7 ms·
Old Easter Island genomes show no sign of a population collapse
- tootie 2y agoIsn't it a buried lede here that the Native American DNA implies they reached South America well before Columbus?
- canjobear 2y agoOr someone from South America reached them. That finding got its due attention a few years ago https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2487-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2487-2
- foobarian 2y agoIsn't this fairly well known already?
- vanderZwan 2y agoI can't answer your question, but on a meta level I would suggest to use "well established" instead, since that is less ambiguous about referring to scientists or other domain experts agreeing on something for various reasons. "Well known" could also be intended to mean that something has become common knowledge among the general public, which I don't think applies here.
- timdiggerm 2y agoIt's been pretty suspected for awhile due to the presence of sweet potatoes in Polynesia. This, however, gives a range of years for when that contact occurred, and that's big. However, the ecocide theory of Rapa Nui has been so popular that, in some ways, finding evidence that that simply did not occur is bigger news.
- gitaarik 2y agoHmm, native Americans were in America before Columbus? Crazy
- vanderZwan 2y agoLet's not be flippant about something GP didn't actually say. The Polynesian people aren't native Americans; as far as we can tell all native Americans came to the continents via the Beringa land bridge in the last glacial maximum[0][1]. However, as others mentioned there have been multiple reasons to believe that Polynesians and native Americans had contact, and this would be more genomic evidence pointing to that. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleo-Indians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleo-Indians [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peopling_of_the_Americas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peopling_of_the_Americas
- billbrown 2y agoThere was a satellite analysis of rock gardening earlier this summer that also had similar findings. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado1459 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado1459
- photochemsyn 2y agoOne of the worst books on this ever written was the very popular "Collapse" by Jared Diamond, which entirely neglects the role European colonialism played in decimating the island's population in favor of a 'they did it to themselves' narrative (which apologists for colonialism naturally embraced). The more accurate historical narrative looks something like this: "In December 1862, Peruvian slave traders landed on Easter Island and captured approximately 1,500 Rapa Nui people, including much of the island's leadership and elite. The raids were brutal, and the kidnapped islanders were transported to the guano islands and plantations on the Peruvian coast. Of these 1,500 individuals, only a small fraction would ever return.Of the roughly 1,500 people taken, it is estimated that fewer than 100 survived to return home. By the mid-19th century, the island's population had been reduced to just a few hundred, down from an estimated 3,000–4,000 before the raids." The invention of ammonia synthesis from atmospheric N2 via the Haber-Bosch process largely put an end to the guano industy and the slave labor that supported it. There's an excellent book, "The Alchemy of Air" by Thomas Hager that covers this history well: https://blog.rootsofprogress.org/turning-air-into-bread https://blog.rootsofprogress.org/turning-air-into-bread
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoI am curious if Diamond has ever done an apology for his incorrect Easter Island theory in Collapse. As I understand it, at the time it was a reasonable conclusion (though even back then it was still highly controversial and lots of scientists disagreed), but in the decades since, it's become obvious this "ecoside" theory is wrong, and this latest study puts the nail in the coffin. So has Diamond ever said "There is new evidence, and I was wrong"? Or is he doing that weird thing that humans often do where they double down on a now obviously incorrect theory because admitting fault is somehow too painful?
- throw4847285 2y agoWell doing that would require Jared Diamond to be a serious scholar and not a pop historian who cares mostly about selling books.
- 2y ago
- anon84873628 2y agoThe Fall of Civilizations podcast, as usual, did an awesome job covering this topic: https://youtu.be/7j08gxUcBgc?si=GGZW_hawmTKTULMg https://youtu.be/7j08gxUcBgc?si=GGZW_hawmTKTULMg
- pipes 2y agoFound that podcast through hacker news. It really is fantastic.
- arthurofbabylon 2y agoI remember in school and in old textbooks hearing the question, “What happened to the Mayan people? They totally disappeared!” and at the same time reading that there are dozens of Mayan languages spoken in the Yucatán to this day. I had the impression that the subject experts just would not accept the possibility that a human civilization might exist that doesn’t resemble what they had preconceived, as if failing to see the sky because it isn’t the exact shade of blue they thought it would be.
- codingdave 2y agoOne of the state parks in Utah (I forget which one), has a sign that says: "Where did the Ancestral Puebloan people go?" With the answer of "We're right here. Come say hi to us at the information desk."
- rnoorda 2y agoI don't know if it's the one you're thinking of, but I believe I saw a similar sign at Capitol Reef National Park.
- throw0101b 2y ago> "Where did the Ancestral Puebloan people go?" With the answer of "We're right here. Come say hi to us at the information desk." "Where did the Ancient Roman civilization go?" "They're eating gelato and drinking espresso at the cafe."
- alejohausner 2y agoThere's an episode in "The Sopranos" where Tony confronts a jewish man he has cornered: Ever heard of Massada? For two years, 900 Jews held their own against 15,000 Roman soldiers. They chose death before enslavement. And the Romans, where are they now? Tony: You're looking at 'em, asshole. I always liked that scene. It argues that the mafia think of themselves as heirs to the violent Roman empire.
- paleotrope 2y ago
- csomar 2y agoThe current theory is that civilizations appeared across the planet due to climate change. This theory is based on the hypothesis that humans pre-1500 didn't have any contact with one another. I've been suspicious of that claim. If the Polynesians came from Asia and were able to reach the Americas, it's possible that there was latent communication between the two worlds but such communication happens at "generational" speeds.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoPeople have known about earlier contacts for a long time. Norse contact at l'anse aux meadows has been established since the late 90s. Trans-bering contact has been known for centuries. Humans arrived to rapa nui and other Pacific Islands relatively late, many thousands of years after the Holocene began. Stronger evidence of 13th century contact doesn't change anything about our understanding of the early history of the Americas.
- saas_sam 2y agoYou're pooh-poohing this idea a bit to harshly IMO. I almost wonder if your knowledge here may be out of date. You're aware that there's now evidence of the Americas' being populated over 20,000 years ago, right? Footprints in White Sands and now sloth bone carvings in Brazil. Far earlier than the Norse you mention.
- eesmith 2y agoAlotOfReading pointed out that 'This theory is based on the hypothesis that humans pre-1500 didn't have any contact with one another.' is not correct by giving examples of how humans pre-1500 did have contact with one another. That there were people and civilizations in the Americas before then is far from the point.
- csomar 2y agoThe people from over 20,000 years ago came from the northern ice bridge, however. My suggestion is that these people got civilization ideas from the Islanders at around 1500BC. They didn't get a full line of communication with the old world but enough ideas were taken to kick start a civilization.
- wnevets 2y agoPBS Nova recently had a great episode about the islands and its people [1] [1] https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/easter-island-origins/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/easter-island-origins/
- echelon_musk 2y agoI enjoyed Jago Cooper's/The BBC's 'Easter Island - Mysteries of a Lost World'. However, I'm not sure how current the research is as it first aired a decade ago. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cv5YHeJ9CZQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cv5YHeJ9CZQ
- pvaldes 2y agoBut we need to remind also that a very fast collapse, would not left a trace on the DNA. A Pompeii like event couldn't be disclosed just with DNA changes.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoAre you sure? I thought there were at least two ways to estimate population size from DNA: Y chromosome (since it is only passed father->son), and mitochondrial DNA(since it is only passed mother -> child). Why wouldn't those show up with a very rapid population collapse?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- darby_nine 2y agoVery fast collapse typically comes with positive evidence of this as people leave their lives out in the open, expecting to return later. Eg see the Roanoke colony in Virginia.