I think what I’m saying is a bit more nuanced than that. LLMs currently struggle with very “wide”, long-run reasoning tasks (e.g., the evolution over time of a

I think what I’m saying is a bit more nuanced than that. LLMs currently struggle with very “wide”, long-run reasoning tasks (e.g., the evolution over time of a million-line codebase). That isn’t because they are secretly stupid and their capabilities are all hype, it’s just that this technology currently has a different balance of strengths and weaknesses than human intelligence, which tends to more smoothly extrapolate to longer-horizon tasks. We are seeing steady improvement on long-run tasks (SWE-Bench being one example) and much more improvement on shorter, more well-defined tasks. The latter capabilities aren’t “hype” or just for show, there really is productive work like that to be done in the world! It’s just not everything, yet.