7 ms·
John Carmack "not all that excited" by next-gen hardware
- MPSimmons 14y agoNot to be cynical, but if I'd just released a 3d VR headset, I'd be pitching it, too.
- slurgfest 14y agoAnd if I were as wealthy and respected as Carmack in the industry (and as sharp) I would also be building rockets, supporting Linux gaming and similarly quixotic but awesome enterprises.
- its_so_on 14y agoI love that supporting Linux gaming is "quixotic" and up there with rocket science. Too true.
- adventureful 14y agoIt's a hack, it's not meant to be a broad commercial product. It's not much different than the test engines he builds for experiment. You're indeed being unnecessarily cynical.
- MisterBastahrd 14y agoI'm not all that excited about John Carmack's antiquated view of the video game market. While there are companies releasing swaths of titles in different genres, he's got... Doom 3. Yay, whatever. Most people will not spend $500 on a peripheral. You can get some hardcore gamers to do it, but unless the VR gear also includes a wireless headset, you're shit out of luck. So now you're looking at close to $600 bucks a unit. Good luck with that. I'd rather buy a 48 inch TV that I can use when I'm not gaming.
- bluthru 14y ago>So now you're looking at close to $600 bucks a unit. Good luck with that. The 60gb PS3 launched for that amount. From what I've read in other articles, Carmack's goggles are 1/10th the cost of comparable units.
- slurgfest 14y agoJohn Carmack has written 3D engines widely used in commercial games for decades now (most recently Rage - whatever its demerits as a game, the technology is cutting edge and the game is definitely not antique). Whether or not you liked the content in Doom 3 has very little to do with Carmack's very technical, back-end work. When the 3dfx boards came out, they cost something like $500. But it still opened up a big market. I don't see why you are assuming that a wireless headset is necessary and will not be included. Buy a TV if you want, all you've shown is that you are not in the targeted market at this early stage. (Probably because there is no way to provide that kind of hardware at lower cost, particularly without more traction) Carmack is certainly wealthy enough already, I would assume that his interest in VR headsets is that he is a geek who wants to move the state of the art forward (not too different from the reasons for doing Armadillo Aerospace)
- ctdonath 14y agoI don't see why you are assuming that a wireless headset is necessary and will not be included. Wireless VR is very important. Getting tangled in cables while you're physically thrashing around sucks. Trust me (owner of original Virtual iGlasses).
- waterlesscloud 14y agoWell, the kit cost $500. Once it's in the hands of a company that can mass produce, the price could be substantially lower. And with console manufacturers, there's always the possibility they'll sell hardware at a loss to move software. The point being we don't know the final end price yet. The real concern there is the Big Corp will compromise the design just enough to make it uninteresting.
- Tooluka 14y ago
- cldrope 14y agoThanks for spamming hacker news with multiple of the same article. I hope your karma rating is worth the damage it does to the community.
- JVIDEL 14y agoDude, Carmack was never a consoles guy, he didn't like the Genesis nor the SNES, he didn't like the Playstation, Saturn and N64, etc... If he was excited by nextgen consoles, now THAT would be news...
- SwellJoe 14y agoDid you read the article, at all? The point is what he is excited about, which is developments in VR.
- JVIDEL 14y agoYeah, 5 days ago, with next-generation he means consoles, not VR HMDs
- adventureful 14y agoAnd yet he did like the Xbox 360.
- brooksbp 14y agoas well as Microsoft's static analysis tool for Xbox 360 development!
- starship 14y agoThe 1990's were fifteen years ago. Since then Carmack has spent 60 hours per week writing code for every conceivable console, PC, and mobile platform. Most people in his position would have moved into management by this point, he chose not to. As a result he has more expertise on more topics than just about anyone else in the gaming industry. And more than most in computer science generally. If he has an opinion on something, its because he knows what he's talking about.
- JVIDEL 14y agoI'm not saying he doesn't know what he's talking about, he just never liked consoles, he was always a PC guy and if he were truly "excited" about the nextgen that's like hearing Armstrong will quit riding bikes and be a F1 pilot.
- frou_dh 14y agoI found John Siracusa's summary of the march-of-progress on Hypercritical insightful. Along the lines of: > Processors can never be fast enough, memory can never be big enough. If you take your favourite device 20 years in to the future and try to convince people that it had been "good enough" to settle down, they'll rightfully laugh in your face. --- Then again, it's a double-edged sword if increasingly advanced ways to bombard you with distraction, or make trash jingoistic war games, come along for the ride.
- phoboslab 14y agoI love how Carmack is constantly pushing the industry forward. He made raycasting engines when everyone else was still doing 2D stuff. He made fully 3D games when everyone else was still using raycasting. He built a game engine with completely dynamic lighting, when everyone else was still relying on lightmaps and some cheap hacks. Arguably Duke Nukem 3D looked better than Quake, but polygonal was the future. Half-Life 2 looked better than Doom 3, but dynamic lighting was the future. While everyone else keeps iterating current technology (often to astonishing results), Carmack does something new - something that may have a lot of drawbacks initially, but will be the future. I see the same happening in other industries - take Tesla vs. any other automobile industry out there for an example. I haven't been this excited about a new piece of gaming hardware since I got the N64 for my birthday back in 1996. I'll buy it! (Of course it's not only Carmack who is doing research in that department. This post isn't so much about praising him, as to praise innovative thinking.)
- pestaa 14y agoExactly. First I didn't understand why MegaTexture was implemented in a production-ready game (Rage) because it made lots of texture look like a decade old, but I guess Carmack sees the future in it.
- Negitivefrags 14y agoRage was a huge shame (tech wise). They needed to be able to ship more data to make the tech really shine. The game was 3 DVDs as it was but it needed to something more like 8 or 9 DVDs. It just feels like such a shame for the graphics to look bad for want of the ability to ship data to the customer.
- piechlediech 14y agowhile rage did not push the state of the art of graphics cards, it runs well on older hardware and there is nothing that comes close to it there.
- zanny 14y ago
- motters 14y agoIt doesn't sound as if anything has been done about the VR sickness problem. Wearing bulky screens in front of your eyes probably doesn't have much of a future, but I think that augmented reality using something like the EyeTap device has a much bigger future which extends significantly beyond gaming.
- Negitivefrags 14y agoMy understanding is that the sickness was in large part due to the latency (Solved by Carmack). Beyond that it's just a matter of getting the perspective correct (Also solved by carmack).
- motters 14y agoIt occurs if there's a sustained mismatch between your vestibular sense and visual odometry. That's ok if the game only involves looking around in a fixed position, but if the avatar is walking/flying then you're likely to get VR sickness, no matter what the frame rate is. Apparently, VR users do habituate to the effects after a few days, in the same manner as space sickness, but in the intervening period there can be some unpleasantness.
- 6ren 14y agoI knew someone working in VR about 20 years ago, and the big problem then was latency - if there's too much delay between when your head moves and the scene is rendered at the new orientation, it just doesn't work. IIRC the eyes are sensitive, in this respect, to delays of less than a movie frame's 1/24 sec. Carmack is both very concerned and very knowledgeable about latency in rendering, so it seems likely that he's solved this problem... but I haven't seen it explicitly addressed in anything I've read about his recent work. It might help his advocacy if he explained why this tremendously exciting thing failed last time, and that he's solved it, to overcome the "VR winter".
- staunch 14y agoHe's talked about this exact issue and is addressing it. http://www.pcgamer.com/2012/06/06/john-carmack-is-making-a-virtual-reality-headset-500-kits-available-soon-video-interview-inside/ http://www.pcgamer.com/2012/06/06/john-carmack-is-making-a-v...
- kalleboo 14y agoThese videos were more interesting than the OP. Hearing him geek out about all the things he's tried to make it work well makes me really excited for the stuff that's in the pipeline.
- warp 14y agoAnother video from E3: http://www.giantbomb.com/e3-2012-john-carmack-interview/17-6164/ http://www.giantbomb.com/e3-2012-john-carmack-interview/17-6...
- nohat 14y agoHe addressed that in a video here http://www.pcgamer.com/2012/06/06/john-carmack-is-making-a-virtual-reality-headset-500-kits-available-soon-video-interview-inside/ http://www.pcgamer.com/2012/06/06/john-carmack-is-making-a-v...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cenuij 14y agoCan you see how gamers might empathise with this but as a corollary? `gamers "not all that excited" by next-gen gaming engine` Rage was a boring game, built on a series of boring games that were seemingly more often developed as a showcase for licenees than for gamers.
- ivankirigin 14y agoIs the related kickstarter active yet? Link?
- nixarn 14y agoNot yet, it was planned to go live 1.5 weeks ago, but some "good news" delayed it by 2 weeks, so it should probably go live this week. And the good news might be some great hardware partner(s).