2 ms·
What do you mean, "anti-competitive"? There is no rule of competition that says you need to reveal trade secrets to your competitors.
by tptacek 2y ago
What do you mean, "anti-competitive"? There is no rule of competition that says you need to reveal trade secrets to your competitors.
- n42 2y agoisn't it such that saying something is anti-competitive doesn't necessarily mean 'in violation of antitrust laws'? it usually implies it, but I think you can be anti-competitive without breaking any rules (or laws). I do think it's sort of unproductive/inflammatory in the OP, it isn't really nefarious not to want people to have easy access to your secret sauce.
- tptacek 2y agoIn what sense is not giving your competitors ammunition "anti-competitive"? That seems pretty competitive to me. More to the point: it's almost universally how competition in our economy actually works.
- n42 2y agoI think maybe we're just disagreeing on a legal interpretation vs a more literal interpretation of a term that is thrown around somewhat loosely. fwiw I agree with what you're getting at with your original response. maybe I'm arguing semantics. the more I think about your point that this is just competitive behavior the more I question what the term anti-competive even means
- pixelbro 2y agoCompetition is important for maintaining a healthy marketplace. Any behavior that makes it harder for others to compete, reducing the amount of competition, is therefore bad. That's what anticompetitive means. I don't think protecting trade secrets is sabotaging the competition though.
- n42 2y agoI think sabotage is the word I was looking for!
- kobalsky 2y agoyou can use chatgpt to learn about anything ... except how an ai like chatgpt work.
- tptacek 2y agoYou can use Google to search about anything, except the precise details about how the Google search rankings work.
- kobalsky 2y agoyou can search about it all you want, google won't threaten to ban you. and google gives everyone the possibility of being excluded in their results.
- tptacek 2y agoThere's all sorts of things you can do to get banned from Google apps! This is not a real issue. It just recapitulates everyone's preexisting takes on OpenAI.