3 ms·
I think a large part of it is because of Elon Musk's obsession about controlling (if not owning) as much of stack as possible. That mentality goes into even th
by andsoitis 2y ago
I think a large part of it is because of Elon Musk's obsession about controlling (if not owning) as much of stack as possible. That mentality goes into even the things you do not own, but lease.
In the Isaacson biography there's a theme across his ventures, sparked by early misfortune, about being in control of things end-to-end because then you have more flexibility to optimize, make more leaps that can come from orchestrating creative adn bespoke integration options.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoIt's really because SpaceX is Musk's hobby company with the singular goal of putting a colony on Mars. The commercial launches and Starlink are just a way to leverage all the infrastructure they've had to build to make it pay for itself.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- afiodorov 2y agoNo, in this case it is much more pragmatic. Elon has commented on this aspect himself. When he started he thought of just buying rockets and related equipment from Russia on the cheap but quickly found the exuberant prices states want to charge. He then made a first order approximation of how much it’d cost to just manufacture things he needs and it was an order of magnitude lower - thus he bit the bullet and started doing just that. Had the states let him buy things at a fair price may be the controlling of the stack would not have happened.
- schiffern 2y agoHere's story as retold by (now retired) SpaceX engine chief Tom Mueller: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/is-spacex-changing-the-rocket-equation-132285884/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/is-spacex-... > Significantly, the Merlin engines—like roughly 80 percent of the components for Falcon and Dragon, including even the flight computers—are made in-house. That’s something SpaceX didn’t originally set out to do, but was driven to by suppliers’ high prices. Mueller recalls asking a vendor for an estimate on a particular engine valve. “They came back [requesting] like a year and a half in development and hundreds of thousands of dollars. Just way out of whack. And we’re like, ‘No, we need it by this summer, for much, much less money.’ They go, ‘Good luck with that,’ and kind of smirked and left.” Mueller’s people made the valve themselves, and by summer they had qualified it for use with cryogenic propellants. > “That vendor, they iced us for a couple of months,” Mueller says, “and then they called us back: ‘Hey, we’re willing to do that valve. You guys want to talk about it?’ And we’re like, ‘No, we’re done.’ He goes, ‘What do you mean you’re done?’ ‘We qualified it. We’re done.’ And there was just silence at the end of the line. They were in shock.” That scenario has been repeated to the point where, Mueller says, “we passionately avoid space vendors.”
- jp42 2y agohere more such things from Dan Rasky (nasa scientist) about his experience with spacex: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMLDAgDNOhk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMLDAgDNOhk
- heisgone 2y agoI suspect one of the reason behind that is that the supplier is asked to provide a part that cost only a few thousands bucks, but could potentially blow a multi-million rocket. So, each part end up having a sort of implied insurance and over-the-top quality control, to avoid liability. When SpaceX build something itself, it can evaluate the proper risk of each part and doesn't need to add unnecessary markup.
- eastbound 2y agoThat’s s problem in classic microeconomics: The right price is anything between the marginal cost of manufacturing and the total price of the rocket minus $1. Every parts manufacturer tries to extract as much as possible from the leeway in the middle.
- patwolf 2y agoWhat made SpaceX capable of being able to design and build the valve themselves faster and cheaper than the vendor? It makes a good story, but I worry about other companies trying to emulate it when the economics of space vendors might be far different from other industries.
- alright2565 2y agoI'm not sure if this applies to smaller parts like this, but traditional aerospace suppliers are allergic to iteration. Everything must work the first time. You can see this in how many rockets SpaceX has blown up vs. how many ULA has blown up. I imagine it's similar to what we see in software, where we see mega-waterfall projects delivered for the government cost way too much and still fail, and where tech companies & literal hobbyists can deliver higher quality software more quickly by avoiding an overbearing planning process.
- andsoitis 2y agoI think you and I are saying the same thing.
- nomdep 2y agoIt doesn't look like that. You are saying it like it was a symptom of a mental disorder, while he is stating that is the most practical and logical decision.
- dingaling 2y agoAs a benchmark, Aerojet will charge NASA between $70 and $110 million for each new-build RS-25 engine for Artemis. And that's a design that dates back to the 1970s and which flew as the SSME on the Shuttle. SpaceX builds all 33 engines on a Starship for that amount.
- treflop 2y agoIn my opinion, it's not that he wants to control so much as that his goal is going to Mars. Someone that goes to work to do the tasks assigned to them (which applies to both managers and those on the line) vs. someone that goes to work because they want something (e.g. maybe a certain product made with certain features) thinks very differently. The latter has a whole plan and the plan has certain sub-requirements that all feed back into the greater goal. As part of going to Mars, you will likely have to send many supporting missions, which drives the requirement to lower costs. When designing bespoke systems, contracting it out to third party vendors can be expensive. Usually you contract out to third party vendors because they can utilize economies of scale because they have many clients who are asking for the same thing, but there are no economies of scale here because no one has reusable rockets in their catalog.