3 ms·
i'm disappointed in brian mcmanus every time i watch a 'real engineering' video and find out that it's full of factual inaccuracies, like all the previous 'real
by kragen 2y ago
i'm disappointed in brian mcmanus every time i watch a 'real engineering' video and find out that it's full of factual inaccuracies, like all the previous 'real engineering' videos i watched. you'd think i'd learn, but i keep confusing him with 'practical engineering', which is actually real
- cruffle_duffle 2y agoWas going to say… I love the practical engineering channel but that channel doesn’t really dive deep enough into any one topic to encounter any factual inaccuracies.
- kragen 2y agoadmittedly, it does fall far short of being practical; if your preparation for building a railroad is watching https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqmOSMAtadc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqmOSMAtadc and your preparation for building a landfill is watching https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRx_dZawN44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRx_dZawN44, your trains will derail and your garbage will leach into your groundwater but that's not really a difference between the two channels; real engineering manages to pack plenty of misstatements into videos that are equally superficial
- blagie 2y agoI find Real Engineering to be pretty good for aerospace, and horrible for everything else. There are errors, but no more so than any other resources I've seen on aerospace. The problem I have is that it's trying to do electronic engineering, fusion, and now history. The worst is interviews / human interest / travel / behind-the-scenes, etc. My question is always: Why? Why do you think you're at all qualified to do a better job than the people who specialize in this? If I had a choice, the Nebula-exclusive content would go more into math or deeper engineering: How does a jet engine work? That kind of thing. But yes, Practical Engineering is very, very good.
- gverrilla 2y ago> and now history I told him not to that unless he has actual knowledge, and he got very angry at me. On the occasion he made a very poor analysis of political and social situation of an African country (that's all I remember).
- kragen 2y agomaybe he has personality problems that make it hard for him to interact with people more knowledgeable than himself; that would explain why his videos are so filled with errors stated with absolute conviction
- blagie 2y ago> On the occasion he made a very poor analysis of political and social situation of an African country Cultural sidenote: I do the same (although in personal conversation; I would obviously never do that on Youtube). I am very happy to espouse on topics I have little knowledge of, as did most of the community I spent time in when I was in grad school. This is looked down upon in most mainstream cultures, but it's actually very helpful. If I espouse something incorrect, someone can correct me. I learn something. It's a form of constructive / interactive learning which I find hyper-productive, and we did that all the time. It's also helpful in social situations. The point isn't to convince you of something, so much as to communicate the state of my brain to you. That makes it much easier for us to debug who is wrong where. Of course, that's completely incompatible with: > he got very angry at me Conversations got heated but never angry. There's a distinction: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/04/opinion/sunday/kids-would-you-please-start-fighting.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/04/opinion/sunday/kids-would... What I struggle with is that in mainstream Western culture, this mode of communication comes off as arrogant, and conveys many subtexts which I don't want to convey. Part of that is that we expressed too much confidence when making those statements, but that's maybe 10% of the problem; even expressed with modesty, it mostly breaks in mainstream Western culture (and 90% of the other cultures I've been in; parts of Eastern Europe tolerate this a little bit better).
- kragen 2y ago