2 ms·
Absolutely, what we need to solve all humanity's problems is more moon rock. If only we had enough moon rocks, things would be just so much better. Why can't th
by simonh 14y ago
Absolutely, what we need to solve all humanity's problems is more moon rock. If only we had enough moon rocks, things would be just so much better. Why can't the paper pushers and beureaucrats just get with the program and give us our moon rocks?
How much moon rock do you think we need? A dozen tons? A hundred tons? Wow, imagine what we could achieve with a hundred tons of moon rock. Why, the sky's the limit!
Which pressing need of humanity for moon rocks do you think we should tackle first?
- rimantas 14y agoYeah. Imagine the same kind of thinking many many years ago: why would we play with fire—it burns! Why should we leave the cave? Why should we sail the seas?
- simonh 14y agoWhy shouldn't I wear my pants on my head and run down the street naked? Maybe I'll start a new trend. Note that I'm not against us going to the moon. The fact is we've done it. So now if we're going to do it again, all I ask is for an actual reason to do so. If it turned out that fire had no actual useful applications and was just horrifically dangerous, we would perhaps have experimented with it briefly and then forgot about it. We wouldn't still be habitually setting everything around us on fire, just because. It turned out that fire did have many useful practical applications though.
- ericd 14y agoYou're really missing the point of going to the moon really, really hard.
- arethuza 14y agoWhich was to get to the Moon before the Soviets?
- simonh 14y agoCan it be a coincidence that the moon rock-poor USSR collapsed while the moon rock-rich USA is now the world's only real superpower? OK, so maybe I'm pushing this a bit...
- cema 14y agoUSSR was not moon rock-poor, it had a reasonable amount of moon rock extracted by automatic space craft (more precisely, space craft not inhabited by humans). The point of reaching the Moon is different, it's to spark the imagination and inspire. And one of the reasons the USSR collapsed is, btw, the ideas it was based on were not inspiring any longer (an understatement!)
- simonh 14y agoUSA: 382 kg USSR: 0.32 kg Recovered from meteorites: 48 kg But that's from Wikipedia, so you can add a few grains of salt to those figures. One of the main reasons the moon missions were cut short is because the public lost interest, just as they did with the Space Shuttle. The inspiration argument only gets you so far, and we've been that far already.
- ericd 14y agoThe original point was competing with the Soviets and generating national pride, sure. The point now would be to get practice with the harder problems of survival in space, as a trial run for the marathon that is going to Mars. Every time we as a nation do something that seems audacious, we raise the morale of the nation and energize the populace to work harder on pretty much everything else. We could certainly use a shot of national pride to the arm after the events of the past decade...
- jlgreco 14y agoDo you really think the reason we have not returned is because the resources were diverted to solve "humanities problems"?
- simonh 14y agoThey were diverted to solve some problems faced by some humans. Problems that would not have been solved otherwise.
- ricardobeat 14y agoYou're right, what we need is weaponry. Lots of it. To solve problems.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoWe should return to the moon because people want to go. Is any additional reason really needed?
- simonh 14y agoActually you're right. That's a perfectly good and reasonable point. If people want to go to the moon, they should be at liberty to do so. If you want to help them, perhaps you could donate money to the cause. Heck, let's make it tax deductible. Just checking though - you're not suggesting using any of my money, or other taxpayer's money to send them, right? Because if so, we're back to needing one of those good old fashioned actual reasons again.