5 ms·
Videogame firms hit with EU complaint over 'tricking consumers'
- ChrisArchitect 2y agohttps://archive.ph/kl5Zx https://archive.ph/kl5Zx
- Spivak 2y agoIt's crazy that such an obvious problem ties the hands of regulators because people are making too much money on it. There is no defensible justification for incorporating a money siphon into an entertainment product. This could be dealt with swiftly with a law that says that video games must have upfront pricing— either a one time payment or a fixed-cost subscription. It's fine to have loot boxes or random rewards but how many rolls of the dice or your odds can't be affected by IRL money, and in-game items must be purchasable by either in-game currency or money, not both. Items that affect gameplay in any way must be in-game currency. I would just ban all in-game purchases because it's still a money siphon based on social pressure but I recognize that it's a lesser evil.
- darby_nine 2y ago> There is no defensible justification for incorporating a money siphon into an entertainment product. What do you mean? Society would obviously collapse if we did literally anything else—the Free Market is all that keeps people from murdering each other. By endorsing regulation you're just endorsing murder.
- totetsu 2y agoSounds like we need to be preemptively taking out all the Product Monetization executives if they're so ready to start murdering people.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- darby_nine 2y agoOh no, that would also make society collapse. Amy change to society would make it collapse. We live in a very delicate ecosystem and the only way for anything to work is to beg the beautiful people for favor, as it should be.
- Aerroon 2y agoAs somebody that plays games I would unkindly ask organizations like this to stop existing. The only thing I ever see from these organizations is them lobbying to ban something in the name of "protecting people". Children do not make their own money. You can't trick someone that doesn't have money, let alone have a credit card to make purchases. It's nonsense. >This could be dealt with swiftly with a law that says that video games must have upfront pricing— either a one time payment or a fixed-cost subscription. And leave millions of people unable to play games. Free games are popular for the same reason websites are ad supported: people don't want to, can't afford to or lack the payment methods to pay for them. People used their wallets to vote on this. And they chose the F2P microtransaction-laden P2W games. The vast majority of those players will spend nothing on that game. You make it buy to play and these games are dead on arrival. If these systems truly were so nefariously predatory as they are portrayed then you'd think that more than a tiny percentage of players would be spending on them. I don't like these mechanics either, but I grew up playing them (Korean F2P MMOs), because they were the only ones available to me. If this change why through then these games wouldn't suddenly change, they just wouldn't be available in Europe. If the entire world adopted the regulation then the game wouldn't have been made in the first place. Instead you would get "to play this $60 game you must buy our custom $350 hardware" or something else like that. Or... You would just get less games. If you don't like a game then just don't play it. Why do you feel the need to make others unable to play it too?
- Pannoniae 2y ago"People used their wallets to vote on this. And they chose the F2P microtransaction-laden P2W games. The vast majority of those players will spend nothing on that game. You make it buy to play and these games are dead on arrival. If these systems truly were so nefariously predatory as they are portrayed then you'd think that more than a tiny percentage of players would be spending on them." In an ideal world, this would be true. However, this is not that easy when all your friends are playing those crapware games and they don't exactly want to do anything else. No matter what you choose, you lose in some way. These games have negative externalities.
- CamperBob2 2y ago
- everforward 2y agoThere are some niceties from it, primarily that it keeps games affordable to virtually everyone. The price of a video game hasn’t really changed since the 90s. If anything, it’s come down given how many major games are F2P these days. I don’t think it’s abhorrent in principle that people with expendable income bankroll the game for people without in exchange for silly skins. Somebody has to pay, and I suspect the upfront purchase price will be higher than people expect.
- PlunderBunny 2y agoAs far as I can see, the article doesn't give any examples of what the complaint is specifically about ("tricking consumers about the real cost"). I don't think the complaint is about 'in-app' purchases for skins etc in-and-of-itself.
- Kikawala 2y agohttps://www.digitaljournal.com/tech-science/eu-consumer-groups-slam-manipulative-video-game-spending-tactics/article https://www.digitaljournal.com/tech-science/eu-consumer-grou... This one give slightly more information. "Today, premium in-game currencies are purposefully tricking consumers and take a big toll on children. Companies are well aware of children's vulnerability and use tricks to lure younger consumers into spending more," Gacha games.
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoGacha is a good example, but those base builders that feature fun characters and start slowing and slowing you down more, promising you can unlock the next level of cannon or whatever for just a few cents more, those are nasty. Or the ones that offer a way to battle baddies with your friends but your weapons are just not quite good enough, but there's a premium upgrade... I remember my kid playing a little "My Little Pony" game on iPad that was free and pleasant and then four levels in, suddenly "oh, you need Twilight for the next missions. Parents, Twilight costs $5."
- sixothree 2y agoI downloaded a puzzle game for iOS and was enjoying it. I was maybe 5 or 8 levels in and of course it got harder. But the last level was literally impossible to complete without some additional purchase. I tried a few ways just to prove that it was a trap. And it was. I have literally not played an iOS game since that moment.
- dumpsterdiver 2y ago> I have literally not played an iOS game since that moment. Do you still play games on other mobile operating systems? What does iOS have to do with the puzzle game interaction?
- BlackFly 2y agoBuying cosmetics in games is basically just playing digital barbie, and I do not mean that pejoratively. Dressing up dolls (both male and female) is an activity loved by people of all ages and genders. Pay to win has its defenders from people who work hard for their money and just want a game which is more fun than challenging. The EU has been pretty good at legislating digital content rules in order to achieve a basic level of equivalence between your digital dress for your digital barbie and a physical one: if it doesn't fit properly, if it isn't the color advertised, basically any lack of objective or subjective conformance and they either fix it or give your money back. Permanence thereof is a bit up in the air. Buried in the directive on digital content and services is this fun interpretation: > Digital representations of value such as electronic vouchers or e-coupons are used by consumers to pay for different goods or services in the digital single market. Such digital representations of value are becoming important in relation to the supply of digital content or digital services, and should therefore be considered as a method of payment within the meaning of this Directive. Digital representations of value should also be understood to include virtual currencies, to the extent that they are recognised by national law. Differentiation depending on the methods of payment could be a cause of discrimination and provide an unjustified incentive for businesses to move towards supplying digital content or a digital service against digital representations of value. However, since digital representations of value have no other purpose than to serve as a method of payment, they themselves should not be considered digital content or a digital service within the meaning of this Directive. They are inventing payment methods and then requiring them, possibly in contradiction to legal tender laws. Plus, they are legally currencies, standard contract terms notwithstanding. In principal, one needs to report that to tax authorities. But that discrimination hints at the fact that the practice probably falls under the unfair commercial practices legislation among others. This is quite obvious if you think about it, why are they introducing and requiring those currencies but to obscure the cost and attempt to circumvent our ordinary commercial laws?