7 ms·
Boeing spent $43B on stock buybacks between 2013 and 2019 while paying their CEO ~$30M/year. > To support its share price, the company under McNerney poured bi
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Boeing spent $43B on stock buybacks between 2013 and 2019 while paying their CEO ~$30M/year.
> To support its share price, the company under McNerney poured billions into stock buybacks instead of investing profits into the kind of research and development needed to stay competitive. McNerney decided not to spend billions of dollars building a new plane to replace the 737. Instead, Boeing tweaked and updated the existing model and called it the 737 Max, outfitting it with larger, more efficient engines for increased economy. Compensating for the resulting instability was a secretive automated system called MCAS that would adjust the plane’s pitch without input from the pilot.
> McNerney also fought to deeply cut costs. On his watch, the company opened its first non-unionized aircraft production line and initiated a program called “Partnering for Success” that pushed suppliers to cut their prices by 15 percent or more. Many feared that squeezing suppliers would harm the quality of their components, but McNerney was determined to recoup the cost of the 787’s development; if the subcontractors complained, they could find their work taken away from them, as happened to landing-gear-maker United Technologies Aerospace Systems.
> McNerney retired in 2015, handpicking his successor, president and COO Dennis Muilenburg. Over the next three years, Boeing’s stock price more than doubled as it sold new planes the world over. (As Bloomberg News reported, Muilenberg and McNerney “had personal reasons to emphasize productivity and cost-cutting” because their compensation was tied to share performance. Together they took $209 million in total pay over seven years.)
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/boeing-planes-problems-stock-price-shareholders.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/boeing-planes-proble...
- hinkley 2y agoThey started new factories in new states to try to break the unions in Seattle.
- IntelMiner 2y agoBoeing fleeing Seattle while trying to cheerfully pretend they're a "Washington company" was absolutely disgraceful
- beaglesss 2y ago[flagged]
- sofixa 2y agoThey moved their HQ to Chicago and then DC to focus on government contracts (they suck at those too), so "Washington company" is extra funny.
- extraduder_ire 2y agoI mean, any company based in DC can call itself a Washington company.
- hinkley 2y agoTechnically they also had offices in St Louis after the coup. The MD people moved to Chicago. And I hope every single one of them was a Cardinals fan.
- rob74 2y ago...with resounding success: > In 2019, following the discovery of exterior damage on planes manufactured in Charleston [the non-unionized factory], for a time Qatar Airways would only accept delivery of Dreamliners assembled in Everett [the unionized factory]. (from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_South_Carolina#Quality-control_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_South_Carolina#Quality-...) But then they moved all 787 production to North Charleston, so problem solved.
- hinkley 2y ago> But then they moved all 787 production to North Charleston, so problem solved. That better be some top shelf sarcasm. It’s shameful what’s happened to Boeing. I worked there during the fall. After the bribery scandal, but before MD broke it. It was still okay-ish until they butchered their R&D dept. That’s not a healthy company.
- hsdnd65 2y agoIts not about one or two guys its financial engineering culture that Wall St rewards. You can make bank without being an engineer anymore. 2008 meltdown has not changed the culture.
- x0x0 2y agoAlso, the 25% (over 4 years) they're bandying about as the offer includes (per [1]) a loss of a bonus with a 4% target, and that's an annual bonus. I don't understand how this person calculated, but one of the employees claims it's more like a 10% raise including the foregone bonus. Good deals don't need to be sold with lies. [1] https://archive.is/qVO5D https://archive.is/qVO5D
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoWhy is the CEO pay relevant? It is not even within an order of magnitude of the amounts needed to pay for even the contract Boeing proposed to the union, let alone the union’s demands. People complain about CEO pay as if paying them less would get them what they want. Frankly companies need CEOs, and people who are qualified for the job are very few in number. Whereas the line workers represented by the machinist unions are in trades where there are massive quantities of workers available - which is why many took Boeing jobs even if they were not happy with the pay and benefits. I am also not sure why the stock buybacks are worth mentioning. There are many reasons why a buyback may be the right thing for a company to do. I am aware that sometimes it can be a manipulation of executive compensation by artificially raising the stock price (and may have been so here). And obviously I don’t support that. But I feel like the practice of buying back is attacked by many without adequate understanding of what it is for and how it can be financially good for the company, helping support future investments.
- stevage 2y agoHigh CEO pay is a symptom of poor board control, not a direct cause of poor performce.
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoCEO pay generally has a relationship to company size, and Boeing is pretty big. It would be hard to argue their CEO is overpaid if they paid the CEO that much and the CEO did a good job. Implying the problem is not how much they were paid but rather the quality of the work.
- tempfile 2y ago> Implying the problem is not how much they were paid but rather the quality of the work. Aren't those identical? If you do a bad job, we could have got the same bad job from someone else, who we could have paid less...
- 2y ago
- JackYoustra 2y agoIt's kinda fun, right? The whole point of tying executive compensation to share price was to have them have some rough stake in the business, but even that didn't prove enough: there's always a longer term, and doing a visible, clear NPV boost is usually accretive to market cap even if it introduces long-term risk, because the long term risks are usually hidden from public eye and very mushy. Ironically, I think the poster child for how to properly structure compensation away from this is Hank Greenberg's AIG, where not only was his compensation basically all deferred stock options, they were deferred until retirement, so about as long-term a view as you can get. He was very risk-averse, and his biggest flaw wasn't under his operational ownership but under successor and personnel selection (looking at you, Welch). But at some level, it was just bad people making bad calls. I don't think McNerney thought that this would wreck Boeing, he was just wrong. Even if he was left predictably destitute at the end of such a failure, he probably wouldn't have changed his choices because he thought they were good. You could claim that this is a failure of boards and governance (and, truly, I think boards are by and large really bad and I wish there was a much more pervasive activist investor culture) but at some level I'm not sure how much of this is solvable. I don't know. There's probably a way to do boards well enough that this isn't a problem.
- sofixa 2y ago> But at some level, it was just bad people making bad calls. I don't think McNerney thought that this would wreck Boeing, he was just wrong. Well, he was stupid not to - there's no way he didn't know thay focusing on the short term stock price won't have negative effects on the quality and future of an engineering organisation whose main business, building and selling airplanes, is extremely capital intensive. He came from McDonnell Douglas who nearly bankrupted themselves doing the same sort of crap (pushing suppliers to the edge, cost cutting at every opportunity).
- metaphor 2y ago> [McNerney] came from McDonnell Douglas... Cite? Wiki[1] appears to suggest otherwise. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_McNerney#Career_path https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_McNerney#Career_path
- swarnie 2y ago> Boeing spent $43B on stock buybacks between 2013 and 2019 while paying their CEO ~$30M/year. Boeing share price was up almost 400% in that period. If the business goal was to maximise share price and therefore return for investors over that period it was a cracking success. Since the US government will always pick up the pieces in the event of a failure its a minimal risk stratagy.
- cced 2y agoCan someone explain to me the theory of stock buybacks? How is this not just financial engineering? How are you meant to differentiate companies who’s stock goes up because they’ve been productive and made great products from those that increase their stock prices using buybacks? Are there rules against taking out loans and using them to perform stock buybacks?
- bombcar 2y agoStock buybacks are mathematically identical to dividends if you work it out. And yes, people track that, and yes taking loans to pay dividends is a favorite trick of dying companies.
- darkfloo 2y agoDo you have to pay taxes on dividend under American law ? If so I guess that makes stock buyback better from a point of view of shareholders
- bluGill 2y agoYou pay taxes in Dividends, which is one reason shareholders generally don't like them. A lot of shareholders are also in the savings phase of their life - they are working some other job and don't need the income from Dividends yet and so getting a dividend is a bad thing as it is more money they have to invest (particularly if you have to pay for each trade which is common). Shareholders who are retired like dividends because it is a simple paycheck without needing to sell their shares and they would be paying those taxes anyway.
- Simon_ORourke 2y ago> Muilenberg and McNerney “had personal reasons to emphasize productivity and cost-cutting” because their compensation was tied to share performance. Together they took $209 million in total pay over seven years. Absolutely stunning - those guys will walk away from this mess with more money than God and American aviation will take a backwards step that may take decades to fix if at all... fuming here.
- passwordoops 2y agoIncentives matter. The extremist solution would be to ban executive compensation tied to stock price and some mechanism where every penny more that goes into buybacks/dividends than R&D/CapEx is taxed at 105%. Oh, and make executive and BoDs personally and criminally liable for safety fiascos like the 737MAX. I bet you'll see culture change in a hurry under those circumstances
- gigachadbro 2y agoJust make stock buy-backs illegal. It would streamline a lot of "focus" issues when it comes to financial "engineering" mindsets.
- dh2022 2y agoStock buy-backs are a tax efficient way to send distribute to shareholders. If you make them illegal then the only way left to distribute money to shareholders is via dividends. Want to make that illegal as well???
- Nemo_bis 2y ago"Some mechanism" is called simply taxation. In 1944, the top income tax bracket in the USA was 94 %. Nowadays you'd also need a wealth tax to deal with the perverse incentives caused by past accumulation of stock. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States#Income_tax_rates_in_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_State... https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/03/09/thomas-piketty-goes-global https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/03/09/thomas-piketty...
- markus_zhang 2y agoI have said this and I'll say this again: executives should never have a disproportionate pay comparing to their most senior trench workers (think a very senior, lead engineer). 3-5x should be the maximum. The saying of "oh if you don't give big bucks then you won't hire good talents" is only true to certain extends. Einstein doesn't figure out GR because he wants the cash from Nobel's prize, actually none of the winners probably achieve because of the money. Scientists won't stop inventing because they don't get the big bucks (most don't get big bucks anyway). Carmack would still pump out great code if he stays indie. As long as properly paid, pretty much every real talent would be happy and do whatever they love to do. Giving disproportional pay to executives ONLY attract bad players and TBH some 500 are probably better NOT have an executive. It also creates sort of toxic culture everywhere that people are forced to chase big bucks because average pay is screwed.
- passwordoops 2y agoAlso, the only reasonable response to the saying of "oh if you don't give big bucks then you won't hire good talents" is "you mean the same talent that got you into this mess in the first place?"
- triceratops 2y agoPretty much this. If a potential leadership hire is willing to walk away solely because of the pay then they are clearly not the right hire. Of course they should be well-paid. But the job is about the job, not about the money. If they aren't sufficiently excited by the mere idea of being in charge of the company's products, services, and future direction, doing a good job for customers, shareholders, and employees, then they should look for a different job.
- ericd 2y agoMy reply to this is that the potentially outsized rewards gives Carmack de facto leadership of his next project, because he’s the one paying the bills, and it lets him work on whatever he wants, in perpetuity, without ever having to consider money again. In a system where that’s not the case, then maybe his superior skills are enough to secure a leadership spot, or maybe not, because maybe he hasn’t invested enough in developing his political skills. This is generally a failing of engineers versus business people. Many of the engineer-led companies you see these days are because they were founders.
- jmyeet 2y ago> Boeing spent $43B on stock buybacks I am very sympathetic to this line of criticism but I also find that "stock buybacks" are misunderstood and, as a result, overly demonized. So I just want to explain a few things for anyone who reads this. The question with a corporation is what to do with surplus profits. The first iteration of this was to pay dividends. These legally are paid equally among shareholders. If you distribute $1B in profits and have 100M shares issued then each share gets a $10 dividend. Simple. Additionally, dividends had to be profits so corporate taxes were paid on those. So there are two problems here: 1. Not every shareholder may want a dividend; and 2. The US tax treatment of dividends is bad, specifically double-taxing. as an example, the company may pay 15% corporate tax, pay a dividend with the remaining 85% and then the individual may 50% federal and state taxes on that, leading marginal tax rates of upwards of 60%, possibly higher. (2) has led to some screwy legislation (eg passthrough corporation discounts) so solve what is otherwise a simple problem. Australia has completely solved this problem with so-called "franking credits". This means that $1B of profit is made, 30% taxes are paid and $700M is distributed but it comes with $300M in tax credits. So if you get a $700 dividend, you also get $300 credit with the ATO. If your marginal tax rate is higher than 30% is higher, you may have to pay a little more. If it's lower, you'll get a refund. Now you generally can't borrow to pay dividends until you historically pay dividends. There are a lot of rules around this. Enter share buybacks. This is where the company buys back its own stock on the open market. This reduces supply and hopefully raises the price for remaining shareholders. Some will argue this is market manipulation but it really isn't. It's just a different way of distributin gmoney to shareholders. Unlike dividends, you can choose to take it or not by selling or not. A share buyback has none of the dividend tax problems but it's even better. If you've held for 12+ months you're paying the long-term capital gains tax rate, which can be substantially lower than the marginal income tax rate. But here's the big problem: it's completely fine to borrow money for a share buyback. This loophole needs to be closed. Prior to the IRA and Trump tax cuts, it would work like this: you would leave profits overseas so you wouldn't have to pay corporate tax on them. You'd then borrow money used those overseas profits as collateral and do a share buyback. This should've been illegal. Or, in the very least, any borrowing against foreign profits should be treated by the IRS as repatriation of profits and thus tax is owed. The Trump tax cuts changed how foreign profits are treated. The IRA further changed this with the 15% minimum tax, which was a very good change and one that didn't get a lot of attention. Should a company pay out shareholders or pay its workers more? I absolutely favor the latter. But we shouldn't focus solely on share buybacks because that's a small part of the problem. I'd say what we need is: 1. A higher corporate tax rate; 2. An end to passthrough corporations; 3. End the double-taxing of dividends. Just do what Australia does; 4. All share buybacks have to come from profits only; and 5. An aggressive attack on profit-shifting / transfer pricing to offshore profits.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> Boeing spent $43B on stock buybacks between 2013 and 2019 Stock buybacks should be illegal or at least very difficult to do. They provide short-term gain to shareholders (and the executives who authorize them to prop up the stock price on which their bonuses depend) but can be extremely damaging to the company long-term (by which time the CEO is out anyway, and shareholders may have reaped their profits and moved on), with workers, and the local economy, left paying the price. The worst kind of capitalist poison.