin in his classic 1968 essay "The Tragedy of the Commons": http://dieoff.org/page95.htm http://dieoff.org/page95.htm
- billswift 14y agoHardin overstated his case, for much better and more nuanced treatments, go to Google Scholar and search for "Elinor Ostrom" "Tragedy of the commons". She won the 2009 Nobel in economics, largely for her work in how "the commons" really are managed.
- scythe 14y agoMalthus introduced exponential growth rates, but not equilibria; he assumed a runaway growth would lead to collapse. Logistic functions, which describe equilibrium-finding, were introduced by Pierre Verhulst. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Fran%C3%A7ois_Verhulst http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Fran%C3%A7ois_Verhulst John von Neumann and John Nash deserve some credit for founding game theory; in particular the strategies described are minimax strategies, introduced by von Neumann. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimax
- SiVal 14y agoI agree that these aren't Malthusian, and some aren't even true. The ones that are true seem to exemplify incentives and constraints. When you have an incentive to do more, you do more until either the incentive (marginal_benefit - marginal_cost) or your ability to do a little more fades to zero. When the incentives or constraints change, the behavior adapts accordingly. A Malthusian collapse is a special case that is not relevant to most situations of incentives and constraints.
- CWuestefeld 14y agoBut the reason that Malthus' doom-mongering hasn't come to pass is because he failed to consider that there was sufficient incentive for people to find alternatives, such that they could skirt the constraints. Malthus said that the carrying capacity of Earth is limited to X because of finite arable land (and so on). But then humans came up with irrigation, and crop rotation, and terracing, and selective breeding, and fertilizers and insecticides, and powered machinery, etc., all of which allowed the Earth to provide for ever-increasing numbers of people. Malthus saw humanity as limited to subsistence dirt farming, but the people saw the ability to prosper, have large families, etc., as sufficient incentive to invent alternatives. The incentives didn't change, and the constraints only changed so far as did the body of human knowledge.
- slowpoke 14y agoIt is true, though, that there is a limit to how much people this planet can reasonably sustain, and I'd say we're billions over that mark - the only reason the system still works (barely) is because a large part of the world's population lives in poverty and hunger. Optimization will only get you so far. We simply can't optimize away the fact that there is limited space on this planet and that we're pretty much out of it already. We can't sustain 7 billion people, tendency growing. Not at a humane average living standard.
- scarmig 14y agoWhy do positive feedback loops always end in a counterbalancing negative feedback? Because if they didn't, they'd continue until they hit one.
- tocomment 14y agoHere's another one. There can never be too much traffic, because if there were, people would stop driving.
- sp332 14y agoI heard that for over 100 years the actual speed of traffic in London was 9 miles per hour. If traffic started moving faster, more people drove. If it got slower people wouldn't bother driving. Not sure if it's true or not but it sounds plausible :)
- guth 14y agoSame thing with matter/antimatter, and "white flight" demographics. Also, the more energy-efficient we make our technology, the more energy we will use in total. Any tension not in a buffered solution will collapse to dominance by one-side. This one, though: > Why can’t everyone just agree to a family-friendly, 40-hour workweek? You can choose to opt-out of the rat race, and still be happy. Some other too. Yes, to a first approximation, there are no easy problems (or free lunches), so only attack problems you'd love to solve.
- zem 14y agothis one (from the comments) i'd truly never thought of before: > Why are so many people having to get fertility treatment to have children? Because if they stayed fertile longer, they’d put off having children even more.
- adavies42 14y agowhy do people repost three-year-old articles? because it's easier than finding new ones saying the same thing. this is like anthropic reasoning--always true, rarely useful.
- gojomo 14y agoWhy would a 'new [article] saying the same thing' be any better? Aaronson has a parallel post about Anthropicisms, which seems to share your skepticism about their value: http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=101 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=101 For the 'Malthusianisms', I'd agree the name isn't exactly right, and I could quibble with his specific examples. But the observation that things are in their current and often 'sucky' state because some balance between tensions has been reached is often useful. It can help us get past frustration or superficial ranting about a situation, to investigating the real forces at work. And, while some could take from this analysis fatalism, I think it instead highlights what's necessary to be effective. Simply tugging a little in the direction of one of the existing forces is rarely the best path to change. You've got to approach such dynamically-balanced situations from an oblique angle, and apply other forces/insights to jump it to a new equilibrium.
- kfk 14y agoThe OP has seriously misunderstood Malthus. Malthus never got to understand that resources are relative and prices too. That's the same problem with people saying we are doomed because oil is finishing: there will be alternatives, prices will go so high to incentive real research on alternative energies. And the examples are mere examples of economic incentive, not even that clear if you ask me. But then, what do I know, I only studied this stuff.