2 ms·
> “In abstract, the author should add more scientific findings.” “Discuss the novelty and clear application of the work in the abstract as well as in introducti
by gus_massa 2y ago
> “In abstract, the author should add more scientific findings.” “Discuss the novelty and clear application of the work in the abstract as well as in introduction section.”
I don't understand why that are smoking guns. They look like standard problems that can be addressed with standard phrases. Do they appear in absolutely all the reviews of some reviewers?
It's like “We recommend that the paper be accepted after revision.” The interesting part is if the paper makes sense and if the list of recommended revisions make sense, not that they copy&pasted a filler sentence.