3 ms·
When Fact-Checks Backfire
- oldpersonintx 2y ago"fact checking" is a psyop first of all, the "fact checker" simply claims the mantle of objectivity with no supporting evidence. why is some nameless writer at Snopes the arbiter of truth? because they say so? and all "fact checks" merely knock down a strawman to reinforce some hand-wavey political point. here is every fact check: CLAIM: Democrats are great CHECK: true!
- rtkwe 2y agoThe actual power of objectivity isn't just from claiming it though. If you have a blatant history of obviously biased checks it'll lose power quickly as stories about your checks get tagged with your history. They're still useful within closed media ecosystems but the people in those are already looking for confirmation from anyone 'objective' or not.
- richbell 2y agoI think "fact checking" has lost its legitimacy in the eyes of many people — and journalism in general. You can't convince people that something is objective when it has an obvious bias. Think of The Washinton Post's absurd "fact check" of Bernie Sanders. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/bernie-sanders-medical-bankruptcy-washington-post-fact-check-878120/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/bernie-s... Granted, we know that some beliefs are incredibly resistant to contradicting evidence, and can even result in people doubling-down (e.g., anti-vax). (Ironically, I don't have a citation for this at hand.)
- delichon 2y agoThe fact that someone can gain credibility by announcing that they are a truth teller explains way too much about the reliability of garden variety human empiricism.
- adamrezich 2y ago“Fact-checker” is just a sad last-ditch attempt to salvage this “Arbiter of Truth” status from the smoldering remains of the once-respected “journalist” profession.
- susiecambria 2y agoI agree. But at the same time wonder if there are just some folks who are contrary and use facts when it suits them and ignore them when not. I know in one case, the person is simply always right. So in this case, it's a personality thing more than a fact thing.
- JohnClark1337 2y ago[dead]
- cormorant 2y agoSeems like no one so far actually read the article (podcast transcript).[†] Bottom line: the "backfire effect" doesn't replicate. They managed to cause a backfire effect by phrasing their "fact checks" in a deliberately vitriolic way. This should surprise nobody, and to me, only confirms that the general "backfire effect" isn't real. [†] Including me. I used Kagi Universal Summarizer and then spot-checked it. https://kagi.com/summarizer/index.html?target_language=&summary=takeaway&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theatlantic.com%2Fpodcasts%2Farchive%2F2024%2F09%2Ffact-check-polarization-opinion-politics%2F679898%2F https://kagi.com/summarizer/index.html?target_language=&summ... or pastebin[.]com/z0qx45tG
- Spivak 2y agoIt's crazy to me how much the US internet despises fact-checking when we just watched a debate where a candidate unabashedly lied about easily verifiable information for an hour and would have gotten away with it if not for the moderators stepping in to call out the bullshit. The value fact-chekers provide is context, not the rating-- where did they get this information, does their statement follow from it, and is the source reputable / corroborated by others. The thing that keeps fact-checkers in check is academic discourse. If someone is doing a poor job then write yourself a Re: and publish it. The "psyop" is convincing people that truth doesn't exist and you should just immediately discount anyone who presents an argument that disagrees with your pre-existing biases. The back-and-forth is the point. Anyone can be a fact-cheker, it uses the same skills you all learned in highschool to write papers. I can understand not liking the label "fact-checker" because it implies some unassailable source of truth, and I agree I would have called them critics or reviewers, but I don't get to choose the language that catches on.
- adamrezich 2y agoMy favorite part was when they immediately fact-checked the statement that US soldiers are not currently deployed in any active combat zones, which not only demonstrated the even-handedness of their fact-checking rigor but also proved that truth—not partisan media bias or running cover for the current regime—is and should always be the ultimate goal of any media fact-checking initiative. Oh wait that didn't happen lol
- Spivak 2y agoNPR called her out for this and gave it "mostly false" despite it being true but misleading and required a confirmation from the DoD. What did you want to happen? "Just a moment Vice President Harris, I need to get on the phone with Kirby to confirm this before we continue." https://www.wusf.org/politics-issues/2024-09-13/politifact-fl-harris-debate-remarks-us-military-combat-zones-misleading https://www.wusf.org/politics-issues/2024-09-13/politifact-f...
- adamrezich 2y ago
- KoolKat23 2y agoHumanity needs ground truths or we just descend into anomie.
- gruez 2y agoYeah, but that's not why people are upset about factchecks. They're upset about it being used in nitpicky ways in an attempt to score political points, eg. https://x.com/NBCNews/status/785299709342654465 https://x.com/NBCNews/status/785299709342654465
- sickofparadox 2y agoOr when they "fact check" a statement with 4 paragraphs of text that amount to "it's true but inconvenient so we'll say it's been 'fact checked' to undermine the statement." https://www.nytimes.com/live/2024/09/10/us/debate-trump-harris-fact-check/now-she-wants-to-do-transgender-operations-on-illegal-aliens-that-are-in-prison?smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/live/2024/09/10/us/debate-trump-harr...
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoSome people are upset about that. Some people are upset that their politically convenient lies are being challenged.
- KoolKat23 2y agoAnd ironically more chaos/anomie, we can't even trust/agree on what we're upset about.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- KoolKat23 2y agoThis is also why I wish political slogans were better worded. Yes it's catchy but others dismiss it at face value when there is perhaps some truth to whatever nuanced grievance they're trying to express. Further polarising debate.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]