4 ms·
Data mining usage habits rarely result in lower prices for people making positive, less risky choices. This is because we live in an inflationary economy. Most
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Data mining usage habits rarely result in lower prices for people making positive, less risky choices.
This is because we live in an inflationary economy. Most prices go up. As a healthy guy, I'd like the price increases to be inflicted on the fattie smokers rather than me.
Not that it really matters in the context of health insurance - the laws surrounding it are structured in such a way as to subsidize the fattie smokers at the expense of healthy gym guy, regardless of what info the insurance company has (and they will become worse in a couple of years, unless the supreme court stops it - good luck with that).
- nitrogen 14y agoAs a healthy guy, I'd like the price increases to be inflicted on the fattie smokers rather than me. I have a friend who agrees with you, and I am constantly dismayed at the willingness of people to throw their fellow human beings under the bus. There are better ways of improving total health than letting insurance companies screw more cash out of the more vulnerable members of society.
- 3143 14y agoYou're dismayed that some people believe the unhealthiest of the population ought to pay the largest share of healthcare costs? Maybe you disagree, but "dismayed" seems very harsh.
- chris_wot 14y agoDepends on whether you are talking about preventable disease or not.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoWhy are you characterizing people who choose to overeat and engage in dangerous habits as the "more vulnerable members of society"?
- nitrogen 14y agoBecause those habits are associated with lower income and education levels. An increase in expenses is the last thing someone on the brink of financial ruin needs, and advocating for such seems to show a lack of empathy.
- lcargill99 14y agoThis is one reason the Obama cigarette taxes were outrageous.
- nitrogen 14y agoI'm less opposed to directly increasing cigarette taxes than I am to secretly raising insurance prices for people whose credit card statements include fast food. At least the cigarette price is visible up front, and the health risks of smoking are well understood. On the other hand, television constantly bombards its viewers with irresistible portrayals of people enjoying their products, with no up front indication that regular consumption of these products will (as hypothesized by the original article) put a black mark on your reputation that only corporations can see.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIf someone is on the brink of financial ruin, they should stop wasting money on cigarettes and excess food. That will improve both their health and their financial situation. To describe such a person as "vulnerable" is a little silly. Their vulnerability is something they created themselves.
- nitrogen 14y agoTell me. Have you ever been on the brink of financial ruin? When life seems bleak, rationality becomes incredibly remote. You'll burn through all your mental willpower just stressing about how you're going to pay enough of your bills to keep the utilities running. Cheap, high-calorie food and other time wasters typically avoided by the more financially able become essential escapes from the misery of baseline existence. They become the only way to stay sane. If you want people to stop eating fast food and watching TV all day, give them something more to live for than their next junk food hit instead of making their continued survival even more uncertain.
- lcargill99 14y agoMainly healthcare prices, education and some classes of real estate go up. Those are extremely rent-sought markets, not subject to competitive forces. And inflation is now running less than the 2% Fed target ( including the things mentioned above ). The "fatty smokers" are a rhetorical lightning rod, and hardly a threat to your way of life. Meanwhile healthy gym guy runs up a sports medicine bill.... the emphasis on "fitness" began with John Kennedy, designed to increase the fitness of draftees, and has gone mad-cow viral since ( especially when they figured out you'd pay $100 for a $5 pair of shoes in the 1980s... )