3 ms·
> This retroactive application of a principle not explicitly required by law at the time of the tax rulings is unfair and creates legal uncertainty for business
by immibis 2y ago
> This retroactive application of a principle not explicitly required by law at the time of the tax rulings is unfair and creates legal uncertainty for businesses.
I don't see any problem with this. They knew they were gaming the system, and knew they could get in trouble for it. The law is NOT a computer program where all outputs can be fully predicted from the source code - it also takes common sense into account.
We should just pass a law that says gaming the system is illegal, then we won't need to find silly justifications against people who game the system, but silly justifications work too.
- Nasrudith 2y agoI expect to see very abusive definitions of 'gaming the system' under such a law such that anything which is the slightest inconvenience is viewed as gaming the system. Just like how common sense isn't common.
- 082349872349872 2y agoIn support of GP, my experience with judges and lawyers says the law* is much less fond of "rules lawyering" than engineers typically believe. * to be fair, this varies with legal system: my personal opinion is that one finds significantly more successful rules lawyering attempts in common law systems than in code systems.