4 ms·
at the inquest, the coroner, Mr JAK Ferns declared: "In a man of his type, one never knows what his mental processes are going to do next." What he meant by "of
by rmc 14y ago
at the inquest, the coroner, Mr JAK Ferns declared: "In a man of his type, one never knows what his mental processes are going to do next." What he meant by "of this type" is unclear.
Oh please, we know exactly what the coroner meant by "of this type". He meant homosexuals. He (and many many other people in the medial and government at the time) thought homosexuality was a mental illness and very unnatural affliction.
- geuis 14y agoThe man was a genius. He was largely responsible for creating the foundations of modern society in many ways, in his work with computation, cryptology, AI, and other fields. "Of this type" means that he was an out of the box thinker and hard to predict. It in no ways should be understood as you are stating.
- schrijver 14y agoHow can you be so sure geuis? It’s well possible the coroner wasn’t aware of Turing’s genius at all.
- planetguy 14y agoWe're well into speculative territory here. Are we suggesting that the coroner was aware of his homosexuality but not of the fact he was a brilliant mathematician? I mean, the coroner must at least have known that he had a chemistry lab, working with dangerous chemicals, in the house. That's way more unusual than gaying it up.
- easp 14y agoWell, he was a man who had taken female hormones as an alternative to going to prison, and who had indicated that the hormones had given him breasts. Do you think a dead man with breasts would have gone unnoticed by the coroner? Do you think he might have wondered why Turing had breasts? It's quite reasonable to think that the coroner would have known that he was homosexual, and it is quite reasonable to think that would have been viewed as a flaw, since, you know, the whole state-sanctioned "choice" between prison and chemical castration thing.
- rsynnott 14y ago> We're well into speculative territory here. Are we suggesting that the coroner was aware of his homosexuality but not of the fact he was a brilliant mathematician? That seems quite plausible. The coroner would be aware of his criminal conviction as a matter of course, but might have relatively little information about his profession.
- defrost 14y agoSmart guy, yes, very smart indeed, but to describe him as "largely responsible" is a disservice to men like William Thomas Tutte, Tommy Flowers and a number of other contemporary collegues who contributed as much but with less fanfare.
- gaius 14y agoTommy Flowers in particular, but whereas Turing was upper-middle class, Flowers was working-class.
- gaius 14y agoThen you don't understand the British ruling class of the time - everyone of them, judges, civil servants, politicians, army officers, would have had homosexual experiences at boarding school, not necessarily consentingly, but they were perfectly well used to homosexuals. The problem as far as the establishment was concerned was that Turing had access to all the nation's secrets and he was inviting anyone home he fancied... That he was gay was just a pretext for what happened next.
- spinchange 14y ago"Alan and I were left with “the Wards”—always we referred to them as “the Wards.” We were the wards and they were our guardians but no matter—this was to be the centre of our existence for many years and our home from home. I believe it was here, perhaps in the first four or five years at the Wards, perhaps even in the first two, that Alan became destined for a homosexual. Has anyone mentioned it until now?" http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/06/23/alan-turing-s-brother-he-should-be-alive-today.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/06/23/alan-turing... I was previously unaware that this was such a common phenomena.
- schrijver 14y agoSo he is suggesting Alan Turing’s homosexuality to be caused by strained relationships with parents… still seeing being gay as some kind of personality disorder, that could have been avoided by people taking better care of Turing?
- gruseom 14y agoThat was a thoroughly conventional thing to think if you were born in 1908.
- rmc 14y agoIf anything it might be seen as forward thinking and caring, as opposed to people who thought it was a sin caused by the devil, and/or the person was cruel and wanted to do depraved things. "It's a mental illness, don't blame the person", is kinder than "They are filthy amoral degenerate", but not as kind as "It's as valid a relationship type as heterosexuality"
- toyg 14y ago"A man of his type" probably just meant "a mad scientist". The stereotype was as strong as ever at the time (thanks to Einstein and the nuclear-science culture of secrecy), and Turing fit it to a T: he dealt with concepts the average coroner couldn't even start to comprehend (advanced crypto, information theory, Frankenstein-style machinery full of valves and levers, experimental chemistry), he was a loner, socially awkward geek, who somehow didn't really like to hide his homosexual side like a proper Englishman would do (homosexual experiences were much more common at the type for the ruling class, due to boarding schools).