3 ms·
Who said anything about banning everything though? That smells like a strawman. Fools rush in is a warning against not diving headfirst into doing whatever you
by defrost 2y ago
Who said anything about banning everything though? That smells like a strawman.
Fools rush in is a warning against not diving headfirst into doing whatever you feel like doing just because you can, it's not advocacy for "banning everything".
- scarab92 2y agoPeople are talking about banning something, when they can’t even outline a real harm that the ban is intended to avoid. If that’s the threshold, then we are genuinely talking about banning everything by default.
- defrost 2y ago> People are talking about banning something, That'd be inglor_cz above. > when they can’t even outline a real harm that the ban is intended to avoid. Unsurprising when { something } (for various values of something) has never been done before. The wise course of action is to not rush full bore into, say, handing out sticks of dynamite, dumping hundreds of thousands of gallons of waste, allowing third parties in other countries to digitize citizens, etc. etc. until time has been taken to look into pootential harms.
- inglor_cz 2y ago"wise" This is very much in the eye of the beholder. In my opinion, we already suffer from an abundance of suffocating safetyism, which may be a consequence of aging of our societies. "time has been taken to look into pootential harms." And I am also very skeptical towards the idea that a theorizing committee can predict future reliably. Which includes future harms and rewards of some technology that has barely started to develop. The experience from the past is that we cannot tell such things in advance.
- defrost 2y agoThe experience from the past is that we cannot unfuck a goat. New technologies don't need to be "banned" forever, what a daft idea. They also don't have to be jumped into head first w/out checking for snags and clearance either.
- inglor_cz 2y ago"They also don't have to be jumped into head first w/out checking for snags and clearance either." So new technologies should be at least put on hold until someone checks them for snags and clearance to an extent satisfying for ... whom? You? An average person? A committee? The parliament? Some regulatory body? Again, what you think of as wisdom seems like obsessive safetyism to me. As someone else here argues, you shouldn't have the right to stop or delay random things just in case, unless you can demonstrate some concrete harm. The world shouldn't be a carefully padded kindergarten for adults. Heck, even current kindergartens for kids are too safetyist by far. Shout out to Lenore Skenazy and her free-range parenting.
- inglor_cz 2y agoLook around, we are living in a veritable vetocracy. There is no need for anyone to advocate banning everything. It is a result of aggregate efforts of a diverse set of activists each trying to ban something. You dislike AI training. Someone dislikes high speed rail, or possibly any new rail at all. Someone dislikes Starship. Someone dislikes new housing or rezoning of their city. Someone dislikes new biotech. Someone dislikes new factories. Someone dislikes new wind turbines. Someone dislikes new nuclear power plants. And nowadays, the fear of harm and doing harmful things is in vogue, so the standard line of defense is to argue potential harms, and given that no activity in the world is completely harmless, the result is stasis and a paper war over everything. It is as if there was a group of activists who dislike individual letters. Even though Alice only hates H and Bob only hates Q, if enough people do this, the entire alphabet is going to be banned soon. There is a certain irony in the fact that the Internet, a revolutionary technology in itself, has enabled various reactionary folks to organize themselves to stop their $Nemesis, for whatever value of $Nemesis. Where once were isolated naysayers, a pressure group is now easily put together.
- defrost 2y ago[flagged]