6 ms·
Inside Apple's Thunderbolt to Ethernet Adapter
- pieter 14y agoSo how does this work? Shouldn't it have a Thunderbolt controller on there somewhere too?
- potkor 14y agoMaybe the thunderbolt cable is short and well-shielded enough that they can just run plain pci express over it.
- kika 14y agothunderbolt IS the PCI express bus (plus Displayport)
- potkor 14y agoIt carries the pcie protocol but pretty obiously it's not electrically identical to pci express (external cables and connectors don't generally provide as good signal integrity as required by pcie that is happening on your motherboard).
- DrJ 14y agothere is one on the other side..
- gcb 14y agoSo, there's no space in a mac for a ethernet port? what's the advantage or serializing a pci-e bus into some 4 or so pins? They must be certain that ethernet port is a thing of the past.
- metatronscube 14y agoI'm a network Engineer and even I have to work hard to remember the last time I used an Ethernet port. Configuring routers and switches and testing scenarios are mostly done remotely via labs (although I do configure and test locally a lot as well) As far as end user goes and my daily life outside work, I very rarely use Ethernet. I suspect the average user just doesn't have the need for it any more.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoIf you use voip or do any online gaming a wired connection is faster and more reliable. I suspect the average user uses one of these. They should just make a thinner ethernet jack.
- bodhi 14y agoRight, and they could give you a dongle that had a proper RJ45 jack on the other end! Er... hang on...
- mixmastamyk 14y agoYes, could be a converter cable, could be a dumb dongle. Either would be cheaper.
- lmm 14y agoThe price is all Apple markup; the actual chip costs pennies.
- ghshephard 14y agoVOIP? You just identified the _single_ example of an application that has minimal requirements for bandwidth (on the order of 30-40 kbits/sec is fine). I live, eat, breath on Skype, have never had a single Skype call over a wired connection. Ironically, the one persistent flaw in my recent Skype calls have been my comcast line that periodically starts dropping 3-5% of it's packets so I've had to switch over to tethering over my iPad with Verizon's Data (also wireless - so, Wireless WIFI from my MBAir over Wireless LTE) - Rock solid.
- ghshephard 14y agoThe 5% of users that do need an ethernet cable will be well served with a thunderbolt/USBx adapter without holding back the other 95% of us greedy bastards who continue to demand thinner/lighter.
- andreasklinger 14y agoDon't you think it is? I can't remember the lasttime i used an eth cable (apart of testing the network/router)
- kelnos 14y agoI use one every day. WiFi is unreliable and slow.
- unimpressive 14y agoDepends. Ethernet cables have saved me quite a few times while installing Linux. (But that's irrelevant to apple, they don't even need to concern themselves with drivers.) Besides that I haven't really needed an ethernet cord all that often for my laptop. (Or at all really.) For my desktop, depending on your definition of "use" (If that means installing an ethernet cable, or connecting to a network with one.) I last used one a few weeks ago, or right now.
- rogerbinns 14y agoOn the Mac you can enter wireless network information in the equivalent of the BIOS menu so wireless networking is available early on. About the only time I physically connect some of my machines is for a network boot to install Linux.
- X-Istence 14y agoThose of us who work in classified locations or on classified projects are not allowed to use wireless. Also, since when have we been able to push 1000 Mbps over Wireless?
- codeka 14y agoI'd say that particular use case is rather uncommon. It's not that wired ethernet is never required, just that wireless is perfectly acceptable for the vast majority of users.
- 14y ago
- maybird 14y agoPerhaps the average consumer's satisfied with wireless speeds, and it would make economic sense to reduce the production cost of the average system by removing the ethernet port.
- ROFISH 14y agoFunnily enough, yes, there is not enough space. If you look at the Macbook Air or the new Retina Macbook Pro, the cross-section is too small for a full-sized ethernet port. For reference, the ethernet port takes up the entire height of the "old" MBP.
- fiatpandas 14y agoEven if they wanted to include ethernet, the retina MBP is so thin it wouldn't be able to fit an ethernet port along the edge. Look at this image for reference: http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/1183987/mbp_comparison.jpg http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/1183987/mbp_comparison.jpg It barely fits on the normal MBP. The only way it could fit on the edge of the Retina was if they cut through the bevel, which would be ugly.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoIn a Macbook Air? No, there certainly isn't. Even other notebook manufacturers are hitting a thiness where ethernet is not possible. They just have tacky hinge pieces that fold down to allow the ethernet connector to slide in.
- sern 14y agoInterestingly, the Retina MBP has a combo Ethernet MAC/PHY + memory card reader chip of which they're only using the latter function. I would guess that either the decision to drop the Ethernet port was made pretty late in the process or the board designers were kept in the dark about the mechanical design until it was too late to pick a different part. Also, a PCI-E lane actually is 4 pins :) Edit: reply to dead - standalone memory card reader ICs are standard components. The USB SD ICs they used in earlier models would have been easier to route (than the PCI-E combo chip) and probably cheaper.
- Morg 14y agoWell you guess wrong, Apple doesn't get much stuff made for them specifically, far less in the PC segment. I.E. they mostly use standard components, and that would be why they have a combo chip instead of the right stuff, as in many cases. Their SSDs are overclocked mSATA where they should be pcie, and there are many more stupid design decisions or just ease of production compromises that I won't even take the time to look at the black pcb to find out. Main thing is, most companies have suboptimal PCBs, and that doesn't matter much.
- gte910h 14y agoThey have a SD card reader
- gmac 14y agoI note from Anandtech's review that there were serious problems with the SD reader in earlier models, so perhaps they were deliberately avoiding those ICs?
- masklinn 14y ago> So, there's no space in a mac for a ethernet port? There isn't even enough depth in the machine, they would need to cut out through the lid to have the room to put an ethernet port (not even talking about the Air there, just the new MBP). Even on the current "pro" macbooks, there is only a thin piece of case above and below the ethernet port (about a third of a mm), and the new MBP is significantly thinner[0] > what's the advantage or serializing a pci-e bus into some 4 or so pins? Flexibility, speed, and doubles as a video adapter (and a PCI-e lane is 4 wires already, the work is not there) [0] http://www.zdnet.co.uk/i/z5/illo/nw/story_graphics/12june/macbook-pro-retina-martin-7.jpg http://www.zdnet.co.uk/i/z5/illo/nw/story_graphics/12june/ma... bottom is the old MBP, top is the new one, note how the flat side of the new MBP is barely thicker than a USB port.
- hammock 14y agoYou could always orient the ethernet port so it is sticking out the top of the body (or even the bottom, with a cutout to allow the wire to exist under the body) rather than the side. Of course this is far from an elegant solution, but it's not 100% accurate to say the MBP is "too thin" for an ethernet port. edit: I did not expect such response to this comment, I think it's quite funny :)
- Flow 14y agoAnd make it look like a FrankenBook Pro? :-/
- caladri 14y agoThis seems like a silly point to pick on. Why is the MBP so thin? Because of design considerations and the desires of the target market. The design considerations are a serious component of the Apple brand, perhaps the single most distinguishing component. To compromise on the design to work-around the thinness which is in service to the design would just be pointless. It may not be accurate and complete and without flaw, but it is a reasonable reduction of the reality of Apple hardware to an understandable and useful form. The difference in thickness is profound, and would have been compromised itself, or have forced a compromise elsewhere in the design of the base hardware platform, without the removal of the Ethernet port due to physical space constraints that arose from the level of space reduction that was possible with this revision of hardware. I think that's a pretty interesting point. The Thunderbolt adapter is a design compromise and a crappy one, but it is a general-purpose one (i.e. there is a consistent peripheral platform) and one that will not impact the vast majority of users. Copper Ethernet is not at the top of Apple laptop users' desire, as one might note conversely design is. There's a sort of elegance in systematizing the edge cases and making the base case streamlined, minimal, satisfactory, beautiful and shockingly-thin.
- haberman 14y agoA Thunderbolt port can be Ethernet, FireWire, DisplayPort, HDMI, or native Thunderbolt. The flexibility of that makes a port that can only be Ethernet seem like a total waste of space (especially at twice the size).
- ricardobeat 14y ago> They must be certain that ethernet port is a thing of the past And they are probably right. For consumer applications, wi-fi already fulfills most needs right now (faster than most internet connections and spinning HDs), and it's getting faster[1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ac http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ac
- gcb 14y agoI stand corrected. Pcie can be 4pin (same pinage as usb, power and data pairs) if you drop lane, jtag, smbus and intelligent power support
- evoxed 14y agoUnfortunately I think it'll take until MacBooks and iPads are literally as thin as paper (edit: hyperbole) before Japan becomes truly wifi friendly... 'til then, I'll appreciate my current MacBook and not having to carry around that dongle everywhere.
- rangibaby 14y agoThere is plenty of semi-public Wifi in Japan. You're ostensibly meant to pay into a seperate contract, but anyone who buys an iPad gets a password to use Softbank hotspots, good for two years[1]. http://store.apple.com/jp/buy/home/shop_ipad/family/ipad/new_ipad?product=MC705J/A&step=accessories http://store.apple.com/jp/buy/home/shop_ipad/family/ipad/new...
- spicyj 14y agoI wonder if it's possible to use this as a PCIe-to-Thunderbolt adapter – as far as I can tell, all existing packaged products are at least $500.
- iridium 14y agoIs it the angle of the photo - or did he just melt the pcb in Photo#4 in order to wipe out the A and figure out what chip it was?