5 ms·
Instagram Teen Accounts
- dmitrygr 2y ago> Teens will get notifications telling them to leave the app after 60 minutes each day. It is insane that someone thinks that an impressionable child/young adult wasting ~ 1/16 of their waking time every day on this drivel is OK! But, I guess profit motive gotta win over sanity. I could justify "5 minutes", maybe "10 minutes". But I am not the one making money from selling their attention and selling them pointless shit. In my household the policy is and remains: kids can have instagram/facebook/tiktok/$latestMindRottingShit when they buy their own phone and their own cell plan.
- kayodelycaon 2y agoMost people spend that much time watching YouTube or TV everyday, if not more.
- dns_snek 2y agoDepending on the type of content one consumes, those activities are a net positive, or at least neutral. Meanwhile social media is a net negative for nearly everyone except "influencers" who get paid to shill for products and services.
- moab_desert1 2y agoAs an adult I agree on principle, but how old are your kids? The social pressure to be present in these things must be tough to deal with as a teenager. Can they still access it on a computer?
- dmitrygr 2y agoI was an uncool outcast in school. Now, the "cool kids" from my high school bag my groceries when I go shopping. Social pressure is what got them to where they are. Not succumbing to it is what got me to where I am. I am OK with my kids hating me for now. They'll thank me when they can afford things they want while the former "cool kids" waste their lives bagging cabbage.
- JohnMakin 2y agoDo you think popular people in highschool don’t become successful? Because I assure you this is a faulty assumption.
- ziddoap 2y agoI was an uncool outcast in school. It has affected me negatively to this day, 20+ years later. At least a handful of the "cool kids" from my school are wildly successful millionaires.
- dns_snek 2y agoI urge you to take your kids' complaints seriously, your comment reads quite dismissive with some strange generalizations of how "cool kids" and "outcasts" will do later in life. Pressure can turn some people into diamonds (you, apparently), but it can also crush them psychologically.
- apsurd 2y agoVery surprised that you or anyone thinks 60 minutes each day is "a long time!" I agree that anything past 15 minutes undeniably unhealthy. But large masses of people are very commonly online for hours upon hours. And all along and alongside there's TV. So this 60 minutes seems very out of touch.
- dmitrygr 2y ago> But large masses of people And I would consider myself a failure as a parent if my kid aspired to such a low standard as "like large masses of people"
- apsurd 2y agoI'm speaking toward empathy perhaps. I agree that values shouldn't be relative to some lowest common denominator. > It is insane that someone thinks… This is overly critical. Social media is an addiction. We're an a new epidemic and we have to assess how to respond. We should be discussing treatments in a similar vein of drug rehabilitation. So I think shooting for your kids to only get 15 minutes is the right value, but very tricky and risky in how one gets there.
- Eumenes 2y ago> We should be discussing treatments in a similar vein of drug rehabilitation. Have you been through a drug addiction? I have. I wouldn't compare having an account on a social media platform to being addicted to hardcore drugs. It doesn't make you sound very smart.
- apsurd 2y agoOnline account is not the same as being addicted to hardcore drugs. You made that up just now. Social media is addictive, like a drug addiction. And there's a spectrum to it.
- TZubiri 2y ago"Daddy can be online 10 hours a day but it's ok because he is being paid money." Gee I wonder how that can go wrong.
- Eumenes 2y ago> In my household the policy is and remains: kids can have instagram/facebook/tiktok/$latestMindRottingShit when they buy their own phone and their own cell plan. Based
- moab_desert1 2y ago"[...] help ensure their time is well spent." I struggle to think of time on Instagram being well spent. Perhaps less badly spent? Also I wonder how they'll do age verification and "parent" verification, might end up being very trivial for most teens to work around the restrictions using secondary accounts. Thinking about it, the policy might be more for show than anything else.
- jakefromstatecs 2y ago"I struggle to think of time on Instagram being well spent. Perhaps less badly spent?" There are a lot of people that use Instagram to follow artists for inspiration for art. This seems like a pretty good way to spend time.
- moab_desert1 2y agoIn my opinion the addiction cost likely outweighs the benefit in this particular example, especially since there are so many other less addictive ways to get inspiration for art.
- bamboozled 2y agoAgree, the price is too high for 30 seconds of actual inspiration per week.
- TZubiri 2y agomessaging and sharing pictures with friends?
- omegaworks 2y agoIt remains to be seen whether these controls will have an impact on the second-order / emergent effects of rampant social media. Would prohibited words or time-limitations stop the algorithm from making an embarrassing moment viral? What happens when these strict restrictions cut someone off from their support systems?
- philip1209 2y agoWe should really just raise the age of COPPA from 13. It’s a robust legal framework and we can amend one line in it to regulate this industry without excessive bloat or bickering. It’s crazy that Americans can be on Instagram 8 years before having a sip of alcohol. We should raise the COPPA consent age at least 16, but probably 18.
- ceejayoz 2y agoBarring some kind of effective globally enforced age verification system, good luck.
- llamaimperative 2y agoWhy does it need to be global?
- ceejayoz 2y agoBecause other countries can host websites too? And their citizens can sign up for Instagram. “Oh, I’m Russian, we don’t have that.”
- llamaimperative 2y agoHaving to download a VPN and do some evasion would probably be a substantial enough deterrent for… [checks notes]… 14 year olds… that it’d be worth doing. And realistically, if Meta et al wanted to stop harming entire generations of developing minds, they could obviously use their immense data infrastructure to separate actual Russian from allegedly-Russian children. So all you really need is corporate buy-in (and toothsome regulations is a perfectly fine way to produce buy-in where markets fail to do so) Edit: realized you’re talking about the case of Russian services being marketed to American children. That too seems straightforward to produce meaningful obstacles, with sufficient appetite from regulators.
- op00to 2y ago
- encoderer 2y agoCool. Like lite cigarettes.
- fraboniface 2y ago> We know parents want to feel confident that their teens can use social media to connect with their friends and explore their interests, without having to worry about unsafe or inappropriate experiences. Or how to ignore the fact that the problem with social media is not harmful content, it's the social media itself. The addiction, the loss of time, and the constant comparison with others. Go design a social media without those.
- wubrr 2y agoTrue, but the things you mentioned are the (unhealthy) reason social media is so popular.
- 31337Logic 2y agoAnd we all know that being popular is the most important thing at all times. :-/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wubrr 2y agoIt's pretty much the most important thing for for-profit social media companies, yes.
- agoodusername63 2y agoI'm not really sure that's possible. Cohost tried and well, they died. The nature of social media just leads to it's very unhealthy problems. By taking away the ability for social media to make viral posts, you take away a lot of the reason people use it. To see popular posts and memes. Then nobody uses it, so nobody sees the ads, so advertisers leave, etc etc. Personally, I'd be happy if we all went back to interest forums that aren't reddit. But I'm not going to pretend that age is going to come back without deeply overreaching legislation.
- 2y ago
- insane_dreamer 2y agoA good start. Should also include the ability for the parent to approve any new follows by the teen, not just new followers. Still not letting my kids have social media accounts (FB, IG, TT, X) until their later teens (messaging groups with friends they already have -- Messenger Kids, despite being a FB app, is pretty good for that).
- polemic 2y agoMy younger ones use Messenger Kids and it gives me some confidence that Meta has thought about the problem and have solutions that actually work for all parties.
- deafpolygon 2y ago> that Meta has thought about the problem and have solutions They just want to ensure that when the kids become "of age", that they'll still be on Meta's services in some shape or form.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoYes, for sure it's self-serving. But at least it's useful for us parents.
- 4b11b4 2y agolol
- polemic 2y agoMessenger Kids was a pragmatic effort by Meta to improve safety on the Messenger platform. It works well, and it looks to me like Instagram Teen accounts is a similar effort. You can bemoan the effects of social media or whether teens should be there but the teens are there, so credit to Meta for making a serious investment. Always lacking in these conversations is a proper definition of "social media". Kids want to talk to their friends, many want to be social, so if we're going to talk about the dangers of social media we need to be specific. E.g. the problems with algorythmic content are entirely different to the issues of bullying and inappropriate direct messaging. Conflating them under a "social media is bad" banner doesn't help us build healthier, safer systems.
- 7e 2y agoThe teens are there because Meta hooked them and brought them there. No credit to Meta at all.
- 7e 2y agoNow introducing menthol cigarettes! "Part of this healthy lifestyle."