4 ms·
This argument fails basic math. Take a company with 10,000 employees (small), If we take away 10 million from the CEOs salary (extremely large) that works out
by bluGill 2y ago
This argument fails basic math. Take a company with 10,000 employees (small), If we take away 10 million from the CEOs salary (extremely large) that works out $1000 extra per employee. Nice money, not enough to make a major lifestyle improvement. To get that much per employee I had to use unreasonable numbers all around.
Not that CEOs aren't being paid too much, but it won't make much difference to lower their pay.
- rockostrich 2y ago> Nice money, not enough to make a major lifestyle improvement. It most certainly is enough to make a major lifestyle improvement when someone is living paycheck to paycheck. That could be the difference between just barely scraping by to being able to comfortably buy necessities and maybe even grow a savings.
- brigadier132 2y ago> It most certainly is enough to make a major lifestyle improvement when someone is living paycheck to paycheck This is not what the recent universal basic income study showed.
- rockostrich 2y ago> the recent universal basic income study If you're talking about the OpenResearch study that Sam Altman is funding then yes it did [1]. Granted this study was a little bit more money but the results imply that any amount of extra money helps people living paycheck to paycheck in terms of financial flexibility and safety. [1] https://www.openresearchlab.org/findings/nber-working-paper-consumption-and-household-balance-sheets https://www.openresearchlab.org/findings/nber-working-paper-...
- stoneman24 2y agoLooking at the utility value for the ceo and the employees. 10M for the ceo may make much difference to his lifestyle (slightly better yacht) but the $1000 for the lowest paid could make a big difference. They just inhabit totally different financial landscapes.
- bluGill 2y agoHow many CEOs make 10M? Even in the fortune 100 level you will find they make less than that.
- fxtentacle 2y agoObviously, you didn't read the article yet. "you'd be able to give every worker a $30,000 bonus, every year"
- bluGill 2y agoNot the first time a journalist wrote something that is wrong. Wanting to support a bias is often more important than the truth. (always has been)
- anticorporate 2y ago> Not that CEOs aren't being paid too much, but it won't make much difference to lower their pay. I disagree. There are multiple benefits of reallocating CEO pay beyond increasing worker pay. The obvious one is morale. I work for a billionaire. I have no incentive to go above the minimum, because I know he is the only one meaningfully collecting from my labor. If my pay included a larger bonus and stock grant portion, at least there would be some connection between my work and my reward. Instead, I've had the opposite trend in my career, with the percentage of my income delivered as base salary increasing but contingent income decreasing, especially as a relative proportion when compared to my C-suite. Two, I'd argue, it's a negative for society as a whole to create a class of ultra-rich. I'd rather see my CEO's excess compensation set on fire and delivered to no one rather than enrich him further. Class inequality will continue to be a problem even if average worker pay increases. We need to increase worker pay, but we also need to end class inequality, even if the latter does not deliver on the former.
- gruez 2y ago>I'd rather see my CEO's excess compensation set on fire and delivered to no one rather than enrich him further. Isn't this just crab-bucket attitude? It's one thing to argue "profits should be redistributed more fairly". It's a whole different thing to argue "excess compensation set on fire".
- anticorporate 2y agoOnly if you don't believe that extreme wealth causes harm.
- silverquiet 2y agoIf the crabs work together, they may be able to get out of the bucket, but they're never climbing to the moon. I believe a few billionaires are in fact planning a visit to the moon shortly though.
- twobitshifter 2y agoThe article argues that stock buybacks are used to inflate ceo compensation and the value of those buybacks could be used to meaningfully increase worker wages.