6 ms·
People have long been worked up over net neutrality. But what about payment neutrality? It seems like it's just as important, if not more. Why don't we hear en
by crazygringo 14y ago
People have long been worked up over net neutrality.
But what about payment neutrality? It seems like it's just as important, if not more. Why don't we hear enough from people demanding laws that prevent payment processors above a certain size from discriminating based on categories of goods and services?
Why can't we make it illegal for MasterCard and Visa to stop processing payments destined for Wikileaks, or PayPal to stop processing payments to VPN providers? This seems to be to be a clear abuse of monopoly power or at least market share, and there isn't even a whiff of transparent, due process in it.
- citricsquid 14y agoSurely it would be backwards to dictate who payment processors can and cannot do business with. There are risks involved with banking, a bank will not give a mortgage to a minimum wage worker and we don't expect them to due to the risks associated with such a mortgage, why should a payment processor be expected to take the risks that banks are not?
- gringomorcego 14y agoUh, so it's okay for the US to wink wink at Amazon, Paypal and numerous other financial payment providers when Wikileaks comes to play? You sound like a true apologist. This stuff matters, it affects people's lives, and it it has NOTHING to do with ROI. That's a bunch of BS. This has to do with favors and stancing and has absolutely nothing to do with profitability or providing a service. I'll show myself the door when I hear about how many chargebacks the VPN was getting.
- citricsquid 14y agoYou're conflating 2 unrelated issues here. It's not okay for the United States government to request (secretly) for a private enterprise to engage in acts that are detrimental to an individual or business because the United States is unable to do anything themselves within the law, however I don't see how the action taken against Wikileaks has any relevance to the action taken against this business. What indication is there that the US requested this?
- gwern 14y agoPaypal's listed justification has nothing to do with the risk of doing business with the VPN; no previous problems were mentioned.
- revelation 14y agoOnce a bank does take someone on, there are very strong regulations on what they can and can not do. A bank can't just cut you off and freeeze your money, as PayPal has done here.
- mistercow 14y agoDictating what categories are not legitimate reasons for rejecting someone is not the same as "you have to accept everyone!" Obviously, PayPal should be allowed to reject actual criminal enterprises, for example. But there is nothing illegal about VPNs that protect your anonymity. Besides, I think it's clear that any legislation that disallowed payment processors from discriminating against businesses would also have to give them legal protection in the case that said business end up being sued.
- mtgx 14y agoDoesn't Paypal censor payments for certain types of books now, too?
- scalable 14y agohttps://action.eff.org/o/9042/p/dia/action/public/?action_KEY=8515&a https://action.eff.org/o/9042/p/dia/action/public/?action_KE... "UPDATE (3/13/12): After public pressure, PayPal has revised their policy censoring publishers of erotic ebooks."
- kiba 14y agoIt's called "Bitcoin", simply because it can serve as an independent non-political payment network. However, its usefulness is limited by poor infrastructure and limited marketshare. Bitcoin is getting more useful, though. There's Bitcoin ATM, smartcards for bitcoin wallets, mobile app that utilize QR code, etc.
- sltkr 14y agoIt's also impossible to charge recurring fees, and unlike Paypal etc, transactions take at least 10 minutes on average to clear (and around an hour if you want a decent amount of security). For TorGuard that is probably acceptable, but in situations where you want to give your customers immediate access to your service, it's far from ideal.
- rictic 14y agoIf you're giving someone access to a service that you can revoke (e.g. web hosting, VPN, etc), it doesn't seem like there's any practical risk in optimistically giving someone access once you see the spend hit the bitcoin network. It's not infeasible to do that in a matter of seconds. If you're shipping something physical you're not going to be working on a timescale less than an hour anyways. Really the only time that I see Bitcoin's transaction processing speed being an issue is when you're doing a moderate to large transaction where waiting around would be inconvenient.
- cookiecaper 14y agoSomeone can chain fake btc transactions to your system granting themselves an infinite supply of access on short-lived accounts if you accept an immediate validation.
- zhoutong 14y agoNo one can ever fake transactions out of thin air. Bitcoin is cryptography. The requirement for confirmation is due to possible double spending, which will cost far more than a VPN account to do it successfully (to cheat a 0-confirmation system).
- DanBC 14y agoBecause there are strict laws in place to prevent money laundering and there are fierce protections to help reduce fraud. Asking money services to handle payments for anyone is problematic.
- netcan 14y agoGood point. And it's not even necessarily about abuse of monopoly, at least its traditional implications. Calling it justice or freedom seems melodramatic, but I don't have better langage for it. For example, paypal's advantage is (supposedly) in fraud detection. But they aren't picking up on fraud, they are picking up on fraud risk. An individual or business can register as risky for some apparently arbitrary reason and effectively be banned from a big slice of online commerce. Paypal have no mandate to provide a service to everyone, they might be better off banning 10% of the total population as high risk and passing those savings onto the remaining 90%. Thats completely reasonable as a business decision. Not really different to simply deciding not to open a shop in Eindhoven. But when it's Paypal it becomes a justice/freedom issue. A person is disadvantaged without access to it.