4 ms·
Health is very different from other services, profit should not be the goal. Business does not attempt to help people, but to maximize profit, which does not n
by gnaritas 18y ago
Health is very different from other services, profit should not be the goal. Business does not attempt to help people, but to maximize profit, which does not necessarily mean increasing availability or lowering prices at all. It might be more profitable to dump the lower income people and jack up the prices on those who can afford it.
Unlike other industries, getting service is often a literal life or death issue, you have to pay or you might die; morally this makes health care very different from other industries.
- jmtulloss 18y agoI agree with you, but it's not that black and white. Insurance companies are usually the ones paying, not the individual. As such, they have a lot of control over the price (especially in the case of medicare). While it might be life or death for the individual, it's not for the insurance company.
- gnaritas 18y agoWhich is a big part of the problem, we've put an entity between doctor and patient who's motive is profit rather than helping the patient. Insurance companies figured out a long time ago that the best way to profit was to deny claims and avoid paying in any way they can. An entire sub-industry has popped up around coding claims correctly because doctors have figured out what they can and can't get paid for, the effect being the insurance companies now basically dictate treatments rather than the doctor. Frankly it's extremely fucked up and it's caused entirely by companies seeing the most profit.
- jmtulloss 18y agoCan't argue with that.
- benl 18y agoProfit is the world's way of signaling that you are doing something in an efficient, effective, and long-term sustainable way. So, given that health care is one of the most fundamental individual needs, profit most definitely should be the goal. But health care is not the most fundamental need -- that would be food. I find it puzzling that people don't apply the same arguement to this need. Why not say that profit shouldn't be the goal of the food industry? And that supermarkets are immoral for making a profit at the expense of hungry people? Well, because it's clearly nonsense, of course. But I wonder if it would seem like nonsense if we lived in a world where there was no free market in food supply. We might worry that greedy corporations would only be interested in serving expensive foods to rich people.
- gnaritas 18y agoThe problem with that viewpoint is it assumes people are inherently good; they aren't. When profit is the goal, people suffer. I find the idea that seeking profit automatically creates the best good rather naive and idealistic. Of course people don't apply the same argument to food, food isn't scarce for most of us and few have problems acquiring it and the ability to produce it can't be easily collected in the hands of a few, anyone can grow their own food. Anyone cannot operate on themselves and perform some life saving operation, and while those who can certainly deserve to be compensated greatly for that ability they walk a fine moral line knowing their product, or the refusal to provide it, will directly kill people. Doctors are much more like firemen and policeman that businessman. Society has certain expectations of them serving the greater good of the community and helping people when they're in need. The free market is not the cure for every ill and seeking profit is not, and should not be the goal of every job. Greed is not some inherently good moral trait.
- pelle 18y agoIn almost all cases profit helps us all. A free exchange benefits all parties. You have something I want, I have something you want. When this situation gets distorted through monopoly or other forms of regulations it is generally speaking bad for everyone. Greed is good. My greed is good for you and your greed is good for me. This is the most fundamental philosophy of entrepreneurship albeit said using a word most people through years of indoctrination think is bad. This is also why I don't like the term social entrepreneurship. Any entrepreneurship that isn't kept a live through some sort of corruption or force is good for society as a whole.
- gnaritas 18y agoThe world isn't that simple and by the way, monopoly is a natural outcome in a free market system exactly because it doesn't always work. It breaks down, that's why we regulate it. The only place the free market actually works is in libertarians imaginations because they think Atlas Shrugged somehow reflects reality.
- pelle 18y agoHealth is no different than other services in 99.9% of the cases. We should not optimize the entire system for that 0.1% of cases. The market optimizes everything for the better if it is allowed. For the exceptions, use exception handling also known as charities such as non profit hospitals and health centers who already donate health care to the poor. The increased efficiency and lower cost of a non regulated approach would benefit all and make it easier and cheaper to provide good care to everyone.
- gnaritas 18y ago> The market optimizes everything for the better if it is allowed. Baloney. This is a belief, not a fact.
- pelle 18y agoIt is a fact that any transaction between two people that is not distorted in any way by outside parties will leave both parties better off.
- gnaritas 18y agoNo, it isn't. You're making the huge assumption that both parties are equal in the exchange and one party isn't using force on the other. Again, typical libertarian fantasy assumes everyone is nice, wake up, they aren't.
- dk 18y agoIt doesn't require anything you name here except the absence of force. No libertarian thinks or assumes everyone must be nice and no libertarian thinker has ever predicated his argument on such. You know, there actually have been some highly intelligent and thoughtful libertarian thinkers, far from whatever fantasy you may have.
- sfk 18y ago> The market optimizes everything for the better if it is allowed. Such as financial products? I think we have enough evidence right now that people are not mature enough for a totally free market.