9 ms·
Anandtech: Macbook Pro with Retina Display Review
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- fabiandesimone 14y agoThe article adds nothing of value and the use of different names for the same machine is nothing but an attempt to do some SEO. How is this on the front page?
- mrcapers 14y agoI feel his reviews are generally worth waiting for as they are more comprehensive and insightful than comparable gadget/electronic blogs.
- jaems33 14y agoIt's a pretty comprehensive review. Page 16 on the battery life at various workloads was important to me.
- fabiandesimone 14y agoOh man, I'm an ass. I read the first page on my phone and did not see the following pages. My previous comment has zero merit.
- rhizome 14y agoAll of the major review sites split their articles into 20+ pages.
- rfrey 14y agoHe's unsatisfied with his 'old' MBP 15" (previous gen) because "it always made me feel like the old fogey at tradeshows where everyone else had something 13-inches or smaller". Stuff like that defies parody.
- phren0logy 14y agoSure, it's a little ridiculous, but I think it's the equivalent of being a hardware fashionista. If you review hardware for a living, it's not (only) about being practical. You are correct that it offers little insight to the rest of us, but that sort of obsession is what gets you a review like this.
- arihant 14y agoThat's signature style of a lot of great, obsessive reviewers. Connecting to what a particular product ultimately "means" to you is something that differentiates reviews from spec-sheets. This reminds me of Jeremy Clarkson on Porsche Boxster - "The only reason you would buy one of these is because you can't afford a 911... so what you're doing as you're driving around is advertising the fact that your life hasn't worked out quite as well as you had been hoping"
- brisance 14y agoAnd that is why Jeremy Clarkson's reviews should not be the final arbiter of what constitutes a "good" car. The Boxster/Cayman has been consistently judged to be a better driver's car than the 911 because the engine is mounted in the right place to begin with. It's very much similar to Intel and the x86 architecture where its greatest success is keeping it from future greatness.
- pacaro 14y agoThe key word here is "judged" - whether the boxster/cayman is a better car than the 911 is exactly that, a matter of judgement. An early 70's 911, all that weight hanging over/behind the skinny (by modern standards) rear wheels, no traction control - a joy to drive. That's just a judgement too!
- brisance 14y agoNo... read the quote again. "The ONLY reason you would buy one of these is because you can't afford a 911..." He has it backwards. The only reason why the Boxster/Cayman is crippled as compared to the 911 is because the Porsche 911 "fans" are keeping it from becoming the best. If you go back far enough when they had the whole air-cooled vs water-cooled engine nonsense, it's the exact same thing. You don't have to take my word for it. Ask the Porsche engineers why each subsequent iteration of the "best" 911, the GT3, has been shifting the engine closer to a midships layout. Clarkson is not a car reviewer. He's an entertainer.
- mikelbring 14y agoSo how will my code editor look on Retina? All blurry?
- mwhawkins 14y agoThat is the issue I am having. Eclipse-based IDEs are not ready for Retina. The text is legible, the IDE is usable, but its noticeably blurry. I've logged a ticket with Aptana Studio and Eclipse, but they have no solution to this issue, just workarounds which don't really work. If you are using Vim or a simple text editor, however, there is no issue with the appearance of the text. Xcode works just fine, too.
- Ogre 14y agoThere's another option. You can get a third party utility like SwitchResX ($, but the free ones didn't work very well when I tried them) and run your display at native resolution. Yes, you get a full 2880x1800 desktop, and yes, some things get terribly small. But, you can then set your font sizes larger in things you use all the time, and I find the really small stuff to still be readable, maybe just not pleasant for long term use. I am running that way right now, using Firefox zoomed in slightly, and it works beautifully. SwitchResX lets you set up hot keys to switch resolutions too, so I've been switching back and forth between 1920x1200 and native resolution trying to decide what I like best. So far, I think 2880x1800 is winning, with Firefox zoomed in, and a 14 point font (Inconsolata) in Emacs and iTerm2. Though both of the latter work correctly at Apple's scaled resolutions already (I've so far settled on Inconsolata 11 at 1920x1200) For me, the biggest thing that's changed is that I've used Monaco 9, or variants thereof on non-Apple platforms, as my code font for the last 15 years. This was already too small for some people to read, and I've had hotkeys set up to switch to larger fonts when showing other people code on my screen for years. Monaco 9 doesn't even really exist at scaled resolutions though - it is NOT the same font you get if you render any other point size of Monaco, which is what happens at Apple's scaled resolutions. "Monaco 9" looks like the rest of Monaco now. (Techincally the old pixel version does still exist when running at native resolution, but it's crazy small and although I can read it with some effort, it's not really practical). But the screen is so great that I'm finally over my obsession with pixel fonts. Inconsolata is a fantastic tiny font when the pixels are too small to see. I'll probably try a few more now that I've been liberated, that was just the best I happened to have installed already.
- untog 14y agoI'm hoping that we see a 13" Air edition with the Retina Display sometime soon. That I will pull the trigger on.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 14y agoI think the focus on retina means we likely won't be seeing a 15" Air anytime soon.
- pvidler 14y agoThat would be nice, but the battery life would be really poor. There's no optical drive to ditch for more room in the Air. I expect this to be the main differentiator between the 13" Air and Pro models going forward.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoConsidering the 13" Pro doesn't have room for a discrete GPU, I doubt we're going to see a retina Air until a few more revs of Intel's integrated GPUs.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoHave you heard of the iPad?
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoThe iPad needed nearly double the battery to keep up with the larger display+GPU's power requirements. The MBP still had to add 20% to keep up. There's no room in the current Air for extra battery, so even if the current GPU could keep up to Apple standards, running time wouldn't. Which means either becoming less Air-y or waiting for a more efficient part (likely Haswell)
- Andys 14y agoOne more revision, in fact. Ivy Bridge's 4K display support enabled the 15" macbook pro to exist with discrete GPU switching. Haswell will be faster enough to ditch the discrete GPU.
- axxl 14y agoThe most interesting section for me was the performance issues of the retina display ( http://www.anandtech.com/show/6023/the-nextgen-macbook-pro-with-retina-display-review/8 http://www.anandtech.com/show/6023/the-nextgen-macbook-pro-w... ). I wonder if waiting for a next generation mbp to really be able to push those pixels would be a smart choice. I had noticed a few stutters when playing around with one in the store, though if Mountain Lion will optimize it as claimed then that could fix it.
- mtgx 14y agoWhat I'm surprised about is that people are just realizing that retina uses a lot more processing power. I bet most people still don't realize that a "retina-optimized" game should should have half the performance on iPad 3 compared to the "low-res" version on iPad 2, if everything else is equal, even though the GPU in iPad 3 is twice as strong.
- axxl 14y agoYeah, twice as strong but pushing four times the pixels, I think a lot of people get easily confused. What can you do but hope the hardware improves more I guess.
- kenrikm 14y agoYes however retina games don't require 4x AA to look great. So you're trading one performance hit for another.
- FrankBooth 14y ago4x AA is only a 15-20% hit when you're talking about MSAA: http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/535?i=455.488.456.492 http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/535?i=455.488.456.492
- kenrikm 14y agoNot all games support MSAA, however yes it's much more GPU friendly.
- wolf550e 14y agoI prefer reading it this way: http://www.anandtech.com/print/6023/the-nextgen-macbook-pro-with-retina-display-review http://www.anandtech.com/print/6023/the-nextgen-macbook-pro-...
- npalli 14y agoIt would have been great if apple introduced a regular macbook pro with an IPS screen. I have a hi-res 15.4" macbook pro and a 1080p Dell XPS 16. Both are non-IPS. I recently picked up a Lenovo 12.5 HD IPS screen which is lower DPI than either the mac or the dell. However after using the lenovo for a couple of days I'm blown away how shitty both the mac and the dell screens looked (dull, like someone had put a film on top). Given many applications are not ready for retina display, apple could have used their supply chain prowess to get an IPS display on their regular macbook pro line.
- superdude 14y agoI agree that it would have been awesome to upgrade the non-retina MacBooks to IPS. But go try the 14" Thinkpad. It uses the shittiest LCD panel in the industry, way worse than any MacBook and worse or on par with the worst Dell laptops.
- ibisum 14y agoAs I use my MBP for Audio/Sessions and other media stuff, mostly, I absolutely need 17" screen, field-replaceable batteries, and an ExpressPort slot. So I think the "Pro" bit is a bit of a stretch these days ..
- Gring 14y agoThe "glare handling" pictures makes me wonder why anybody would buy a portable device (=to sometimes be used outdoors) and be happy with those outrageous reflections. I mean, you can barely see the content! http://www.anandtech.com/show/6023/the-nextgen-macbook-pro-with-retina-display-review/4 http://www.anandtech.com/show/6023/the-nextgen-macbook-pro-w... With the new decice, Aplle again tries to makes those unusable mirrors the only display you can order. I'll pass.
- tedunangst 14y agoNot everyone buys a portable device to use it outdoors. Some people just like moving room to room indoors.
- graeme 14y agoI often switch between: * office desk * standing desk (really an ikea shelf) * kitchen table * couch * cafe (very easy to carry) Have a three pound computer means I don't even have to think about these switches.
- wmf 14y agoGlossy displays do have better contrast and lower black levels.
- scott_s 14y agoYou really equate "portable" with "to be used outdoors"? I can't recall ever using my laptops outside.
- astrange 14y agoGlossy displays are exclusively better in controlled lighting, because their black levels are actually good. Controlled lighting is not difficult to achieve and is already a necessity for graphics work. Actually, it can even be better outside. A screen with reflections on it is not as bad as a screen that you can't see due to low contrast. (I'm currently using a matte desktop LCD, but wasted tons of time looking for a model with an 8-bit screen and good contrast.)
- Kerrick 14y agoI didn't realize Apple was pushing graphics so hard the past few years just to get to a point where retina-level resolution was possible at these sizes. Funny, it reminds me a bit of the big push Vista caused in hardware manufacturers to stop stagnating on the amount of RAM considered 'normal' in computers.
- albertzeyer 14y agoI didn't realized until now that the Ethernet port is gone. I need that! That might actually be the main and only reason for me to not buy this. How sad, I really like the device otherwise.
- efraim 14y agoThey will be happy to sell you yet another adapter. http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/product/MC704ZM/A http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/product/MC704ZM/A
- tzs 14y agoWhy that one, when you can get this one? http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/product/MD463ZM/A http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/product/MD463ZM/A
- lancefisher 14y agoOr this one: http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/product/MC914LL/A http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/product/MC914LL/A
- sounds 14y agoNote: the ethernet chip _is_ present. In this article (anandtech) they look at Gigabit Ethernet performance and benchmark it at 925-928 Mbps - using the _Thunderbolt_ adapter. Over at the iFixit teardown (step #13), you can see that the ethernet chip is present on the I/O board: "Broadcom BCM57100 series Gigabit Ethernet + Memory Card reader controller" http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Pro-with-Retina-Display-Teardown/9462/2#s36202 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Pro-with-Retina-Displ...
- tedunangst 14y agoI'd like to see a teardown of the adapter. My understanding of thunderbolt is it's not going to carry ethernet signals. There's another ethernet chip in the adapter (I think). The one on the motherboard is there primarily for the smart card reader and because it allows Apple to use the same chip on the laptops that do have ethernet jacks.
- Tichy 14y agoI'm allergic to the "best product x Apple has ever built" line, it is such an obvious manipulative marketing spin. Of course every new device should be the best they ever built. All the components have been improved - it is just the way computer technology has progressed for a long time now. Also, it is just a slightly slimmer notebook with a higher resolution. It is not "changing computing as we have known it".
- rayiner 14y agoYet, lots of manufacturers release products that back-slide from their predecessors.
- Tichy 14y agoGive examples? I heard a lot of complaints about ThinkPads, but I think that was when they were no longer being made by IBM. Sure, it happens - but I suppose typically if the manufacturer as whole is in decline.
- mwhawkins 14y agoEven as a lifelong PC user, I tend to disagree somewhat. It's hardly just 'a higher resolution and thinner design' by a long shot. There is a lot more here, and I was a huge Apple sceptic in the past. First of all, this is a powerhouse of a machine in a relatively small form factor. It's also one of the first 'mainstream' laptops to feature full-flash storage as stock and not as an available upgrade (ultra books excluded here - I'm talking laptops with serious power, not portable form). Also, there is nothing on the market even remotely close to the Retina display (yet). I'm blown away by its clarity. Its also the quietest laptop I have ever owned, has the best input (trackpad) device, decent battery life, and really good sound. The OS is first-rate, too and beats Windows in form and function handily (although, with a few minor complaints). Full disclosure: The Retina MacBook Pro I'm typing this on is the first Apple computer I have ever bought in my 12+ years of professional IT experience. I've never owned an Apple device prior to this dating all the way back to the 80's. I also own three other PCs, most are relatively new, and for mobility I only own three or four Android devices thus far. Have been running either Windows or Linux for as long as I have been computing.
- eli 14y agoUgh, having to upgrade to the outrageously priced high-end CPU just to get the 512GB SSD is killing me. I need to upgrade, but I'm seriously considering a fully loaded Air instead because it'd be nice if this came in under $3k.
- tftmon 14y agois it still TFT IPS display, its so thin on photos.
- zokier 14y agoI find the desktop performance bit ridiculous. I mean, a (very) high-end hardware manages only 20FPS while browsing Facebook? It would have been interesting to see similar benchmark on Windows.
- forgetcolor 14y agoi'm so tempted by the weight and the screen resolution, but thrown off by the glossy display and the sluggish frame rates at > 1440 resolutions. i tried a glossy in 2010 and returned it for a highres antiglare because the reflections created a serious eyestrain problem for me. i doubt the new one will be much better, but look forward to seeing one. and i wish he'd try the framerate tests on mountain lion. i really need the performance increase over my 2010 but may go w the old style until they work out the bugs in a year.
- fa_il 14y agoI'd like to be able to buy a laptop-sized retina display, without the Macbook. Something that I could hook up to any other computer. Now that would be useful.