4 ms·
The auto companies are strategically significant because war footing America will turn those F150 lines into tank lines in a matter of months instead of the yea
by bombcar 2y ago
The auto companies are strategically significant because war footing America will turn those F150 lines into tank lines in a matter of months instead of the years it would take to spin them up from scratch.
IBM made machine guns on typewriter lines in WW2.
- mulmen 2y agoExactly correct. Good time to skim https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willow_Run https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willow_Run. Years of startup problems but when it finally started humming they were building a B-24 every 63 minutes! In the meantime existing factories were winning the war. As Americans we tend to glorify the industrial feats of WWII but the US government used a very heavy hand to pull that off. Public-private partnership is the preferred euphemism today but essentially we were a socialist economy.
- bombcar 2y agoAt its peak, the US had 40% of GDP going into the war. Forty percent! Today the US military budget is 3.4% of GDP. Can you imagine it being ten times as much?
- newsclues 2y agoIf America goes to war it will need many f-150s for the war itself.
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoNo it won't, because only about 30% of F150 parts are made in the US. The rest are made elsewhere - mostly China. This is not 1940, and the US simply doesn't have the strategic industrial base it used to. Off-shoring made some people a lot of money and lowered consumer costs (while simultaneously cutting consumer pay.) But it was economically and strategically unwise. The US is set up to run small-scale wars against technologically inferior opponents. It has no ability to sustain a prolonged multi-year slug-fest against an opponent with a superior manufacturing base.
- Dalewyn 2y agoConsidering the US hasn't won a single war against technologically and numerically inferior opponents since the turn of the century, I think we have even more fundamental problems than just a rusty war machine dependent on Chinese blue jeans. Now granted I might be unfair to the US here; the Middle East is known as the graveyard of empires for a reason.
- bluGill 2y agoThe US clearly choose to lose all wars lost though. The military was doing just fine, but the people back home got sick of the efforts.
- vundercind 2y ago1) That’s still losing. 2) I’m not sure the military was doing just fine in all of those. Vietnam comes to mind, but also Afghanistan—reading the Afghanistan papers, the brass seems to have given up on any kind of actual goals or accountability in favor of a system that let them continually cycle officers through and let them claim they succeeded at their mission (funny, they all keep achieving their mission, but facts on the ground remain exactly the same or worse!), for years and years. Fighting fitness may have been OK throughout, but military leadership in the military itself was absolutely not committed to any kind of winnable mission, let alone to actually winning it. That may have been driven (I’m sure it was) largely by civilian leadership, but the entire upper echelon of military leadership betrayed their commands and the soldiers counting on them, to keep up a convenient (to their careers, and a bunch of junior and mid-tier officers who got a big boost to their careers…) political fiction at the cost of any hope of something resembling actual success, and all it took was shitting all over their soldiers and the trust of the American people. I bet Iraq (part 2) was similar. I have some grave concerns about the state of our more-politicized-and-static professional officer corps since roughly Vietnam.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoI'm with you 100% on point #2. Disagree on point #1. We occupied Afghanistan for 20 years. We operated with nearly absolute impunity in all population centers, through all trade routes, and all agricultural areas. Our casualties were a minuscule amount our total forces. Our culture completely transformed theirs (in a way that old school hardliners lament publicly). We killed a huge number of Taliban (and foreign fighters). Clausewitz says that "the political object is the goal, war is the means of reaching it." Can you tell articulate what the political goal of the war was? Thinking back to 2001 (I was in middle school), the goal was retribution. I believe the military achieved that in spades. Yes, in the end Afghanistan did not turn into a US vassal state or a US colony. But was that the goal?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- darby_nine 2y agoSeems like a terribly irrational and inefficient way to run an economy but I'm sure russia will invade any day now. Or is it china these days?
- themaninthedark 2y agoI agree. We should also stop subsidizing agriculture, there is enough food grown around the world for everyone. All this waste is very inefficient! In fact, we dump our cheap overproduced food on third world countries and collapse their ag. sector. If we stopped producing and switched to importing we would boost their economies. Since food can be grown in almost any country on earth, we would have a diverse supply chain. I'm sure nothing would go wrong with this plan./s