2 ms·
Some people refer to these as "indulgences", like the certification of having your sins forgiven that the Catholic Church used to sell before Martin Luther (and
by pjc50 2y ago
Some people refer to these as "indulgences", like the certification of having your sins forgiven that the Catholic Church used to sell before Martin Luther (and half of western Europe) got mad about it.
The effect is to either shift the attribution of emissions to some other company who doesn't care, or to cause renewables to be double-counted.
Consider a toy grid, with two users A and B and generators C(lean) and D(irty). All connect to the same point. A buys a certificate saying that 100% of their energy comes from C. But that does not inform B about anything - they might reasonably look at the grid and then claim that 50% of their energy is clean, when in fact by arithmetic 100% of it is dirty because all the clean stuff has been bought by A.
See e.g. https://industrydecarbonization.com/news/the-trouble-with-european-green-electricity-certificates.html https://industrydecarbonization.com/news/the-trouble-with-eu...
- Ekaros 2y agoAlso I have always wondered about this model. Electricity is only fungible in the moment, not on longer scale. So let's say C goes entirely offline. How many of A instantly stop using any power? B can happily use the D as overall on long term it will balance out, but A should not be able to use any power.
- pjc50 2y agoElectricity is momentary, but REICs are not, so you can just buy some more from a different time period. It averages out, right?
- maxerickson 2y agoThe toy grid example is cute, but in practice, billing does happen.