3 ms·
The same kind of math found on Babylonian clay tablets from 2,000 years earlier then? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics https://en.wikipedia
by defrost 2y ago
The same kind of math found on Babylonian clay tablets from 2,000 years earlier then?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics
Which suggests a long oral and|or easily destroyed "document" tradition of teachings being passed down which came to Aryabhata who compiled such things in a manner that survived.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics
- srean 2y agoThe sophistication of Babylonian mathematics boggles my mind. I am sure a credible science fiction story could be told where the Babylonians are a sophisticated alien race making Earth their home. However, "the same kind of mathematics" rings dismissive. Trigonometry as we know it, came to its own and flourished in the middle ages in Indian, Arab and Persian civilizations. I am not aware of Babylonic trigonometry. The story of the name of sin is itself quite interesting. It was half a 'jyay' (meaning chord subtended by an angle) in India. Through transliteration it became 'jayb' to the Arabs. Or the Europeans who were translating the Arabic mathematical literature derived from India, transliterate it as 'jayb', a phonetically similar bonafide Arabic word, that to this day is used to mean, a pocket/wallet/cavity. So pocket becomes sinus in Latin and then it evolves into just 'sin'. I think it was Napier who gave the name that we use. Cultivation of geometry by Indian scholars go further in the past, to about 8th century BC as recorded in Sulbasutra. https://personal.math.ubc.ca/~cass/courses/m309-01a/kong/sulbasutra_geometry.htm https://personal.math.ubc.ca/~cass/courses/m309-01a/kong/sul... You might be interested to know that combinatorics was also a hot topic among the Indian mathematicians. What we know as Fibonacci goes back far in the past, to Pingala (250 BC +/- 50). Pingala had worked out the binary numeral system and the 'Fibonacci' series. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingala https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingala What I am really keen to know is the mathematics of the Indus valley civilization, they were contemporaries of the Babylonians. Scarce little is known about their mathematics.
- defrost 2y ago> However, "the same kind of mathematics" rings dismissive. That's on you if you read it that way; There are other sources, but sticking with the wikipedia article already linked (which references other sources): * The Babylonian astronomers kept detailed records of the rising and setting of stars, the motion of the planets, and the solar and lunar eclipses, all of which required familiarity with angular distances measured on the celestial sphere. "angular distances measured on spheres" is the domain of trigonometry, how deep is a matter of debate but trigonometry it is. * They also used a form of Fourier analysis to compute an ephemeris (table of astronomical positions), which was discovered in the 1950s by Otto Neugebauer. That seems reasonably advanced. * Tablets kept in the British Museum provide evidence that the Babylonians even went so far as to have a concept of objects in an abstract mathematical space. The tablets date from between 350 and 50 B.C.E., revealing that the Babylonians understood and used geometry even earlier than previously thought. The Babylonians used a method for estimating the area under a curve by drawing a trapezoid underneath, a technique previously believed to have originated in 14th century Europe. This is proto-integration, pre-caclulus, etc.
- srean 2y agoNeugebauer's books are a fantastic resource. I am mostly familiar with their contents. I am aware of Babylonian's contribution to positional astronomy. If I remember right, Hipparchus, considered the father of trigonometry, was familiar with Babylonian astronomy. Contemporaneous (meaning Hipparchus's times) Greek astronomy was not as accurate in comparison. However, I have missed the Fourier series that you mention or any record that shows trigonometric manipulation or working out the values of the trigonometric functions. If you have a reference I would love to read, perhaps a specific Neugebauer book. Almagest model too can be considered a crude Fourier decomposition. So I am quite keen to learn about this Fourieresque decomposition that you speak of. If ancient trigonometry interests you, you should definitely checkout Indian scholars of the middle ages. Neugebauer covers some of that in his books. Glen Van Brummelen is another good resource. Awareness of angle measurement is not yet trigonometry, that would amount to saying Euclid's Elements- I has trigonometry. Trigonometry, whether planar or spherical becomes trigonometry with the awareness of trigonometric functions, their evaluations and trigonometric identities. > > However, "the same kind of mathematics" rings dismissive. > That's on you if you read it that way; Yes I do. The 'same kind of mathematics' is too broad a brush stroke that can easily sweep away any form of mathematical originality and novelty. As a characterization it is somewhere between 'vapid' and 'not very useful'. We do agree about how mind-bogglingly sophisticated Babylonian math was. They had Algebra that the Greeks didn't, and as you noted had figured out the technique of area under the curve well before Archimedes ... another person who seems centuries ahead of his times.