5 ms·
More relevant is that if someone straps wings on their back, jumps off a building and dies, that’s 1 death/0miles or infinity deaths per mile. To get deaths pe
by jodrellblank 2y ago
More relevant is that if someone straps wings on their back, jumps off a building and dies, that’s 1 death/0miles or infinity deaths per mile.
To get deaths per mile down needs a long tail of safe mass use, and that comes after the rough early days of little use and lots of accidents. Cars got a lot less deathy after banning drunk driving, adding white lines on the roads, banning jaywalking - things outside Car technology - as well as seatbelts, airbags, crumple zones, better headlights, power assisted brakes, antilock brakes.
Zeppelins used Hydrogen and several deadly accidents were while emptying or refilling. Now there are better materials, equipment, OSHA rules, industries which deal with natural gas and gasoline and other dangerous gases and chemicals routinely which is outside Zeppelin technology but would help make them safer.
One Zeppelin crash was the gas release valves sealed shut to save money. We have better regulation around airline safety to catch that kind of “safety device isn’t functioning” and expect failovers at the design stage, also outside them being Zeppelins and just general bad practice.
One Zeppelin crash was a last minute extension to the design launched before it could be tested properly for political reasons, that’s an avoidable problem with regulatory bodies overseeing designs and builds - also general bass practice.
Aircraft got safer once the copilot started flying and the pilot advised. Because of social power imbalances, it’s much easier for the pilot to correct the assistant, than for yer assistant to correct the pilot. Maybe that could benefit Zeppelins?
Ocean travel got safer as ships learned to avoid the worst routes and weather, and with the Panama and Suez canals; by the time of the Titanic when lifeboat regulations were being discussed it was an argument that ships don’t crash enough anymore to benefit from lifeboats. Lots of Zeppelin problems with storms should be improved with todays weather prediction/reporting as well as storm-proof materials.
Zeppelins stopped before all those kinds of changes/developments. Left in the era of men standing in a field holding onto them by ropes, altitude by sonar echo and stopwatch, radio by dangling a wire to use as an antenna, controlling speed by telling a man sitting by each engine to turn them up or down, then saying “high deaths per mile they must be inherently unsafe” is more scaremongering dismissal than genuine interested carefully reasoned position.