3 ms·
I find it fascinating that Google is more than a decade old already and yet nobody has been able to completely copy all of their major innovations.
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
I find it fascinating that Google is more than a decade old already and yet nobody has been able to completely copy all of their major innovations.
- sp332 14y agoWhat "major innovation" did Google have 10 years ago that hasn't been copied?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoOK, so, if you look at what has set google apart you see three different things. Hardcore CS savvy is one of them, which led to pagerank. Then you have solid software engineering talent which led to the implementation of pagerank through map reduce and sharding. And combined with that you have revolutionarily different data centers. To google a data center is a single unit at many levels (application level, servicing level, manufacturing). Google manufactures what are arguably single data center sized computers, and makes the software to run on it. This sort of vertical integration is a huge advantage to google, because it gives them a huge quality/price/performance benefit, allowing them to leverage CPU cycle more effectively, more efficiently, and more inexpensively than their competition. Can you come up with an example of a company that scales the same way that google does to the same degree?
- sp332 14y agoOf course there are lots of other search engines that use pagerank. Sharding is of course nothing new. Map-reduce is a smart way to increase throughput of a cluster, but it's not unique (after all there is a popular open-source Hadoop project). I'll give you the data center advances though :)
- InclinedPlane 14y agoExactly, there are a lot of bits and pieces duplicating things that google did in the late 90s but there's nobody out there who's doing all those things at once. Which is surprising because there are huge business advantages to doing so. But it requires a level of execution that only google has been able to pull off so far. Edit: on the one hand it's an impressive achievement on google's part and a testament to their exceptional competence. On the other hand it's a bit disappointing because it means that google is that much harder to compete with and diversity in the marketplace is always a good thing (no matter how benevolent the rule of the monopolist of the moment might be).
- Hominem 14y agoI think many would argue that their shipping container full of motherboards style data centers may have hampered them when it came to an IaaS offering. They didn't leverage VM technology at all did they? That certainly created a bias that led them to GAE. Amazon, Facebook and Microsoft certainly must be operating datacenters on a massive scale and sophistication. They are probably more traditional thus less interesting to tech writers.