3 ms·
I.e. workers who produce more get paid more, those who produce less get paid less. It's always been that way, though it is usually difficult to measure accurate
by WalterBright 2y ago
I.e. workers who produce more get paid more, those who produce less get paid less. It's always been that way, though it is usually difficult to measure accurately.
- uoaei 2y agoTechnically true, while ignoring all details of how "productivity" is defined. Claiming it's an issue of measurement and not definition implies you believe there's some ironclad and universally applicable definition of productivity, i.e., once again imposing your own ideology without any good faith efforts to include other perspectives.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Technically true, while ignoring all details of how "productivity" is defined. There's a specialty profession called "cost accounting" whose sole purpose is to accurately define it. Just like insurance companies do risk assessments. > implies you believe You're just making things up. > without any good faith efforts Give the rudeness a rest.
- myhf 2y agoIt's dishonest to say in one comment that certain workers "produce more" and in the next that you are speaking in terms of "cost accounting" productivity (that is, identifying which workers are likely to accept less pay for the same task).
- WalterBright 2y ago> It's dishonest Being rude doesn't make your argument any better. You know that workers are not perfectly interchangeable, everybody with any sense knows that. You also know that cost accounting isn't an exact science when it comes to the variability of people. But if cost accountants were worthless, businesses wouldn't employ them.
- uoaei 2y agoThere's a specialty profession which merely adopts as fact definitions of productivity and optimizes costs against that. Give the denseness a rest.
- stretchandahalf 2y ago[flagged]
- vundercind 2y agoThis introduction appears to describe a lot more going on than that.
- WalterBright 2y ago[flagged]
- tbrownaw 2y agoWell it talks about Uber varying pay (to make their market clear) in ways that some drivers they talked to find hard to predict and plan around. And there's the section on Amazon varying delivery driver pay based on safety measurements that turned out to be buggy.
- WalterBright 2y agoNeither contraindicates my point.
- vundercind 2y agoThe intro explicitly sets up its core point in contrast to the practice you mentioned (“Though firms have relied upon performance-based variable pay for some time”) Further: “As a labor management practice, algorithmic wage discrimination allows firms to personalize and differentiate wages for workers in ways unknown to them, paying them to behave in ways that the firm desires, perhaps for as little as the system determines that the workers may be willing to accept.18 Given the information asymmetry between workers and firms, companies can calculate the exact wage rates necessary to incentivize desired behaviors, while workers can only guess how firms determine their wages.19” This is different from, and may produce different effects to (that’s that the paper’s about! I haven’t had time to read it all yet, but will tonight) something like a transparent productivity-based pay rate or bonus. The paper may not hold up (I think the main idea of it alone is interesting, though) but it is not about productivity-based bonus or pay structures.
- 2y ago
- Etheryte 2y agoThis isn't even remotely what the article is about, please try and have at least a cursory read of the content you're commenting on.