3 ms·
The argument seems to be that not buying property was a good decision, because investing that capital into a startup instead produced a better ROI than property
by _delirium 14y ago
The argument seems to be that not buying property was a good decision, because investing that capital into a startup instead produced a better ROI than property investment would have.
But is that the normal case? What are median returns for property investment versus self-funded-startup investment?
- swalsh 14y agoI think the argument is not as much, that it was a better ROI, but rather the opportunity costs of buying property would have been more expensive.
- ams6110 14y agoFor me the part that hit a nerve was this: "Nobody likes to have debt and as soon as you have it, you become restricted in what you can do." Most of us hear the constant refrain of what a good idea home ownership is, and how it so much better than renting, when you take into account the mortgage interest deductions and appreciation. And that's all true, but what they never really emphasize is that once you take out a mortgage you've got that $1,000 monthly payment (for example) that you've got to meet EVERY month, for the next 30 years or until you sell. And you have insurance, property taxes, maintenance, etc. Carrying long-term debt and especially owning a home really does impact your thinking. You become more risk-averse. You start thinking that a steady paycheck is a better idea than taking the risk of starting a business. As time goes on, you feel like you have MORE to lose because you've been paying on the debt for a while and you actually have some equity. It's why banks view mortgages with equity as lower risk, and why car insurance is cheaper if you own a home. As far as buying property as an investment, i.e. renting it out, the "common wisdom" is that you make your money when you buy. You absolutely need to get a really good deal when you buy, because the rent you're able to collect will basically be a break-even on your expenses, so wnen you eventually sell your profit is a function of your purchase price. Unfortunately a lot of people pay too much for houses that they think are in a "hot" rental area, and they never really make any money on them.
- Domenic_S 14y ago> what they never really emphasize is that once you take out a mortgage you've got that $1,000 monthly payment (for example) that you've got to meet EVERY month, for the next 30 years or until you sell. And you have insurance, property taxes, maintenance, etc. You've got a similar obligation if you rent. Rent or buy, you're still out on the street if you stop paying. > Carrying long-term debt and especially owning a home really does impact your thinking. You become more risk-averse. Meh, student loans, the ultimate long-term financial obligation, didn't make me risk-averse at all. I'm slightly more risk-averse today -- and I do own a home -- but I attribute a great deal of that to getting older. The prospect of starting over from 0 becomes less appealing the older you get. > As far as buying property as an investment, i.e. renting it out, the "common wisdom" is that you make your money when you [sell]. You absolutely need to get a really good deal when you buy [...] Yes. If you're considering buying a place that you'll possibly rent out in the future, you need to be serious about it and do your research. When I was scouring the internet for articles and forums about it, I was shocked to see just how serious -- and * unbelievably fiscally conservative* the people are who buy rentals seriously are.
- mattm 14y ago> You've got a similar obligation if you rent. Rent or buy, you're still out on the street if you stop paying Not really because usually you just need to give one months notice to move out. So if you are facing hard times, it would be easy to move to a cheaper place or completely move to another place where there is more work to be found. A person that "owns" his own house would only move as a completely last resort because the costs associated with it are much, much higher.
- Domenic_S 14y ago> Not really because usually you just need to give one months notice to move out. Depends on the terms of your lease. [1-3]-year leases are common out here, in which case you'd have a problem on your hands if you gave a month's notice. > A person that "owns" his own house would only move as a completely last resort because the costs associated with it are much, much higher. That also depends on the situation. If there's equity, they may make money by selling. It's impossible to compare these situations except to say that if you don't pay your landlord or bank, you're out.
- Estragon 14y agoNo, the argument is that he could comfortably experiment with starting his own business because his financial obligations are minimal. If I had bought a property I would have had to service the gap between the rent and the interest repayments along with other costs like maintenance etc. If I could buy a property outright, or if rental income serviced the debt and made me money, then I’d buy property but it never does. On his last point in that quote, I can't actually find it now but I believe I read on Calculated Risk recently that rental income will service the debt from a recent house purchase at this point. Now really is a great time to buy. :-) (In the US. The Australian market is still insanely overheated.)